tr,
• "I
• ~
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Brisbane No B44 of 1990 B e t w e e n -
DR THUNG SING TIONG
Appellant
and
MINISTER FOR COMMUNITY
SERVICES AND HEALTH
Respondent
MASON CJ DAWSON J TOOHEY J GAUDRON J
McHUGH J.
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT BRISBANE ON TUESDAY, 25 JUNE 1991 AT 10.23 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
| Tiong(2) | 1 | 25/6/91 |
| MR W. SOFRONOFF, OC: | May it please the Court, I appear with |
my learned friend, MISS E.M. O'REILLY, for the
appellant. (instructed by Corrs Chambers
Westgarth)
MR R.W. GOTTERSON, OC: If it please the Court, I appear
with my learned friend, MRS D.A. MULLINS, for the
respondent. (instructed by Australian Government
Solicitor)
| MASON CJ: | Mr Sofronoff. |
| MR SOFRONOFF: | Your Honours, I hand up copies of our outline |
of submissions.
MASON CJ: Thank you.
| MR SOFRONOFF: | Your Honours, the Health Insurance Act, |
copies of which have been provided to Your Honours,
provides for a scheme by which, among other things,
excessive servicing can be investigated by
tribunals and committees. Can I give Your Honours an overview of the scheme before going to the Act a
little bit later on.
The scheme involves the referral by the Minister in the first instance of matters to a
committee. The committee has a preliminary look at those matters and considers whether it is worth
going on to have a hearing. If it considers that
it is worth going on to have a hearing it gives
notice of that to the practitioner concerned.
There is then a hearing; particulars are requiredto be given; the practitioner is entitled to be there and to examine.witnesses. At that hearing
then, the committee hears evidence in relation to
the particular services in question. At the end ofthe day it can recommend to the Minister that,
among other things, the practitioner be reprimanded
or be counselled and that the practitioner refund
any benefits that he might have received as a
consequence of over servicing. In the event of an adverse finding, the Minister then can make a determination.
The
determination is that he be reprimanded or
counselled as the case may be and that he refund
moneys. He has the right, the Minister, to gazette that determination and in this case he has already
said he is going to do that.
There are three available modes of review from an adverse finding.
Two are under the Health
Insurance Act and one is under the AD(JR) Act. The first is a rehearing de novo before a district court judge. The second is under the AD(JR) in appropriate cases. The third is by way of review
| Tiong(2) | 25/6/91 |
to a tribunal, a tribunal that has a rehearing on
the papers only, a tribunal that is precluded fromhearing new evidence, and that is what happened
here.
The examination here was concerned with not only the appellant but Dr S.J. Tiong as well.
The
appellant is an…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tiong v Minister for Community Services and Health and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1991] HCATrans 154
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the committee, in its investigation of the appellant's services, had examined sufficient evidence to make a meaningful recommendation, and whether the Minister's subsequent determination was valid. The appellant contended that the committee had not adequately considered all the services in question, particularly those referred to a radiologist, Dr S.J. Tiong, and that this failure rendered the committee's findings and the Minister's decision unlawful.
The court considered the scheme established by the Health Insurance Act for investigating excessive servicing, which involves a committee's preliminary review, a hearing where practitioners can present evidence and examine witnesses, and a subsequent determination by the Minister. The court noted that the Minister's guidelines indicated that a committee need not examine all cases referred but must be satisfied that sufficient evidence has been examined to form a basis for a recommendation. The appellant argued that the committee's decision to examine only a portion of the over 2000 services, and to exclude certain services referred to the radiologist, meant it had not gathered sufficient evidence. The court was required to determine if the committee's satisfaction that it had heard sufficient evidence was a legally sound basis for its recommendation and the Minister's subsequent actions.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi