Thornpast Pty Limited v Parramatta City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES LAND AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

CITATION:     Thornpast Pty Limited v Parramatta City Council [2004]  NSWLEC 520

PARTIES:
APPLICANT:
Thornpast Pty Limited

RESPONDENT:
Parramatta City Council

CASE NUMBER:     10550 of        2004

CATCH WORDS:     Question of Law

LEGISLATION CITED:
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, s 4
Sydney Regional Environmental Plan No 28 - Parramatta, cl 17(2)(c)

CORAM:        Pain J

DATES OF HEARING:        15/09/2004

DECISION DATE:    16/09/2004

LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES

APPLICANT:
Mr S. Berveling (barrister) instructed by Pike Pike & Fenwick

RESPONDENT:
Mr J. Johnson (barrister) instructed by Storey and Gough Solicitors

JUDGMENT:

THE LAND AND
ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES

PAIN J

16 SEPTEMBER 2004

10550 of 2004                   THORNPAST PTY LIMITED v PARRAMATTA CITY COUNCIL

JUDGMENT

  1. Her Honour:  Thornpast Pty Limited (“the Applicant”) has commenced Class 1 proceedings appealing against the decision of the Council to refuse its development application for consent to use the ground floor of an existing building at 105 George Street, Parramatta (“the building”) as a brothel. The land is zoned “City Core” under the Sydney Regional Environmental Plan No 28 - Parramatta (“the SREP”). The parties have asked the Court to determine the following preliminary question of law before the Applicant’s appeal is heard:
    (a)          Whether the proposal is prohibited by virtue of cl 17(2) of the SREP.

A further question (b) identified by the parties was not pressed.

The Sydney Regional Environmental Plan No 28 - Parramatta

  1. Clause 17(1) of the SREP provides that:

    The objectives of the City Core zone are as follows:

    (a) to encourage Parramatta’s role and growth as a focus within the Greater Metropolitan Region for finance, commerce, tourism, cultural activities, entertainment and government services,

    (b) to provide a consolidated commercial core to the Parramatta City Centre and concentrate commercial development around the Parramatta Railway Station,

    (c) to encourage and protect accessible city blocks by providing active frontages to streets and a network of pedestrian-friendly streets, lanes and arcades.

  2. Clause 17(2) of the SREP relevantly provides as follows:

    Development controls for the City Core zone are as follows:

    (a)Within the City Core zone, exempt development may be carried out without development consent.

    (b) Any other development may be carried out only with development consent.

    (c)Development at the ground floor street frontage of buildings may be carried out only for the purpose of amusement centres, child care centres, clubs, commercial premises that are frequented by customers, community facilities, entertainment facilities, hotels, medical consulting rooms, motels, places of public worship, refreshment rooms, shops and access to uses on other levels.

    (d)Despite paragraphs (a) and (b), residential buildings, other than hotels and serviced apartments, are not allowed in the hatched area identified on the City Centre Zoning Map.

  3. The parties agreed that the effect of cl 17(2)(b) is that the development the subject of the Applicant’s development application is permissible with consent subject to the operation of cl 17(2)(c).

Does cl 17(2)(c) of the SREP prohibit the proposal?
The Applicant’s Submissions

  1. The Applicant relied on Strathfield Council v Poynting (2001) 116…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thornpast Pty Limited v Parramatta City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWLEC 520
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Thornpast Pty Limited sought to appeal a decision by the Parramatta City Council to refuse a development application for the use of the ground floor of an existing building as a brothel. The matter came before Pain J of the New South Wales Land and Environment Court, who was required to determine whether the proposal was prohibited by clause 17(2)(c) of the Sydney Regional Environmental Plan No 28 - Parramatta. The Applicant argued that the clause in question was a development standard which did not prohibit the proposed development, while the Council argued that it was a prohibition. The Court considered the wording of the clause, as well as relevant case law and statutory definitions. The Court ultimately found that clause 17(2)(c) of the SREP operates as a prohibition on the carrying out of development not identified in the clause at the ground floor street frontage of buildings within the City Core zone. Consequently, the Court found that the proposal was prohibited by virtue of this clause. The Court rejected the Applicant’s arguments that the clause was a development standard, noting that the cases cited by the Applicant did not support its contention. The Court also found that the definition of “frontage” and “ground floor street frontage” should not be constrained beyond their normal meaning. The Court held that the whole of the SREP must be considered in determining the meaning of clause 17(2)(c), but found that the objectives contained in clause 17(1) of the SREP did not advance either the Applicant’s or the Council’s case. The Court ultimately held that the proposal was prohibited by clause 17(2)(c) of the SREP and that the Applicant’s development application for a brothel in the ground floor street frontage of 105 George Street was prohibited.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established