Threlfall v Matthew Goode and Company Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read
26 CLR 217

THRELFALL (COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS FOR

SOUTH AUSTRALIA)

MATTHEW GOODE AND COMPANY

RESPONDENT. LIMITED

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Customs Duties-Duty according to value-Goods purchased abroad-Time at which

value to be taken-Time of export or time of purchase-Customs Act 1901-1910 (No. 6 of 1901-No. 36 of 1910), secs. 154, 155.

Sec. 154 of the Customs Act 1901-1910 provides that " When any duty is imposed according to value-(a) The value shall be taken to be the fair market value of the goods in the principal markets of the country whence the same were exported in the usual and ordinary commercial acceptation of the term and free on board at the port of export in such country and a further addition of ten per cent. on such market value; &.

26 CLR 218

Held, that where goods subject to a duty according to value are purchased abroad by the importer the " fair market value of the goods" must, for the purposes of sec. 154, be taken as at the date of export from the country whence they were exported, and not as at the date of their purchase.

Decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of South Australia.

An action was brought in the Supreme Court by Matthew Goode &Co. Ltd. against Arthur Creswell Threlfall, Collector of Customs for South Australia, by which the plaintiff sought to recover the sum of 14s. 7d., being the difference between the sum of £2 4s. 8d., which the plaintiff had paid under protest as customs duty on two packages of linoleum imported by it from England into South Australia, and the sum of £1 10s. Id., which the plaintiff contended was the proper amount of duty.

Certain admissions of fact having been made by the parties, the plaintiff, on summons, applied to have the action summarily dis- posed of. The material facts are stated in the judgments hereunder.

The summons was heard by Murray C.J., who gave judgment for the plaintiff with costs, holding that in sec. 154 of the Customs Act 1901-1910 the words "the fair market value' mean the fair market value at the time of the purchase of the goods, and not at the time of their export.

From that decision the defendant now, by special leave, appealed to the High Court.

Mann, for the appellant. The market value at the date of export is the value referred to in sec. 154 of the Customs Act 1901-1910. The price for which the goods were sold as stated in the genuine invoice is evidence of that value, but not conclusive evidence. Sec. 155 does not cast any doubt on that interpretation. The reason for mentioning the date of shipment in sec. 155 (b) is that, as there has been no sale of the goods, there is no invoice in the ordinary meaning of that term, and an artificial document, which would not other- wise come into existence, is required…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Threlfall v Matthew Goode and Company Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1919] HCA 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Supreme Court of South Australia concerning the valuation of imported goods for customs duty purposes. The appellant was the Collector of Customs, and the respondent was Matthew Goode & Company Limited, an importer. The dispute arose over the amount of customs duty paid under protest on linoleum imported from England. The importer contended that the duty should be calculated based on the fair market value of the goods at the time of purchase, whereas the Collector argued it should be based on the fair market value at the time of export.

The central legal issue before the High Court was the interpretation of sections 154 and 155 of the *Customs Act 1901-1910*. Specifically, the court had to determine at what point in time the "fair market value" of goods, as defined by section 154(a), should be assessed for the purpose of calculating ad valorem customs duties when those goods had been purchased abroad by the importer.

The High Court, in allowing the appeal, reasoned that section 154(a) of the *Customs Act* mandates that the value for duty purposes is to be taken as the fair market value of the goods in the principal markets of the country of export, free on board at the port of export, plus a ten per cent. addition. While section 154(a) does not explicitly state the date for this valuation, the court found that the overall scheme of the Act, particularly when read in conjunction with section 155, indicated that the relevant time for assessing this market value was the date of export. The court rejected the argument that the date of purchase should be determinative, noting that this could lead to inequalities in taxation and that the invoice, while a verification tool, was not the sole determinant of value or the relevant time for its assessment. The court concluded that the fair market value should be assessed as at the time of export, not the time of purchase.

Background

Background to the litigation

Matthew Goode & Co. Ltd, an importer of goods, brought an action against Arthur Creswell Threlfall, the Collector of Customs for South Australia, seeking a refund of customs duty they had paid on two packages of linoleum imported from England. The company claimed that the customs duty charged on the goods was excessive. The dispute centered on the interpretation of the Customs Act 1901-1910, specifically sections 154 and 155, which pertain to the valuation of imported goods for the purposes of calculating customs duty. The act imposes a duty on goods according to their value, with the fair market value of the goods in the country of export being a key component of this valuation. Matthew Goode & Co. Ltd argued that the fair market value should be determined at the time of purchase, while the Collector of Customs contended that the value should be assessed at the time of export from the country of origin.

The case was first heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia, where the Chief Justice ruled in favor of the company, holding that the fair market value should be determined at the time of purchase. The Collector of Customs appealed this decision to the High Court of Australia. The High Court, in a majority decision, allowed the appeal and held that the fair market value of the goods should be taken at the time of export from the country of origin, not at the time of purchase. This decision was based on the interpretation that the act imposes a duty based on the value of the goods at the time of their entry into Australia, and sections 154 and 155 of the Customs Act merely enable this value to be ascertained. The court also noted that the production of an invoice is not required to necessarily indicate the value of the goods at any particular time, but rather serves as a practical means for the Customs authorities to check the importer's valuation of their goods.

The matter came before the High Court of Australia as an appeal from the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appeal was brought by Arthur Creswell Threlfall, Collector of Customs for South Australia, against a decision of Murray C.J. in the Supreme Court, which had awarded Matthew Goode & Co. Ltd. a sum of 14s. 7d. in a customs duty refund case. Matthew Goode & Co. Ltd. had originally sought to recover the difference between the sum they had paid as customs duty on two packages of linoleum imported from England and the sum they contended was the proper amount of duty. The Supreme Court held that the fair market value of the goods should be taken at the time of purchase, not at the time of export, leading to the refund in their favour. The Collector of Customs appealed this decision to the High Court, arguing that the fair market value should be taken at the time of export, as per the provisions of the Customs Act 1901-1910. The High Court's judgment reversed the decision of the Supreme Court, holding that the fair market value for the purpose of determining customs duty should be taken at the time of export, not at the time of purchase.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate date for determining the fair market value of goods purchased abroad for importation into Australia when a customs duty is imposed according to value?
2. Does section 154 of the Customs Act 1901-1910 require the fair market value to be taken at the date of purchase or at the date of export from the country of origin?
3. Does the difference in language between subsections (a) and (b) of section 155 of the Customs Act 1901-1910 indicate a different point in time for ascertaining market value in the case of sales and consignments for sale?
4. Is there a requirement for equality of taxation between goods exported by the seller and those exported by the consignor of goods for sale in Australia?
5. Does the production of an invoice and a declaration signed by the owner in the presence of the Collector verify the fair market value at the time of the transaction recorded by the invoice, or is it merely a guide to assist the Customs authorities in ascertaining the value?

Held
1. The appropriate date for determining the fair market value of goods purchased abroad for importation into Australia is the date of export from the country of origin, not the date of purchase.
2. Section 154 of the Customs Act 1901-1910 requires the fair market value to be taken at the date of export from the country of origin.
3. The difference in language between subsections (a) and (b) of section 155 of the Customs Act 1901-1910 does not indicate a different point in time for ascertaining market value in the case of sales and consignments for sale.
4. There is no requirement for equality of taxation between goods exported by the seller and those exported by the consignor of goods for sale in Australia.
5. The production of an invoice and a declaration signed by the owner in the presence of the Collector does not verify the fair market value at the time of the transaction recorded by the invoice. Instead, it serves as a guide to assist the Customs authorities in ascertaining the value.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court of Australia in Threlfall v Matthew Goode and Company Limited considered the appropriate date for determining the fair market value of goods purchased abroad for importation into Australia when a customs duty is imposed according to value. The Court determined that the fair market value of goods should be taken at the date of export from the country of origin rather than the date of purchase. The Court's reasoning was based on the language of section 154 of the Customs Act 1901-1910, which provides that the value shall be taken to be the fair market value of the goods in the principal markets of the country whence the same were exported in the usual and ordinary commercial acceptation of the term and free on board at the port of export in such country and a further addition of ten per cent on such market value.

The Court held that section 154 does not expressly indicate the time at which the "value" is to be reckoned. However, the Court found that the fair market value must fluctuate in varying circumstances, and so must transportation and other charges to be defrayed before goods can be "free on board at the port of export." The Court found that the conditions attaching to purchase for exportation being so fluctuating in their character, it would ordinarily be the fact that a person desiring to import goods would pay for their purchase a price very nearly approximating to that ruling at the date of exportation.

The Court also considered the language of section 155 of the Customs Act 1901-1910, which provides that the value shall be verified at the time of entry by the production of the genuine invoice and by a declaration signed by the owner in the presence of the Collector. The Court found that the invoice and declaration alike verify the "value" and, as they are so far on the same footing with reference to the value, there is no more reason for ascribing finality to the one than to the other.

The Court found that the standard for determining the fair market value of goods for the purposes of imposing a customs duty is fixed by section 154(a) of the Customs Act 1901-1910. The invoice and declaration are merely guides to assist the Customs authorities in ascertaining the value, and are not binding standards.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that when a customs duty is imposed on imported goods ad valorem, the fair market value of the goods should be taken at the date of export from the country of origin rather than the date of purchase. This decision ensures uniformity of treatment and facilitates the ascertainment of the dutiable value of imported goods.