TJ v Public Trustee of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

TJ v Public Trustee of Queensland & Anor [2022] QCATA 189

PARTIES:

TJ
(applicant/appellant)

v

PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND
CRG

(respondents)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL149-20

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

GAA611-16 Applicaton for Directions

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

28 November 2022

HEARING DATE:

9 September 2021

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Guthrie

ORDERS:

1.   The oral application for leave to appeal is granted.

2.   THE APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO RELY UPON FRESH EVIDENCE IS DISMISSED.

3.   The application to appeal is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – RIGHT OF APPEAL – where decision made to dismiss an application for compensation under the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) -
where applicant claims member made errors of law – where appeal tribunal dismissed appeal

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – ADMISSION OF FURTHER EVIDENCE – EVIDENCE NOT AVAILABLE AT HEARING – where applicant seeks to rely on publicly available report – where application to rely on fresh evidence refused

Guardianship and Administration Act 2000, s 33, s 34, s 35, s 36, s 59, s 125, s 130, s 155, Schedule 1
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009, s 142(1), s 142(3)(b)
Trusts Act 1973, s 24

Cachia v Grech [2009] NSWCA 232 at [13].
CRG [2020] QCAT 153.
CRG [2019] QCAT 168.
Ebner v The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 205 CLR 337.
Glenwood Properties Pty Ltd v Delmoss PtyLtd [1986] 2 Qd R 388.
Maffey v Mueller [2016] QCATA 19.
McIver Bulk Liquid Haulage Pty Ltd v Fruehauf Australia Pty Ltd [1989] 2 Qd R 577.
QUYD Pty Ltd v Marvass Pty Ltd [2009] 1 Qd R 41.
Thang Long Pty Ltd v CTS Sunstate Group Pty Ltd [2022] QCATA 18.

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondents:

R Whiteford, Official Solicitor to the Public Trustee of Queensland

M Jones of Counsel appointed to represent CRG

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. TJ was appointed by the Tribunal as an administrator for CRG on 26 April 2016 replacing the Public Trustee of Queensland (the Public Trustee).

  2. On 12 May 2020, the learned member of the Tribunal decided to dismiss TJ’s application for an order that, pursuant to s 59 of the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (‘the GAA Act’), compensation be paid to CRG by the Public Trustee.[1] TJ appeals that decision.

  3. The decision followed the same member’s earlier decision on 6 June 2019, that the Public Trustee should compensate CRG in a particular sum, for its failure to comply with the GAA Act in the exercise of a power. At the same time, the learned member dismissed the claim brought against the Public Guardian (‘the compensation decision’).[2] That decision was not the subject of an appeal. In the appeal, TJ relies, to some extent, on the reasons the learned member gave for the compensation decision.

  4. On 10 September 2020 the Appeal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TJ v Public Trustee of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCATA 189
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in TJ v Public Trustee of Queensland involved a challenge by TJ to a decision made by a tribunal to dismiss an application for compensation under the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld). The central issue was whether the tribunal erred in dismissing the appeal and if TJ was entitled to rely on new evidence in the appeal. TJ argued that the tribunal member had made assumptions that demonstrated racial bias and lacked cultural competence, and sought to introduce a publicly available report as fresh evidence to support their appeal.

The tribunal considered the importance of the appeal and granted leave for TJ to appeal the tribunal's decision. However, regarding the application to adduce new evidence, the tribunal found that the fresh evidence sought by TJ was not reasonably unavailable at the time of the trial and did not meet the strict test for admission. The tribunal dismissed the application for leave to rely upon fresh evidence.

Ultimately, the tribunal dismissed the application to appeal, finding that the appeal did not have sufficient merit to warrant a full hearing. The tribunal emphasised the importance of the finality of litigation and the need to balance this against the public interest in ensuring just outcomes in individual cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The oral application for leave to appeal is granted.

2. THE APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO RELY UPON FRESH EVIDENCE IS DISMISSED.

3. The application to appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing, TJ submitted that the learned member had erred by making assumptions he was not culturally competent to make and those assumptions demonstrated racial bias. I have dealt with that submission as a separate ground of appeal. Background decisions TJ relies on a number of previous decisions made by the GAAT and this Tribunal concerning CRG. I consider it useful to summarise those decisions at the outset. By Supreme Court Order dated 21 December 2000, the Public Trustee was appointed administrator for CRG to manage a settlement sum. On 28 November 2002, the GAAT changed the appointment of the administrator for CRG by removing the Public Trustee and appointing CRG’s mother and his aunt jointly (the joint administrators) for all financial matters for a period of five years. The GAAT also made a number of directions including, relevantly, that the joint administrators provide an updated financial management plan within three months of the purchase in CRG’s name of any land. Annual accounts were also directed. In the appeal, TJ specifically relies on the reasons expressed by the GAAT for that decision, in particular, the following paragraphs: The Tribunal has had evidence of [CRG’s mother] and [aunt’s] cultural appropriateness as blood-line elders and accepts this evidence. The Tribunal also accepts Dr Field’s statement in her report that “[CRG] is very dependent on his mother”. An examination of the medical reports which were submitted in support of this application for review also reveals [CRG’s mother’s] advocacy and support for [CRG] over an extensive period of time.[6]The Tribunal does recognise the importance of the ownership of land to aboriginal people and also acknowledges that appropriate decision in relation to the purchase of a property for [CRG] has been delayed due to the conflict between [CRG’s mother] and the [Public Trustee].[7]It is also clear that the possession of a large fund of money by the [Public Trustee] for [CRG] has not improved his quality of life and in fact his quality of life has deteriorated to the extent that he now leads an itinerant lifestyle and is sniffing inhalants.[8]In deciding who is the most appropriate administrator the Tribunal believes that after a consideration of these [General] Principles the proposed administrators … are more likely to maintain the adult’s cultural and linguistic ties, maintain his existing supportive relationships and encourage self-reliance than the exiting administrators.[9][6]GAAT reasons for decision dated 28 November 2002, [28].[7]GAAT reasons for decision dated 28 November 2002, [38].[8]GAAT reasons for decision dated 28 November 2002, [39].[9]GAAT reasons for decision dated 28 November 2002, [46]. The joint administrators purchased a bush retreat for CRG and later, on 22 July 2003, a unit at the Sunshine Coast. On 14 January 2005, the bush retreat was sold. Between the purchase of the properties and the sale of the unit in 2007, the Adult Guardian (as the office was then known) was appointed by the GAAT, during particular periods, to make decisions about where CRG lived. For the purposes of the appeal the parties do not dispute that the relevant periods for which the Adult Guardian was appointed to make such decisions was 22 December 2003 to 7 April 2004, and 7 February 2007 to 22 March 2007. CRG was incarcerated in late 2003 residing with his father as part of his bail conditions from 11 December 2003. Otherwise, it is agreed that CRG was presumed to have capacity to make his own decisions about where he lived.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I am prepared to accept that the matters raised by TJ in the appeal in relation to how the Public Trustee as administrator for CRG made decisions for CRG is a matter of general importance upon which a further argument and a decision of the Appellate Tribunal would be to public advantage. In particular, I accept that whether and the extent to which the General Principles in the GAA Act were applied by the Public Trustee in making decisions for CRG and how the Public Trustee as administrator balanced the application of the General Principles with the application of the prudent person rule in s 24 of the Trusts Act 1973 are matters of general importance upon which further argument and a decision of the Appeal Tribunal would be to public advantage. I have decided that to the extent necessary to hear and determine the appeal, TJ has leave to appeal. Application to adduce to new evidence TJ also seeks to adduce new evidence in the appeal. TJ had initially sought to rely on a Brisbane Property Market Update dated 2 September 2021 published by Smart Property Investment citing Hedonic Home Value Index data by Corelogic released on 31 August 2021 (‘the Property Market Update’). However, at the hearing agreed that reliance on such information was premature given that the learned member below did not deal with remedy and foreshadowed further directions for the provision of relevant evidence and submissions should that become necessary[19]. I consider that concession appropriate.[19]Directions of the Tribunal made 24 February 2020 and see [4] of these reasons. The other ‘new evidence’ TJ seeks leave to adduce in the appeal is the document entitled ‘Preserving the financial futures of vulnerable Queenslanders – A review of Public Trustee fees, charges and practices’ published by the Public Advocate in January 2021 (‘the Public Advocate report’). That document is a publicly available. In Thang Long Pty Ltd v CTS Sunstate Group Pty Ltd[20] the Appeal Tribunal had this to say in relation to applications to adduce new or fresh evidence:[21]Permission to introduce post-trial evidence is not given lightly. Finality of litigation is a firm policy of the law, particularly in tribunals where the legislature expects proceedings to be relatively simple and expeditious. Indeed the legislative purpose of the QCAT Act’s leave-to-appeal provision is to ensure the primary decision will normally be final. …In the interests of finality the law sets a strict test for the admission of ‘new’ or ‘fresh’ evidence. The material in question must be evidence not reasonably available to the applicant at the time of the trial; it must be credible, and, if accepted, likely to have a substantial effect on the result. [20][2022] QCATA 18.[21]Ibid at [11] and [12]. TJ wishes to rely on the Public Advocate report to the extent that it summarises and comments on decisions of the Tribunal, including in its appeal jurisdiction which TJ says are decisions that were made in relation to historical applications made concerning CRG. The Public Trustee says those decisions are not relevant in the appeal and the Public Advocate’s summary of, or comments about them, are irrelevant.[22] [22]Public Trustee’s submissions in response to fresh evidence applications dated 13 April 2021 at [6] (IN007).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established