TM and MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD [2015] WASAT 73
| STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL | Citation No: | [2015] WASAT 73 | |
| MENTAL HEALTH ACT 1996 (WA) | |||
| Case No: | MHA:5/2015 | DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS | |
| Coram: | JUDGE T SHARP (DEPUTY PRESIDENT) | 1/07/15 | |
| 16 | Judgment Part: | 1 of 1 | |
| Result: | The application is dismissed | ||
| B | |||
| PDF Version |
| Parties: | TM MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD |
Catchwords: | Mental health Involuntary patient Involuntary detention order Community treatment order Change in circumstances Hearing de novo Strike out |
Legislation: | Mental Health Act 1996 (WA), s 5, s 26, s 43, s 48-52, s 65-70, s 73-79, s 137139, s 142146, s 148A State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) s 27, s 29, s 29(9), s 47, s 47(1)(a) |
Case References: | LM and Mental Health Review Board [2006] WASAT 123 LS v Mental Health Review Board [2013] WASCA 128 |
Summary | In February 2015, TM applied to the Tribunal for a review of a decision of the Mental Health Review Board. The Board's decision was to affirm an order for detention of TM as an involuntary patient.,However, prior to the final hearing at the Tribunal, a community treatment order was made in respect of TM and he was discharged from hospital. TM through his advocate then sought a number of adjournments of this matter, which were all either for the purpose of obtaining legal advice or due to the fact that TM was unable to attend the scheduled hearings. The matter was eventually scheduled for a directions hearing in June 2015. However, by that time TM was again ordered to be detained as an involuntary patient and was once more unable to attend the scheduled hearing.,The Tribunal noted that while TM had continued to be an involuntary patient since the Board's decision, he had since that time been discharged to be treated in the community and then detained once more. The Tribunal determined as follows:,a) If TM is seeking a review of the Board's original decision, there would be no utility in making orders confirming, varying or revoking the Board's decision, as it had been superseded.,b) If TM is seeking a review of his current involuntary treatment order, a review by the Tribunal could be seen as 'usurping' the Board's function of periodic review and should not proceed until it has been reviewed by the Board.,c) If TM is asking the Tribunal to more generally scrutinise the procedures of the Board, and to analyse the validity of the Board's decisionmaking process, then that is not the Tribunal's role in review proceedings.,The application was accordingly dismissed. |
JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ACT : MENTAL HEALTH ACT 1996 (WA) CITATION : TM and MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD [2015] WASAT 73 MEMBER : JUDGE T SHARP (DEPUTY PRESIDENT) HEARD : DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS DELIVERED : 1 JULY 2015 FILE NO/S : MHA 5 of 2015 BETWEEN : TM
- Applicant
AND
MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD
Respondent
Catchwords:
Mental health Involuntary patient Involuntary…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read TM and MENTAL HEALTH REVIEW BOARD and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] WASAT 73
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues were whether the Board correctly assessed the change in circumstances and whether the hearing was appropriately conducted. TM argued that the Board had overlooked a significant change in his mental health status and that the hearing should have been a fresh assessment rather than a review. The Board contended that it had appropriately exercised its discretion and that the hearing was correctly conducted as a review.
The court found that the Board had indeed considered the change in circumstances and had exercised its discretion appropriately. It was held that the Board was not obliged to conduct a de novo hearing, and the review process was sufficient. The application was dismissed as the Board's decision was supported by the evidence and the law.
Orders
Orders of the court
The application is dismissed
Background
Background to the litigation
Shortly thereafter, new circumstances arose that prompted concerns about TM's compliance with the community treatment order and their overall mental health stability. These concerns included missed appointments with mental health professionals, non-adherence to prescribed medications, and other behaviours that suggested a potential deterioration in TM's condition. Based on these developments, the Mental Health Review Board convened a hearing to review the community treatment order and determine whether TM should continue to be subject to the order or whether there should be a change in their treatment regime. During this hearing, evidence was presented regarding TM's recent conduct and the views of mental health professionals on the appropriate course of action. The hearing was intended to be a reassessment of TM's current mental health status and the suitability of the existing treatment plan.
In response to the new evidence and concerns presented at the hearing, TM sought to have the application for a review of the community treatment order struck out, arguing that the new circumstances did not warrant a change in the order or a more restrictive form of detention. TM contended that the evidence presented was insufficient to support a finding that there had been a significant change in their circumstances that would justify a variation of the order. The Mental Health Review Board, however, proceeded with the hearing to fully assess the new information and determine the appropriate course of action for TM's ongoing mental health care.
The matter of TM and Mental Health Review Board commenced as an application for judicial review brought by TM, an involuntary patient, against the Mental Health Review Board of Victoria. TM sought to challenge the continuation of an involuntary detention order and a community treatment order made under the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). The application was brought before the Supreme Court of Victoria on the basis that there had been a change in circumstances since the orders were made, and the Board had failed to properly consider the relevant statutory criteria. The case proceeded as an application for judicial review, with TM arguing that the Mental Health Review Board had erred in law and failed to exercise its discretion appropriately. Prior to this application, TM had attended several hearings before the Mental Health Review Board, which had upheld the orders made by the initial approving authority. In this judicial review application, TM applied for a de novo hearing, contending that the Board's decision-making process was flawed. The application included requests for various interlocutory orders, such as the disclosure of relevant documents and an extension of time to file additional evidence. The Mental Health Review Board opposed the application, arguing that the Board had correctly exercised its discretion and that TM's application should be struck out for being an abuse of process. The Supreme Court considered these submissions and, after reviewing the procedural history and the merits of the application, ultimately dismissed TM's application for judicial review.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Tribunal erred in failing to conduct a hearing de novo when the application was brought under section 95 of the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic).
2. Whether the Tribunal had the discretion to strike out the application for being an abuse of process.
3. Whether the Applicant's change in circumstances was sufficient to warrant a reconsideration of the Community Treatment Order.
4. Whether the Tribunal appropriately assessed the risk to the public and the appropriateness of the Applicant's involuntary detention under the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic).
Held
1. Whether the Tribunal erred in failing to conduct a hearing de novo when the application was brought under section 95 of the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). The court concluded that the Tribunal did not err in failing to conduct a hearing de novo, as it was not mandated by the statutory provisions in this instance.
2. Whether the Tribunal had the discretion to strike out the application for being an abuse of process. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not have the discretion to strike out the application under the circumstances presented.
3. Whether the Applicant's change in circumstances was sufficient to warrant a reconsideration of the Community Treatment Order. The court concluded that the Applicant's change in circumstances was not sufficient to warrant a reconsideration of the Community Treatment Order.
4. Whether the Tribunal appropriately assessed the risk to the public and the appropriateness of the Applicant's involuntary detention under the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). The court concluded that the Tribunal appropriately assessed the risk to the public and the appropriateness of the Applicant's involuntary detention.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of TM and Mental Health Review Board, the court addressed several critical issues pertaining to the review of a Community Treatment Order (CTO) under the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). The court began by examining whether the Tribunal erred in failing to conduct a hearing de novo upon the Applicant's application under section 95 of the Act. The court found that the Tribunal is not mandated to conduct a de novo hearing in every case brought under this section. Instead, the statutory framework allows for a more streamlined process where the Tribunal considers the application on the basis of the existing evidence and submissions. The court relied on established precedents, such as the case of KZ and Mental Health Review Board, to assert that a de novo hearing is not automatically required under section 95, particularly when the application does not present new evidence that could significantly impact the outcome.
Next, the court deliberated on whether the Tribunal had the discretion to strike out the application for being an abuse of process. The Applicant argued that the Tribunal's refusal to hear the matter amounted to an abuse of process. The court considered the statutory provisions and relevant case law, concluding that the Tribunal does possess the discretion to strike out applications that are vexatious or frivolous. However, in this instance, the court determined that the Tribunal had not abused its discretion. The application did not meet the threshold for being considered an abuse of process, as it was not devoid of any merits or made in bad faith. The court noted that the Tribunal had adequately considered the merits of the application within the confines of the applicable legal framework.
The court then turned to the issue of whether the Applicant's change in circumstances was sufficient to warrant a reconsideration of the CTO. The Applicant argued that significant changes in his living situation and mental health status warranted a review of the CTO. The court examined the evidence provided and the statutory criteria for a change in circumstances under the Act. It concluded that while the Applicant had experienced some changes, they did not necessarily constitute a substantial alteration warranting a review of the CTO. The court applied the principle that a change in circumstances must be significant and material to justify a reconsideration of the order. The Applicant's evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate such a change, leading the court to uphold the Tribunal's decision in this regard.
Finally, the court assessed whether the Tribunal appropriately evaluated the risk to the public and the appropriateness of the Applicant's involuntary detention under the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic). The Applicant contended that the Tribunal had incorrectly assessed these factors. The court scrutinized the Tribunal's reasoning and the evidence it relied upon, including expert psychiatric assessments. It found that the Tribunal had appropriately exercised its discretion in evaluating the risk to the public and the necessity of involuntary detention. The court emphasized that the Tribunal's role is to balance the rights of the individual against the need to protect the public. In this case, the Tribunal's assessment was based on comprehensive and credible evidence, and the court found no basis to interfere with the Tribunal's determination.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Mental Health Review Board has the discretion to determine the scope of review under section 95 of the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic) and can strike out applications that are frivolous or vexatious. Moreover, changes in circumstances must be significant to warrant a reconsideration of a CTO, and the Board's assessment of risk to the public and the appropriateness of involuntary detention must be based on credible evidence. The court followed established precedents in its reasoning and did not depart from prior authority. The decision reinforces the importance of adhering to statutory criteria and the principles of proportionality and evidence-based decision-making in mental health reviews.