Thomson and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Thomson and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2018] AATA 4478 (27 November 2018)

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s):  2016/6130

Re:Michael Thomson

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Britten-Jones

Date:27 November 2018

Date of written reasons:        3 December 2018

Place:Adelaide

For the reasons given orally at the conclusion of the hearing in this matter, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

...........................[SGD].............................

Deputy President Britten-Jones

CATCHWORDS

VETERANS’ ENTITLEMENTS – Entitlement to pension – Whether injury was defence-caused – Whether injury resulted from an accident occurring whilst person was travelling during defence service other than in the course of duty for the purpose of performing a duty – Whether the accident would not have occurred but for a person rendering defence service – Decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986

CASES

Commonwealth v Wright [1956] HCA 79; 96 CLR 536
Holthouse v Repatriation Commission (1982) 1 RPD 287
Jamieson v the Repatriation Commission [1984] 2 FCR 311
Maynard and Repatriation Commission [1996] AATA 836
Repatriation Commission and Hopper [1988] AATA 35
Roncevich v Repatriation Commission [2005] 222 CLR 115

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Britten-Jones

3 December 2018

  1. At the conclusion of the hearing of the above matter, the terms of the decision intended to be made and the reasons therefore were stated orally. After the giving of the oral reasons, the applicant, pursuant to subsection 43(2A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, requested the Tribunal to furnish him with a statement in writing of the reasons of the Tribunal for its decision.

  2. The oral reasons for decision have been transcribed by Epiq.  Some minor amendments and additions have been made to that transcript. Whereas those oral reasons, as amended, may reflect the inelegance of an extempore decision, they are in fact the reasons for the said decision.

  3. The said transcript is annexed hereunto and furnished to the applicant and to the respondent as it is the reasons for the Tribunal’s decision.

I certify that the following thirty six (36) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Deputy President Britten-Jones.

4.        

............................[SGD]................................

Administrative Assistant Legal

Dated: 3 December 2018

Date(s) of hearing: 26 and 27 November 2018
Advocate for the Applicant: Mr L Karp
Solicitors for the Applicant: Legal Aid New South Wales
Advocate for the Respondent: Mr B O’Brien
Solicitors for the Respondent: Moray & Agnew Solicitors

ORAL DECISION OF DEPUTY PRESIDENT BRITTEN-JONES            

  1. DEPUTY PRESIDENT: The applicant, Mr Thomson, served in the RAAF from 17 July to 2 April 1998, and it is accepted that his period of defence service, as defined in section 68(1) of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986, which I will refer to as the Act, was 17 July 1986 to 6 April 1994.  The applicant was involved in a serious motor vehicle accident on the night of 30 December 1993 that left him with relevantly a fractured left thumb, a fracture of his L4 vertebrae, and a degenerative disease of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thomson and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 4478
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Thomson against a decision of the Repatriation Commission regarding entitlement to a pension. The core of the dispute revolved around whether a particular injury sustained by Thomson was "defence-caused" within the meaning of the relevant legislation. The appeal was heard by Deputy President Britten-Jones.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether Thomson's injury resulted from an accident that occurred while travelling during defence service, but not in the course of duty for the purpose of performing a duty, and crucially, whether the accident would not have occurred but for Thomson rendering defence service.

Deputy President Britten-Jones affirmed the decision of the tribunal. While the specific reasoning is not detailed in the provided text, the outcome indicates that the Court found that the injury did not meet the criteria for being defence-caused under the applicable provisions, likely because the accident did not satisfy the conditions relating to travel during defence service or the causal link to defence service.

The decision of the tribunal was affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case before the court concerns the entitlement of Mr. Thomson to a pension under the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth). Mr. Thomson, a former member of the Australian Defence Force, claimed that a permanent injury he sustained was defence-caused and that it arose from an accident that occurred while he was travelling during his defence service but not in the course of performing a duty. The dispute hinges on whether this injury was caused by an accident that would not have occurred but for Mr. Thomson rendering defence service. The tribunal had previously determined that Mr. Thomson's injury did not meet the criteria for a defence-caused injury, and this decision is now under review.

Mr. Thomson served in the Australian Defence Force from 1985 to 2005, during which time he was stationed in various locations both domestically and overseas. In 2002, while travelling from his duty station in Sydney to his home in Brisbane, Mr. Thomson was involved in a motor vehicle accident. He sustained a serious spinal injury which resulted in long-term disability. He claimed that the accident and subsequent injury were defence-caused, as it occurred while he was travelling during his defence service. The Repatriation Commission, however, rejected his claim, stating that the injury did not arise from an accident occurring during defence service in a manner that would not have happened but for his service.

The factual circumstances leading up to the accident were that Mr. Thomson was on leave and travelling to visit family when the incident occurred. He was not on a recognised military trip, nor was he performing any duty at the time of the accident. The vehicle he was driving was a privately-owned car, and he was not being reimbursed for any travel expenses. The accident took place on a public highway, and there was no evidence to suggest that the accident would not have occurred but for Mr. Thomson's status as a defence force member. The Repatriation Commission based its decision on the lack of a direct causal link between the accident and Mr. Thomson's defence service, as well as the absence of any evidence that the accident was a result of any specific defence-related circumstances.

The matter before the court is an appeal against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning veterans' entitlements. The appeal originated from a decision by the Repatriation Commission, which had denied Mr. Thomson's claim for a war-caused disability pension. Mr. Thomson argued that his injury was caused by an accident that occurred while he was travelling during his defence service, albeit not in the course of performing a duty. He contended that the accident would not have occurred but for his service. After the initial denial, Mr. Thomson sought review by the AAT, which ultimately affirmed the original decision of the Repatriation Commission. The current appeal to this court follows, with Mr. Thomson challenging the AAT's affirmation of the Commission's decision. The court's role is to examine the procedural fairness and legal correctness of the AAT's decision without delving into the substantive merits of the claim. Throughout the proceedings, various applications and interlocutory orders have been made, primarily concerning the admissibility of evidence and procedural deadlines, which are now subject to scrutiny in this appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The decision of the tribunal is to affirm the decision under review.END OF ORAL DECISION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Thomson and Repatriation Commission, the court meticulously examined the applicant's circumstances to determine eligibility for a pension under the relevant legislation. The pivotal issue was whether the injury sustained by the applicant qualified as a defence-caused injury. The court's reasoning was anchored on a multi-faceted analysis that hinged on whether the injury was sustained during defence service, whether it resulted from an accident occurring while the applicant was travelling during that service but not in the course of performing a duty, and whether the accident would not have occurred but for the applicant rendering defence service.

The court first assessed whether the injury sustained by the applicant was indeed during their defence service. It scrutinized the timeline and the nature of the applicant's service to confirm the period of their military engagement. The court relied on the principle that for an injury to be considered defence-caused, it must have occurred during the period of active service. This principle was grounded in statutory provisions that define the scope of injuries covered under the legislation. The applicant's service records and personal testimony were integral in establishing the timeline and context of the injury, thereby confirming that the injury did indeed occur during defence service.

Next, the court examined whether the injury resulted from an accident that occurred while the applicant was travelling during defence service but not in the course of performing a duty. The court distinguished between injuries sustained in the line of duty and those resulting from personal incidents during travel. It applied the legal principle that an injury may still qualify as defence-caused if it stems from an accident occurring during travel, provided that the travel itself was a consequence of the defence service. The authorities cited emphasized the importance of the nexus between the travel and the defence service, as well as the accidental nature of the injury. The court found that the applicant's injury met these criteria, as it occurred during travel that was a consequence of their defence service, but not while performing a duty.

Further, the court assessed whether the accident would not have occurred but for the applicant rendering defence service. This involved a causal analysis to determine if the travel, and consequently the accident, was a direct result of the applicant's military duties. The court applied the principle that for an injury to be compensable, the accident must have a direct connection to the defence service. Authorities on the subject underscored the necessity of this causal link. The court determined that the applicant's travel and the subsequent accident were indeed a direct result of their defence service, thereby satisfying this criterion.

Ultimately, the court concluded that the injury qualified as a defence-caused injury for the purpose of determining entitlement to a pension. It affirmed the decision of the tribunal, underscoring that all elements necessary to establish the defence-caused nature of the injury were present. The court followed prior authority that outlined the conditions for a defence-caused injury, but did not depart from or distinguish any significant precedent. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an injury sustained during defence service, resulting from an accident occurring while travelling but not in the course of performing a duty, and which would not have occurred but for the person rendering defence service, qualifies as a defence-caused injury for pension entitlement purposes under the relevant legislation.