Thompson v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Thompson v State of Queensland [2009] QDC 242
PARTIES:  Martin Neil THOMPSON
(Appellant)
and
State of Queensland
(Respondent)
FILE NO/S:  D 108/09
DIVISION:  Criminal
PROCEEDING:  Appeal
ORIGINATING 
COURT: 
Magistrates Court, Townsville
DELIVERED ON:  30 July 2009
DELIVERED AT:  Townsville
HEARING  22 & 24 July 2009
DATES: 
JUDGE:  Durward SC DCJ
ORDERS:  1. Appeal allowed.
2. Sentence imposed on 16 April 2009 set aside and in lieu
thereof the appellant is to be re-sentenced as follows:
(a) In respect of the eight burglary and commission of
indictable offence and three enter premises and
commission of indictable offence charges I make an order
of probation for a period of two years.
(b) In respect of the seven unlawful entry of a motor
vehicle and commission of an indictable offence and five
stealing charges I make a community service order for 60
hours;
(c) I order that the appellant pay restitution in the sum of
$3,457.75; and
(d) I order that no convictions be recorded.
3. I make no order as to costs.
CATCHWORDS:  APPEAL – SENTENCE - whether term of imprisonment
wholly suspended with convictions recorded manifestly
excessive – serious property offending – 9 day crime spree –
university student – 18 years age – no previous criminal
history – good character – employed – early plea – remorse –
restitution made in full – rehabilitation – unlikely to re-offend
– professional career prospects.
RECORDING OF CONVICTIONS – Section 12 (2) exercise of discretion – review of specific authorities.
Hughes v Hopwood (1950) QWN 21; House v R (1936) 55
CLR 499; R v Briese; ex parte Attorney-General (1988) 1 Qd
R 487; R v Brown; ex parte Attorney-General (1994) 2 Qd R
182; R v Bain (1997) QCA 035; R v Pahoff (2002) QCA 525;
R v Cay, Gersch & Schell; ex parte Attorney-General (Qld)
(2005) QCA 467; R v Ndizeye (2006) QCA 537.
COUNSEL:  Ms V Keegan for the appellant Ms C Kelsey for the respondent
SOLICITORS:  Anderson Telford Lawyers for the appellant
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the
respondent
THE SENTENCE 
  1. On 16 April 2009 the appellant was convicted on pleas of guilty, in the Magistrates Court at Townsville, to imprisonment for 12 months wholly suspended for an operational period of two years; and ordered to pay restitution in the sum of $3,457.75. The charges were 23 indictable offences involving burglary and property offending. Convictions were recorded.

  2. The appellant was also convicted of two summary offences and one traffic offence and fined in respect of each. No convictions were recorded on the two summary offences. A conviction was recorded on the traffic offence.

    GROUNDS OF APPEAL

  3. The appeal was made in respect of the indictable offences only. The grounds of the appeal were:

“1. That the learned Acting Magistrate failed to have regard to the sentencing principle that a sentence of imprisonment should only be imposed as a last resort; and

2.              That the learned Acting Magistrate placed insufficient weight on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thompson v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QDC 242
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Thompson v State of Queensland, the appellant, who had no prior criminal history and was an 18-year-old high achiever, found himself in the company of a bad peer group, leading to a series of burglaries committed over nine days. The appellant largely cooperated with the authorities, entered timely pleas of guilty, and expressed remorse. The court acknowledged his efforts at rehabilitation, including paying the restitution order in full, enrolling in an engineering course, and living a more stable life. The appeal focused on the sentence of imprisonment imposed on the appellant, which the respondent conceded was excessive and should have been a community-based order instead.

The court was tasked with determining whether the sentence was appropriate and whether convictions should be recorded. The appeal hinged on whether the Acting Magistrate had erred in imposing a sentence of imprisonment that was manifestly excessive and whether convictions should have been recorded. The court considered the principles of sentencing, particularly those outlined in section 9(2) of the Act, which emphasize the importance of non-custodial orders when appropriate.

The court found that the Acting Magistrate had erred in imposing a term of imprisonment and in failing to properly weigh the principles of sentencing. The sentence was manifestly excessive and did not align with the principles of the Act. The court also found that the Magistrate's decision to record convictions was erroneous. Consequently, the court allowed the appeal, set aside the sentence, and ordered the appellant to be re-sentenced with appropriate community-based orders. The court further decided not to record convictions, considering the appellant's rehabilitation and the overall circumstances of the case.

In summary, the court's decision was to allow the appeal, set aside the original sentence, and re-sentence the appellant with community-based orders, while also deciding not to record convictions. The court emphasized the importance of adhering to sentencing principles and the potential for rehabilitation in cases involving first-time offenders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant had no criminal history. He was 18 years of age. He had good antecedents and character and had been a high achiever at high school through to grade 12. He had been a student at university, having commenced a course in medicine. He committed the offences over a period of nine days in the company of others and influenced he seems by a bad peer group that he had fallen in with. Alcohol, drugs, personal and family problems and difficulties with his peers contributed to what is in my view, aberrant conduct on his part. When apprehended by the police he largely co-operated with the authorities and he entered timely pleas of guilty. He was prepared to pay the restitution order in full. He had returned to a more stable life and it appears that he no longer takes drugs or abuses alcohol. He expressed remorse for his conduct. BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE FACTS The appellant committed the offences in the company of others. Three of the dwellings that were the subject of burglaries were occupied at the time of entry. He was a lookout and a vehicle driver respectively in two of those. He was inside the premises in the other when the occupant was disturbed. A co-accused female who was involved in four burglaries was given an 18 month probation order in the Magistrates Court. The offences were serious. However there was no evidence of harm or injury to any person and damage to or loss of property was the subject of a restitution order. APPELLANTS’ CIRCUMSTANCES AT APPEAL HEARING The changes in circumstances were not great but reflected an ongoing process of rehabilitation. Hence the appellant appeared on the appeal with antecedents that were minimally different from those submitted to his Honour on sentence. When the appeal was heard the appellant had paid the restitution order in full. He had enrolled in an engineering course at university. He was working. He was living in a more stable environment. He aspired to pursue an engineering degree including the possibility of seeking a career in the Australian Defence Force. There is a reasonable basis for the view that I have formed that any re-offending behaviour is unlikely to occur. THE APPEAL HEARING On the hearing of the appeal on 22 July 2009 the respondent conceded that in all of the circumstances the sentence of imprisonment was excessive and that there were other options, specifically community based orders, that had been open to the Acting Magistrate to impose. However, the respondent submitted that in all the circumstances it was proper that convictions had been recorded and maintained that in any re-sentencing of the appellant, in the event that the appeal was allowed and the sentence below was set aside, convictions should again be recorded. I allowed the appeal and intimated that I would set aside the sentence imposed by the Acting Magistrate. I adjourned the hearing so that I might give further consideration to the issue of the recording of convictions. On 24 July 2009 I made formal orders with respect to the appeal, as I have indicated, set aside the sentence imposed below and re-sentenced the appellant. I further reserved the reasons for my decision not to record convictions on the re- sentencing.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Similarly, in House v R (1936) 55 CLR 504 (at p505), Dixon, Evatt and McTiernan JJ sated that “…it is not enough that the judges composing the appellate court consider that, if they had been in the position of the primary judge, they would have taken a different course. It must appear that some error has ben made in exercising the discretion.” CONCLUSION It was, in all the circumstances open to his Honour to not record convictions. In my view that would have been the proper course for him to have taken. There was sufficient evidence, upon a broad application of the discretion as is proper in respect of section 12(2) (c) of the Act in particular, to support an exercise of discretion in the appellant's favour. I find that the Acting Magistrate's exercise of discretion, even if it was exercised, in respect of s 12(2) of the Act has miscarried and that he was in error in rejecting the submission that convictions should not be recorded. The orders made below should be set-aside and the appellant re-sentenced. In so far as the sentence of imprisonment was concerned, whilst I dealt with this in the oral reasons given on 24 July 2009, I should for the sake of completeness say something further about that in this judgment. I found that the imposition of a term of imprisonment wholly suspended was manifestly excessive. Community based orders were open in all of the circumstances. Quite apart from the weight of considerations which would in my view have made non-custodial orders quite unobjectionable, his Honour failed to give proper weight to the principle of sentencing in s 9(2) of the Act, namely: In my view the failure by the Acting Magistrate to recognise and to apply that principle, which is evident on the face of the record, was a significant error in the circumstances of this case. ORDERS 1. Appeal allowed. 2. Sentence imposed on 16 April 2009 set aside and in lieu thereof the appellant is to be re-sentenced as follows.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.