Thorpes Ltd v Grant Pastoral Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read
92 CLR 317

THORPES LIMITED

GRANT PASTORAL COMPANY PROPRIE-

TARY LIMITED PLAINTIFF,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Water, Water Supply and Watercourses-River-Riparian owners-Rights and

liabilitiesCommon law-Statute--Earth works-Construction along banks of tributary and flood alveus-Interference with natural flow-Flood waters- Damage-Water Act 1912-1946 (N.S.W.) (No. 44 of 1912-No. 35 of 1946), AppealSubmission-Made late in address to High Court-Not made at trial of

action, nor during appeal to State court-N allowed.

A river flowed through certain lands owned and occupied by P. and also MELBOURNE, through D.'s lands opposite thereto. D. had constructed certain earth works along the banks of a creek, a tributary of the river, and across a flood alveus of the river, which in time of flood formed an escape channel for water which overflowed the banks of the river. During 1950, waters from the river inundated P.'s lands, leaving as they subsided a deposit of sand, silt and debris which caused considerable damage. In an action P. alleged that D. was negligent in the construction and maintenance of the earth works and was guilty of nuisance in interfering with the natural flow of the river and diverting its water on to P.'s land. A jury found for P. on both counts.

Held that the Water Act 1912-1946 (N.S.W.) had not deprived a land- owner of his right to complain that water silt and debris had been thrown on his land by an obstruction made to the channel or natural flood channel of a stream without lawful justification or excuse.

Hanson v. Grassy Gully Gold Mining Co. (1900) 21 N.S.W.L.R. 271, referred to and distinguished.

Decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Full Court): Grant Pastoral Co. Ltd. v. Thorpes Ltd. (1953) 54 S.R. (N.S.W.) 129 71 W.N. 101, affirmed.

92 CLR 318

At the close of the address on behalf of the appellant, D., its counsel submitted that the levee banks had been erected by way of defence against a common enemy and that the case was covered by Gerrard v. Crowe (1921) 1 A.C. 395. That submission had not been made either at the trial or upon the appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

Held that in the circumstances such submission not having been made previously should not be allowed to be made at that late stage.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

Grant Pastoral Co. Pty. Ltd. brought an action in the Supreme Court of New South Wales claiming that the defendant, Thorpes Ltd., had caused damage to certain land of the plaintiff.

The declaration contained two counts. In the first count it was alleged that at all material times the plaintiff was the owner and occupier of certain lands in the neighbourhood of the Belubula River and of certain other creeks or streams, and the defendant, who was possessed of and in occupation by its servants and agents of certain land in the same neighbourhood, by those servants and agents wrongfully…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thorpes Ltd v Grant Pastoral Co Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1955] HCA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales concerning a dispute over land damage caused by earthworks. The plaintiff, Grant Pastoral Co. Pty. Ltd., alleged that the defendant, Thorpes Ltd., had wrongfully constructed embankments and channels on its land, which altered the natural flow of the Belubula River and a tributary creek, causing floodwaters, sand, silt, and debris to be diverted onto the plaintiff's land, resulting in significant damage to pasturage, crops, and the land itself. The plaintiff's claim was based on negligence and nuisance. A jury found in favour of the plaintiff, and this decision was upheld by the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the Water Act 1912-1946 (N.S.W.) had abrogated the common law rights of landowners to sue for damages caused by the obstruction or diversion of natural water flows, particularly where such actions resulted in water, silt, and debris being cast upon their land. The defendant argued that the Act vested the control of water in the Crown and that any private rights to complain of interference with water flow had been extinguished. The court was required to determine if the plaintiff's action was solely an infringement of riparian rights, which the defendant contended were abolished by the Act, or if it was based on more general common law rights of landowners to be free from such interferences.

The High Court, in dismissing the appeal, reasoned that the plaintiff's claim was not solely based on the infringement of riparian rights, but rather on the ordinary common law right of a landowner to be free from nuisance and negligence that causes physical damage to their property. The court held that the Water Act 1912-1946, while vesting control of water in the Crown, did not extinguish a landowner's right to complain of damage caused by the unlawful obstruction or diversion of water, especially when it resulted in the deposit of harmful materials like sand and silt on their land. The court distinguished the plaintiff's claim from cases solely concerning the interference with the natural flow of water in a river channel, emphasizing that the damage here arose from floodwaters being diverted and cast onto the plaintiff's land, causing physical injury. Furthermore, the court refused to entertain a late submission by the appellant regarding the "common enemy" doctrine, as it had not been raised at trial or in the prior appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Grant Pastoral Co Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) brought an action against Thorpes Ltd (the defendant) in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, alleging that the defendant had caused damage to certain lands of the plaintiff. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant had negligently constructed and maintained certain earthworks along the banks of Emu Creek, a tributary of the Belubula River, and across a flood channel of the river, thereby obstructing and altering the natural flow of the river and its tributaries. This obstruction and alteration of the river's flow resulted in floodwaters overflowing onto the plaintiff's land, causing significant damage to crops, pasture, and land, as well as depositing sand, silt, and debris. The jury found in favour of the plaintiff, awarding damages in the sum of £3,600. The defendant appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which dismissed the appeal. The defendant then appealed to the High Court of Australia, arguing that the Water Act 1912-1946 (N.S.W.) had deprived the plaintiff of any right to complain about the damage caused by the obstruction and alteration of the river's flow. The High Court held that the Water Act 1912-1946 did not deprive the plaintiff of the right to complain about the damage caused by the obstruction and alteration of the river's flow, and dismissed the defendant's appeal.

The matter came before the High Court on appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Initially, Grant Pastoral Co. Pty Ltd brought an action against Thorpes Ltd in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, claiming damages for alleged negligence and nuisance caused by earthworks constructed by Thorpes Ltd on its land. The jury found in favour of Grant Pastoral Co. Pty Ltd, awarding damages of £3,600. Thorpes Ltd then appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which dismissed the appeal. Dissatisfied with the Full Court's decision, Thorpes Ltd further appealed to the High Court. The High Court upheld the Full Court's decision, dismissing Thorpes Ltd's appeal with costs. The central issue in the case was whether the Water Act 1912-1946 (N.S.W.) had deprived landowners of their common law right to complain about damage caused by obstructed water flows. The High Court held that the Act had not abolished these common law rights, and that Grant Pastoral Co. Pty Ltd was entitled to maintain its action for damages. The Court also rejected a late argument raised by Thorpes Ltd that the case should be decided under the principle of defence against a "common enemy," as this argument had not been raised at the trial or during the earlier appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Water Act 1912-1946 (N.S.W.) has deprived land owners of their common law right to complain that water, silt, and debris have been thrown on their land by an obstruction made to the channel or natural flood channel of a stream without lawful justification or excuse.
2. Whether the defendant's actions constitute a nuisance, given that the plaintiff's land was damaged by the obstruction and diversion of the natural flow of the river and creek.
3. Whether the defendant's construction and maintenance of the levees and channels on its land, which obstructed and diverted the waters of the river and creek, was a reasonable use of its property or an unreasonable interference with the plaintiff's rights.
4. Whether the defendant's actions caused the damage to the plaintiff's land, and if so, whether the defendant is liable for the damages.
5. Whether the doctrine of Gerrard v. Crowe applies to the defendant's actions, allowing it to erect the levees and channels as a reasonable use of its property to throw off flood waters, even if it caused damage to the plaintiff's land.
6. Whether the submission made by the appellant's counsel at the end of the address, that the levee banks were erected by way of defence against a common enemy and that the case is covered by Gerrard v. Crowe, should be allowed, given that it was not raised at the trial or during the appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

Held
1. The court held that the Water Act 1912-1946 (N.S.W.) has not deprived landowners of their common law right to complain that water, silt, and debris have been thrown on their land by an obstruction made to the channel or natural flood channel of a stream without lawful justification or excuse. The appeal was dismissed.

2. The court held that the defendant's actions did constitute a nuisance, given that the plaintiff's land was damaged by the obstruction and diversion of the natural flow of the river and creek. The appeal was dismissed.

3. The court held that the defendant's construction and maintenance of the levees and channels on its land, which obstructed and diverted the waters of the river and creek, was not a reasonable use of its property or an unreasonable interference with the plaintiff's rights. The appeal was dismissed.

4. The court held that the defendant's actions did cause the damage to the plaintiff's land, and that the defendant is liable for the damages. The appeal was dismissed.

5. The court held that the doctrine of Gerrard v. Crowe does not apply to the defendant's actions, allowing it to erect the levees and channels as a reasonable use of its property to throw off flood waters, even if it caused damage to the plaintiff's land. The appeal was dismissed.

6. The court held that the submission made by the appellant's counsel at the end of the address, that the levee banks were erected by way of defence against a common enemy and that the case is covered by Gerrard v. Crowe, should not be allowed, given that it was not raised at the trial or during the appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court of Australia, in the case of Thorpes Ltd v Grant Pastoral Co Pty Ltd, considered whether the Water Act 1912-1946 (N.S.W.) had deprived landowners of their common law right to complain about water, silt, and debris being thrown on their land by an obstruction made to the channel or natural flood channel of a stream without lawful justification or excuse. The court held that the Water Act 1912-1946 had not deprived landowners of this right. The court distinguished the case of Hanson v. Grassy Gully Gold Mining Co. (1900) 21 N.S.W.L.R. 271, which held that the common law right asserted by the plaintiff had been taken away by the Water Rights Act 1896. The court found that the plaintiff in the present case was not asserting a "riparian" right, but an ordinary right vested in every owner of land.

The court also found that the defendant's actions constituted a nuisance, as the plaintiff's land was damaged by the obstruction and diversion of the natural flow of the river and creek. The court held that the defendant's construction and maintenance of the levees and channels on its land, which obstructed and diverted the waters of the river and creek, was an unreasonable interference with the plaintiff's rights. The court found that the defendant's actions caused the damage to the plaintiff's land, and that the defendant was liable for the damages.

The court considered whether the doctrine of Gerrard v. Crowe (1921) 1 A.C. 395 applied to the defendant's actions, allowing it to erect the levees and channels as a reasonable use of its property to throw off flood waters, even if it caused damage to the plaintiff's land. The court found that the doctrine did not apply in this case, as the levees and channels were erected within the channel of the creek, rather than outside the flood channel to repel a common enemy.

Finally, the court considered whether the submission made by the appellant's counsel at the end of the address, that the levee banks were erected by way of defence against a common enemy and that the case is covered by Gerrard v. Crowe, should be allowed. The court held that this submission should not be allowed, as it was not raised at the trial or during the appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Water Act 1912-1946 has not deprived landowners of their common law right to complain about water, silt, and debris being thrown on their land by an obstruction made to the channel or natural flood channel of a stream without lawful justification or excuse. The court also found that the defendant's actions constituted a nuisance and that it was liable for the damages caused to the plaintiff's land.