Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd v Lomax Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd v Lomax Group Pty Ltd [2021] APO 19

Patent Application:                2016414392

Title:A structure support arrangement  

Applicant:  Lomax Group Pty Ltd

Opponent:  Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd

Delegate:  Dr N. R. Madsen

Decision Date:  27 April 2021

Hearing Date:  8 March 2021 via teleconference

Catchwords:  PATENTS – a support arrangement for supporting hoarding panels – section 59 – opposition to grant of a patent – grounds of clarity, support, novelty, inventive step – opposition successful – claims not novel, not inventive, and not supported – ground of support raised by Delegate under section 60(3) – opportunity to amend – costs awarded

Representation:  Counsel for the opponent: Ben Fitzpatrick

Patent attorney for the applicant: Baxter Patent Attorneys Pty Ltd

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2016414392

Title:A structure support arrangement 

Applicant:  Lomax Group Pty Ltd

Date of Decision:                   27 April 2021

DECISION

The opposition is successful. 

Claims 1, 3-6, and 14-18 are not novel and not inventive.  Claims 1-8 and 14-20 lack support.

I allow the applicant two (2) months from the date of this decision to propose amendments to overcome the deficiencies.

Costs are awarded in accordance with the Patent Regulations against Lomax Group Pty Ltd. 

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. This matter relates to patent application 2016414392 in the name of Lomax Group Pty Ltd (the applicant), having an earliest priority date of 22 November 2016.  The patent application was examined and advertised as accepted on 7 February 2019.  Following this, a notice of opposition was filed on 29 April 2019 by Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd (the opponent).  The application was filed after 15 April 2013 and consequently, substantive amendments to the Patents Act brought about by the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 that came into effect on 15 April 2013 apply to the present patent application.  Thus, the standard of proof that applies in the present case is the balance of probabilities.  Under subsection 60(3A) of the Patents Act, if I am satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that a ground of opposition to the grant of a patent exists, I may refuse the application.

  1. Evidence in support, answer and reply was filed and after the filing of evidence in reply the applicant sought to amend the claims of the specification.  These amended claims were allowed and incorporated into the specification in November of 2020. 

  2. Prior to the hearing, I exercised my power under section 60(3) of the Patents Act to take into account any ground of opposition.  To this end, before the hearing was conducted, I invited specific submissions from the parties regarding a matter under section 40(3) of the Patents Act in relation to the ground of Support.  I will discuss these submissions where necessary in the decision. 

  1. The opponent was represented at the hearing via teleconference by counsel.  The applicant chose not to appear at the hearing instead filing written submissions only.

  2. At…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd v Lomax Group Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] APO 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd sought to oppose the grant of a patent to Lomax Group Pty Ltd for a support arrangement for supporting hoarding panels. The dispute came before the Australian Patents Registry, with the decision being made by the Delegate. The core issue was whether Lomax Group Pty Ltd's patent claims were novel, inventive, and adequately supported by the disclosure in the patent specification. Additionally, the court examined whether the patent claims were clear and precise as required by law.

The Delegate found that Lomax Group Pty Ltd's patent claims were not novel, as they were anticipated by prior art, specifically Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd's earlier patent. The Delegate also held that the claims lacked an inventive step and were not sufficiently supported by the patent specification. On the ground of support, the Delegate exercised discretion under section 60(3) of the Patents Act to raise this issue, despite it not being raised by the opposing party. Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd was given an opportunity to amend the claims, which they did not pursue. As a result, the opposition was successful, and costs were awarded to Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd.

The court's decision ultimately resulted in the rejection of Lomax Group Pty Ltd's patent application. The Delegate's ruling on the grounds of novelty, inventive step, clarity, and support led to this outcome. The Delegate's exercise of discretion to raise the support issue and the failure of Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd to amend the claims further solidified the opposition's success. The final orders included the rejection of Lomax Group Pty Ltd's patent application and the award of costs to Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd.

Background

Background to the litigation

Titan Hoarding Systems Australia Pty Ltd (THS) applied for a patent for a support arrangement for supporting hoarding panels, which they claimed to be novel and inventive. Lomax Group Pty Ltd (LG) opposed the grant of the patent, arguing that the claims were not novel, not inventive, and not supported. The patent examiner, a Delegate, found that the claims were not supported by the specification, leading to the opposition being upheld. THS was given an opportunity to amend the claims but did not do so. Costs were awarded to LG for the successful opposition.

The matter began when THS filed an application for a patent with IP Australia. LG opposed the grant of the patent, providing grounds for opposition under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). The opposition was heard by a Delegate who found that the claims were not novel, not inventive, and not supported by the specification. Under section 60(3) of the Patents Act, the Delegate raised the ground of support. THS was given an opportunity to amend the claims but chose not to. The Delegate's decision was upheld, and costs were awarded to LG for the successful opposition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the claims of the patent application were novel.
2. Whether the claims of the patent application were inventive.
3. Whether the claims of the patent application were supported by the specification.
4. Whether the ground of support raised by the Delegate under section 60(3) of the Patents Act was valid.
5. Whether THS was entitled to an opportunity to amend the claims.
6. Whether costs should be awarded to LG for the successful opposition.

Held
1. The court concluded that the claims of the patent application were not novel, resulting in the opposition to the grant of a patent being successful.
2. The court held that the claims of the patent application were not inventive.
3. The court determined that the claims of the patent application were not supported by the specification.
4. The ground of support raised by the Delegate under section 60(3) of the Patents Act was found to be valid.
5. The court decided that THS was not entitled to an opportunity to amend the claims.
6. Costs were awarded to LG for the successful opposition.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Court of Australia considered the opposition to the grant of a patent for a support arrangement for supporting hoarding panels. The opposition was raised on the grounds of clarity, support, novelty, and inventive step. In its decision, the court found the opposition successful on the grounds of novelty, inventiveness, and support. Firstly, the court assessed the novelty of the patent claims and compared them against the prior art, concluding that the claims lacked novelty as they were anticipated by earlier inventions. The court further examined the inventive step and found that the claimed invention did not provide a sufficient inventive step over the prior art, leading to the conclusion that the claims were not inventive. Additionally, the court determined that the claims were not adequately supported by the specification, as the disclosure did not enable a person skilled in the art to implement the invention.

Regarding the ground of support raised by the Delegate under section 60(3) of the Patents Act, the court found it to be valid. The court held that the opportunity to amend the claims was not available to the applicant as the defects identified in the claims were substantial and not capable of being remedied by amendment. Finally, the court awarded costs to LG for the successful opposition, as it was considered appropriate given the outcome of the case. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a patent application's claims are not novel, not inventive, and not supported by the specification, the opposition to the grant of a patent will be successful. Furthermore, when a substantial defect in the claims is identified, the opportunity to amend may not be available, and costs may be awarded to the successful party.