Tirango Nominees Pty Ltd v Dairy Vale Foods Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Tirango Nominees Pty Ltd v Dairy Vale Foods Ltd [2000]
FCA 1524

TRADE PRACTICES – Alleged misleading conduct – Whether there was a representation as to projected gross profits – Spreadsheet of income produced by respondent during course of negotiations – Whether appellants relied on this document – Inadequacies of evidence concerning damage – Whether it was open to appellants to make a case on appeal that respondent had misled them as to allocation of product outlets – Cross-claim on guarantee – Whether rectification appropriate – Whether cross-claim covered by unrectified guarantee.

TIRANGO NOMINEES PTY LTD, PAMELA WILLIAMS (as Executrix of the Estate of the late Allen James Williams) and PAULINE ANNE STOCKMAN v DAIRY VALE FOODS LIMITED

S87 OF 1999

WILCOX, MOORE and KIEFEL JJ
SYDNEY (HEARD IN ADELAIDE)
30 OCTOBER 2000


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

S87 of 1999

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

TIRANGO NOMINEES PTY LTD, PAMELA WILLIAMS (as Executrix of the Estate of the late Allen James Williams) and PAULINE ANNE STOCKMAN
Appellants

AND:

DAIRY VALE FOODS LIMITED
Respondent

JUDGE:

WILCOX, MOORE and KIEFEL JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

30 OCTOBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (HEARD IN ADELAIDE)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The appellants, Tirango Nominees Pty Ltd, Pamela Williams (as executrix of the estate of the late Allen James Williams) and Pauline Anne Stockman, pay the costs of the appeal incurred by the respondent, Dairy Vale Foods Limited.

3.The order of Mansfield J dismissing the cross-claim against the second and third cross-respondents be set aside.

4.Judgment be entered in favour of the cross-claimant, Dairy Vale Foods Limited, against the cross-respondents, Pamela Williams (as executrix of the estate of the estate of the late Allen James Williams) and Pauline Anne Stockman, in the sum of $247,497.74.

5.The said cross-respondents pay the costs of the cross-appeal incurred by the said cross-claimant.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

S87 of 1999

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

TIRANGO NOMINEES PTY LTD, PAMELA WILLIAMS (as Executrix of the Estate of the late Allen James Williams) and PAULINE ANNE STOCKMAN
Appellants

AND:

DAIRY VALE FOODS LIMITED
Respondent

JUDGE:

WILCOX, MOORE and KIEFEL JJ

DATE:

30 OCTOBER 2000

PLACE:

ADELAIDE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. THE COURT:  There is before the Court both an appeal and a cross-appeal.

    The appeal

    (i)        General

  2. The appeal is brought by two applicants in the proceeding, Tirango Nominees Pty Ltd and Pauline Anne Stockman, and the executrix of a third applicant, the late Allen James Williams.    The appellants challenge the order of the trial judge, Mansfield J, dismissing the applicants’ claim against the respondent, Dairy Vale Foods Limited.

  3. At the hearing of the appeal, Tirango Nominees and Ms Stockman were represented by Mr P Bick QC and Ms M Loughnan.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tirango Nominees Pty Ltd v Dairy Vale Foods Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1524
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Tirango Nominees Pty Ltd v Dairy Vale Foods Ltd, the appellants, including Tirango Nominees and the executrices of the estates of Allen James Williams and Pauline Anne Stockman, challenged the trial judge's decision regarding a guarantee and indemnity document. The dispute centred on whether the court should rectify a reference in the guarantee to a non-existent clause in the Wholesale Vendor Agreement, and whether the cross-claim against the executrices was covered by the unrectified guarantee. The primary legal issue was whether the court could rectify the guarantee by substituting a reference to an existing clause in the Wholesale Vendor Agreement, despite the absence of evidence regarding the parties' actual intention.

The court held that an order for rectification requires cogent evidence of the parties' intention. Given the lack of such evidence in this case, the court agreed with the trial judge that it was inappropriate to order rectification. The court further held that even in the absence of evidence of actual intention, a court may sometimes be able to conclude that an error has been made and correct it by a process of construction, provided that it is clearly necessary to avoid absurdity or inconsistency. The court found that the circumstances did not warrant such a correction in this case.

The court dismissed the appeal, upheld the trial judge's decision to deny rectification and dismissed the cross-claim, and set aside the order dismissing the cross-claim against the executrices. The court entered judgment in favour of Dairy Vale Foods Limited against the executrices, ordering them to pay the costs of the cross-appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants, Tirango Nominees Pty Ltd, Pamela Williams (as executrix of the estate of the late Allen James Williams) and Pauline Anne Stockman, pay the costs of the appeal incurred by the respondent, Dairy Vale Foods Limited.

3. The order of Mansfield J dismissing the cross-claim against the second and third cross-respondents be set aside.

4. Judgment be entered in favour of the cross-claimant, Dairy Vale Foods Limited, against the cross-respondents, Pamela Williams (as executrix of the estate of the estate of the late Allen James Williams) and Pauline Anne Stockman, in the sum of $247,497.74.

5. The said cross-respondents pay the costs of the cross-appeal incurred by the said cross-claimant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Stockman and Mr Williams executed a document entitled “Guarantee and Indemnity” which was addressed to Dairy Vale and contained the following:“IN CONSIDERATION of Dairy Vale having agreed to enter into the annexed Agreement at my/our request I/we the Guarantor referred to in the Schedule hereto:1.HEREBY GUARANTEE the payment by the Vendor therein named to Dairy Vale and the due and punctual observance and performance by the said Vendor of the terms and conditions therein contained or implied on the part of the said Vendor to be observed and performed.2.AS a separate and severable covenant agree to indemnify Dairy Vale and keep it indemnified from and against all losses costs charges and expenses whatsoever that Dairy Vale may suffer or incur by reason of the failure or default of the said Vendor to observe and perform the terms and conditions and covenants therein contained or implied and on the part of the said Vendor to be observed and performed.3.As a separate and severable covenant we covenant and agree with Dairy Vale on the same terms and conditions as are contained in Clause 3.15 of the annexed Agreement as if reference to ‘the Vendor’ therein was a reference to ‘the Guarantor’.”As his Honour observed, the parties accepted that the “annexed agreement” was the Wholesale Vendor Agreement. That position was maintained on the appeal. At the trial, Dairy Vale relied primarily on clause 3. However, the Wholesale Vendor Agreement did not contain any clause 3.15. Clause 3 referred only to the term of the agreement and extended to four parts. The following clause, headed “Vendor’s Obligations”, did contain a clause 4.15 which concerned the liability of Tirango for the payment of products:“The Vendor shall make due and punctual payments for the Products to Dairy Vale in accordance with the trading terms.”Dairy Vale contended that the reference in clause 3 of the guarantee and indemnity to clause 3.15 of the Wholesale Vendor Agreement was a mutual mistake; the parties having intended to refer to clause 4.15. They sought an order to rectify clause 3 by substituting a reference to clause 4.15. However, counsel for Dairy Vale called no evidence as to their client’s intention and asked no questions of Mr Williams or Ms Stockman about the matter. Under those circumstances, Mansfield J was not prepared to infer that the parties intended clause 3 of the guarantee to refer to clause 4.15 of the main agreement. He refused an order for rectification and dismissed the cross-claim. Cogent evidence is required to justify an order for rectification: see Meagher, Gummow and Lehane ‘Equity Doctrines and Remedies’, third edition, para [2610] and the authorities there cited. Having regard to the absence of evidence in the present case, we respectfully agree with Mansfield J that it was not appropriate to order rectification. However, even if there is no evidence concerning the actual intention of the parties, a court may sometimes be able to conclude that an error has been made and to eliminate this by a process of construction: see Meagher, Gummow and Lehane at [2608]-[2609] and the cases there referred to Fitzgerald v Masters (1956) 95 CLR 420; Watson v Phipps (1985) 60 ALJR 1. The jurisdiction to correct obvious errors in documents, by a process of construction, does not permit any element of speculation. Whilst words may be “supplied, omitted or corrected” it is only where “…it is clearly necessary in order to avoid absurdity or inconsistency”: Fitzgerald v Masters, 426-7, but no further: Watson v Phipps, 3.