TKFR and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

TKFR and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2022] AATA 3341 (13 October 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:2021/2967         

Re:TKFR  

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndJGXG

OTHER PARTY

Decision

Tribunal:Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

Date:13 October 2022

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision, being the AAT1 Decision dated 23 March 2021, is set aside and is substituted with the new decision that:

(a)       the Existing Care Determination is revoked;

(b)new care determinations are made that the Mother had 100% care and the Father had 0% care of the child from 5 December 2019;

(c)the date of effect of the revocation of the Existing Care Determination is 20 April 2020.

..............[Sgd]..........................................................

Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care decision – whether there was a change in care – dispute about percentage of care – Tribunal satisfied there was a change in care – existing care determination revoked – new care determinations made – Mother notified Agency more than 28 days after the date of the change of care – date of effect of revocation – practical effect of this decision is that the Objection Decision is upheld – AAT1 decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) ss 49, 50, 54A, 54F, 54F(3)(b)(i), 54G, 55C

Cases

Parent A and Child Support Registrar and Anor [2013] AATA 562

Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959

Secondary Materials

Guides to Social Policy: Child Support Guide [2.2.1]

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

13 October 2022

background

  1. The Father (JGXG) and the Mother (TKFR) are the separated parents of a minor child, A, born on 3 February 2017.

  2. There is a dispute between the Father and the Mother regarding the percentage of care provided to A from 5 December 2019.

  3. From 7 November 2019, the child support assessment was based upon the Mother having 86% care and the Father having 14% care of A (T9/64). I will refer to this as the Existing Care Determination.

    Advice of a change in care

  4. On 21 April 2020, the Mother notified the Child Support Agency (Agency) that she had 100% care of A from 5 December 2019 (T19/88-89).

  5. On 29 April 2020, the Agency wrote to the Father to state that the Mother had advised them that the care percentages for A had changed and to contact the Agency to discuss these changes (T20/92). However, post-hearing submissions and evidence confirmed that the letter received by the Father was blank (see also T35/124).

  6. The Agency unsuccessfully tried to contact the Father by telephone to confirm the change in care on 15 May 2020…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TKFR and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 3341
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review of a child support second review decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The parties involved were the Mother and the Child Support Registrar, with the Father's care arrangements for the child, A, being the central point of contention. The dispute arose from differing claims regarding the percentage of care each parent provided for A, which directly impacts child support assessments.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether there had been a change in the pattern of care for A on or before 5 December 2019, necessitating the revocation of existing care determinations and the making of new ones. If a change in care was established, the Tribunal also had to determine the effective date for these new percentage of care determinations.

The Tribunal found the Mother's evidence to be more reliable and persuasive, supported by corroborating documentary evidence from third parties, including a work colleague, a friend, and the child's former husband. This evidence suggested the Father had minimal, if any, contact with A, and that the Mother was the sole carer. The Tribunal considered the factors outlined in *Polec & Staker & Anor* [2011] FMCAfam 959, which guide the determination of care, and concluded that the Mother bore the responsibility for A's accommodation, food, childcare, education, health care, emotional support, supervision, transport, and financial support. The Tribunal was not persuaded that the Father had the claimed 14% care, finding instead that the Mother had 100% care and the Father had 0% care.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the previous AAT decision. It found that there was a change in care on or before 5 December 2019, and substituted new care determinations reflecting 100% care for the Mother and 0% care for the Father. The practical effect of this decision was to uphold the Mother's objection.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Mother’s evidence was corroborated by other documentary evidence, which I will now summarise:(a)A letter from a work colleague, N, dated 19 August 2020, confirmed that N had witnessed the Mother having to bring A to work because the Father was unable to look after him. N also stated that she had witnessed the Father dropping A off earlier than arranged before the Mother’s work shift ended, and that the Mother had to make alternative care arrangements for A (T43). (b)The Mother’s friend, Z, stated that for the last three years she had assisted the Mother to babysit A when the Mother was at work. She stated that since A’s birth she had observed that the Father was “barely there” and that the Mother would often ask her to babysit at the last minute because the Father had failed to pick the child up at the agreed time. She stated that if the Father did babysit A, he would only do so for a maximum of three hours. Z further stated that “at times” the Father had dropped A off at her house “halfway through the day without a good excuse” when he had agreed to care for the child for the whole day (T53/164). (c)In an undated letter, the Mother’s former husband, E, who is the father of her eldest son and whom she is on good terms with, stated that he had been assisting to look after A when she was at work, and that he “never saw A’s father picking him up or bringing him anything” (T55/166). (d)A screenshot of text messages between the Mother and the Father received by the Agency on 19 August 2020 shows a bank payment confirmation for $50 paid to the Father on 6 June 2020 with the description “child care” (T44). This supports the Mother’s evidence that she paid the Father to have the child overnight on two occasions. (e)An email letter dated 30 November 2021 from the Director and owner of A’s early learning centre confirms that A has attended the centre since 12 February 2020, one to four days per week and that the Mother brings him to the centre and picks him up. She confirmed that she has never met the Father (A1). Another letter from A’s kindergarten teacher, D, dated 1 December 2021, states that she has been A’s teacher in 2021 and that it was only the Mother, A’s older brother, and the parent’s of a kindergarten friend of A’s, who were authorised to collect him from school (A1). It is most unlikely that a parent who has care of a child for up to three nights per week, as the Father has claimed, would never have dropped off or picked up the child from kindergarten or his early learning centre. This evidence supports the Mother’s evidence that the Father has minimal, if any, contact with A and that she is the sole carer of the child. The Father’s evidence The Father said that he moved out of the house he shared with the Mother and A in approximately March 2019. He stated that he had no contact with A until he moved into his own place in approximately June 2019. From December 2019, the Father stated that he cared for A “three days, two days, four days” for “five, six hours” or “a full 24 hours”, sometimes at short notice, and sometimes when the Mother had to work.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 23 March 2021, the AAT1 decided that there was no change in care of A on 5 December 2019; and did not revoke the existing percentages of care for A of 14% for the Father, and 86% for the Mother (T2). The AAT1 decision is the Reviewable Decision. AAT2 proceedings On 6 May 2021, the Mother lodged an application seeking review of the Reviewable Decision (T1) in the General Division of this Tribunal (AAT2). The hearing of this application was on 5 April 2022. The Tribunal could not contact the Father and after numerous attempts proceeded without him. The Father subsequently contacted the Tribunal and the hearing was resumed on 2 May 2022 with both parties in attendance. At the second hearing on 2 May 2022, the Father stated that he had received blank letters from the Agency which affected his ability to object on time (transcript/35-36). I therefore directed for further submissions and evidence to be filed to confirm what had happened in this regard. As I have indicated above, it was only the letter of 29 April 2020 that was blank, which is of little consequence. the issue The issue before me is whether:(a)there was a change in the pattern of care for A on 5 December 2019 which required the Existing Care Determination to be revoked and new determinations to be made;(b)and if so, the date that the new percentage of care determinations should take effect. For the reasons set out below, I have accepted the Mother’s evidence that there was a change in care on or before 5 December 2019 whereby she had 100% care of A and the Father had 0% care of A. evidence of care percentagesThe Mother’s evidence The Mother’s evidence was that the Father stopped living with her and the child, A, on 25 March 2019. In October and November 2019, the Father would collect A approximately twice a week and take him to the shops to buy candy, the park or swimming for short periods of time. The Mother said that she and the Father agreed that the Father would have the child for two days including one night a week, but that the Father did not honour the agreement and would only take the child for short periods of time for one or two hours (A1). She further explained that there would be days and months where she could not communicate with the Father. The Mother said that the Father had A overnight on two occasions (she could not remember the dates) when she had shifts at work and that she paid the Father $50 on those occasions. She almost entirely disagreed with the Father’s list of dates between 8 December 2019 and 5 June 2020 where the Father claimed he had cared for A (T4). The Mother’s evidence was that the Father had not contributed financially to caring for the child, including buying clothes for him. According to the Mother, the Father has had very little involvement in A’s life, apart from a two month period when they lived together. She stated in an email dated 2 December 2021 that the Father had not seen the son for more than a year (A1). At the second hearing the Mother stated that the Father, “has never been responsible for the child” and that she “covered for him” by not informing the Agency of his lack of care earlier because she thought it was required for the Father’s visa requirements. She admitted becoming frustrated with the Father and texting him that she had informed the Agency of the truth of the days that she looks after A, and telling him that he was “in trouble”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I find that it is more likely that the Father only had care of the child, A, overnight on a couple of occasions, as shown in a photo taken on 11 April 2020 at 12.07am showing the child awake and dressed (T18/87) and another photo of A’s face taken on 2 May 2020 at 4.11am, showing that A was awake at that time (T21/93). The text messages produced by the Father (T52) are not specific enough to support the Father’s assertions of having care of A overnight for two to four days a week. They show communications between the Mother and the Father concerning dropping off and picking up the child on 8 December 2019, 10 December 2019, 18 and 19 December 2019, 23 and 24 December 2019, 26 December 2019, 14 January 2020, 27 and 28 February 2020, 5 March 2020, 18 March 2020, 10 and 11 April 2020, 25 April 2020, 26 May 2020, and 5 June 2020. They tend to suggest some contact, but it is often unclear how long for and whether that contact eventuated. I also note an email from the Father to the Tribunal’s Registry on 24 November 2020 (T51) where he states that he last saw his son on 6 June 2020 and that he had not seen his son for six months. consideration Overall, I find the Mother’s evidence, which is supported by the evidence from third persons, to be more reliable and persuasive. The evidence supports a finding that the Mother had 100% care of A. I am not persuaded that the Father had 14% care of A. The Father appears to have minimal, if any, contact with the child. Any contact appears to be unreliable and brief with the Father expending minimal, if any, money on the child, including being paid by the Mother to have him overnight on two occasions. The evidence suggests he had less than 14% care, which would reduce his cost percentage to nil (s 55C of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (Assessment Act). Although the number of nights a child spends with a parent is the primary measure of care, (s 54A of the Assessment Act), the factors in Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959 (which are reproduced in the Child Support Guide at paragraph [2.2.1]) provide further guidance for determining whether and to what extent a person has care of a child. These include:· To what extent the person has control of the child, including having overall responsibility for the child and makingo major decisions relating to who the child spends time with and the child's health, education, discipline, recreational and/or social activities, ando arrangements for others to meet the needs of the child (delegated care).· To what extent the person meets the needs of the child by providing the child with accommodation, clothing, food, child care, education, health care, emotional support, supervision, transport and extra-curricular activities.· To what extent the person pays for the costs of meeting the needs of the child.· To what extent the person otherwise provides financial support for the child.… I do not have evidence regarding the first factor, namely the making of major decisions concerning the child’s health, and so on. However, the evidence before me tends to suggest that the Mother made arrangements concerning delegated care, that the Mother provided the child with accommodation, clothing, food, childcare, emotional support and supervision, and that she paid the costs of meeting the needs of the child and otherwise financially supported the child.