Thompson v Desmond and Insurance Australia Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

MAGISTRATES COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title: Thompson v Desmond & Insurance Australia Limited

Citation:

[2015] ACTMC 6

Hearing Date(s):

1 December 2015

DecisionDate:

15 December 2015

Before:

Magistrate Morrison

Decision:

See [40], [43], [49]

Category:

Costs

Catchwords:

CIVIL LAW – costs – review of deputy registrar’s decision on assessment  –  jurisdiction of deputy registrar  –  relevance of offer and reasonableness of plaintiff’s refusal to costs assessment when no special costs order made  –  point in time at which deputy registrar’s assessment of whether costs incurred fair and reasonable to be made  –  powers of deputy registrar to determine facts

Legislation:

Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT)

Cases:

Brennand v Hartung and Best Practice Education Group Ltd [2014] ACTSC 326
Bartlett v Higgins [1901] 2 KB 230
Grant v Australian Knitting Mills [1937] SASR 113

Parties:

Justin Dowling Thompson (plaintiff/respondent)
Mary Desmond (first defendant/appellant)
Insurance Australia Limited Trading as NRMA Insurance (second defendant/appellant)

Representation:

Counsel
Ms Castle (appellants)
Mr Crowe SC (respondent)

Solicitors
Sparke Helmore Lawyers (appellants)
Maliganis Edwards Johnson (respondent)

File Number:

CS 219 of 2012

MAGISTRATE MORRISON:

Background

  1. The proceedings between the parties were resolved by way of a consent judgment for the plaintiff in an amount of $70,000.00. The formal order of the Court does not record against whom the judgment is entered but nothing turns on that for present purposes.  The Court order goes on to require the defendants to pay the plaintiff’s costs to be agreed or assessed.

  1. The plaintiff applied for an assessment of costs. A bill of costs was prepared. A notice of objection was filed. In the course of the assessment the deputy registrar, who may exercise the powers of the registrar by virtue of rule 5(4) of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) identified 2 points raised in objections and which he described as novel.

  1. He invited written submissions on them on the basis that they needed to be determined as preliminary questions. The parties agree that the document which is Exhibit A accurately records the decision of the deputy registrar following those written submissions. In it he describes the 2 points raised in objections in this way:

Point 1:

The defendants object that the Bill of Costs does not represent fair and reasonable costs having regard to the mandatory offer made five months prior to settlement and accepted only on the week prior to the hearing. 

It is obvious that the deputy registrar understands the objection to relate to costs for work performed between when the mandatory final offer was made and when acceptance of the offer for that amount took place.  I refer to the relevant work in these reasons as the disputed work.

Point 2:

The insurer’s solicitors advised the plaintiff’s solicitors by letter dated 3 June 2013 that in their view, the economic loss report and addendum letter of Geoffrey Davis, Macquarie Reporting Service, both dated 4 November 2013 were not a reasonable disbursement and that they intended to dispute payment at the resolution of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thompson v Desmond and Insurance Australia Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ACTMC 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Thompson v Desmond and Insurance Australia Limited, the appellant, Mr. Thompson, sought a review of a decision made by the deputy registrar regarding the assessment of costs. The matter was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, where the deputy registrar had initially ruled on the assessment of costs following a Calderbank offer and the reasonableness of the plaintiff's refusal to accept the offer. The case raised questions about the jurisdiction of the deputy registrar in determining the fairness and reasonableness of costs incurred in light of such offers and the timing of the assessment.

The central legal issues the court needed to address were whether the deputy registrar had the authority to assess the reasonableness of the plaintiff's refusal of a Calderbank offer and to determine the fairness of the costs incurred based on the evidence provided. Additionally, the court had to consider the timing at which the deputy registrar should assess whether the costs incurred were fair and reasonable, as well as the extent of the deputy registrar's powers in determining such facts. The appellant argued that the deputy registrar had jurisdiction to review the reasonableness of the refusal and the fairness of the costs, while the respondent maintained that these determinations were outside the deputy registrar's jurisdiction and should be left to the court.

The court concluded that the deputy registrar had effectively denied himself jurisdiction by not considering the merits of the objections raised concerning the reasonableness of the refusal of the Calderbank offer and the fairness of the costs incurred. The court found that the deputy registrar's reasoning indicated a belief that it was not his role to form a view on these matters, as they were better suited to the court. The court held that the deputy registrar's jurisdiction was limited to certain factual determinations and procedural matters, and that broader assessments of reasonableness and fairness were beyond his remit. The court further found that the timing of the assessment was crucial and should have been made at a point when all relevant evidence was available.

The court ultimately determined that the deputy registrar's decision to decline jurisdiction over the assessment of the reasonableness of the refusal and the fairness of the costs incurred was correct. The appeal was dismissed, and no orders were made altering the deputy registrar's decision on the assessment of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [40], [43], [49]

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I adopt the approach just described. In that context the decision of the deputy registrar and his reasons are important.The deputy registrar’s decision In his decision in the first instance, the deputy registrar made reference to the power of a court to make what are special costs orders where a Calderbank offer has been made. He went on to say: His decision on reconsideration included the following at paragraph 31: From that record of the reasons given by the deputy registrar, I conclude that he declined to consider the merits of the objections raised on either point on the basis that he had no power or jurisdiction to do so. Counsel for the appellant said that the deputy registrar “denied himself jurisdiction” which I treat as another way of saying the same thing. That then is the statement of principle which the appellant must demonstrate to be wrong for the purposes of the review, but it must be looked at in conjunction with the reasons given by the deputy registrar. As to point one, the deputy registrar appears to have concluded that he had no power or jurisdiction because it was not his role to form a view on the reasonableness or otherwise of the plaintiff’s rejection of the original mandatory final offer. As to point 2, in his original decision the deputy registrar appears to base his conclusion (of no power or jurisdiction) on his inability to form a view about whether the plaintiff’s evidence justified the assumptions on which the loss report was commissioned. The deputy registrar refers to that inability to do so by reference to the need for “access to a range of powers and procedures” which he says were not available to him. In his reconsideration reasons the deputy registrar lumps together both point 1 and point 2 in saying that he regards the determination of costs emanating from a Calderbank offer, or an ‘economic loss report’ clearly into a category that is the preserve of the Courts. The respondent, on my understanding of the submissions put to me, takes a somewhat subtly different view of the effect of the reasons given by the deputy registrar. My conclusion however is that his reasons on the reconsideration decision in effect restate those he gave at first instance as just set out. The arguments of the parties are well set out in the written outlines before me. Counsel were unable to locate any directly relevant authorities. The submissions of the appellant in relation to point 1 can be summarised in this way: The respondent’s argument on point 1 is relatively straightforward. It is that the terms of the order made at the finalisation of the proceedings - being what might be described as the usual order for costs without limitation or reservation - do not leave any room for reading the order down by reference to offers or counter-offers made at some earlier time. The answer to the contest over point 1 is to be found in analysis of the temporal aspect of the assessment required of the deputy registrar under the rules.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established