Thompson v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL

CITATION:

Thompson v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2024] NSWPICMP 597

CLAIMANT:

Belinda Thompson

INSURER:

Allianz Insurance Australia Limited

REVIEW PANEL

PRINCIPAL MEMBER:

John Harris

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Drew Dixon

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

David Gorman

DATE OF DECISION:

23 August 2024

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999; claim for proposed lumbar spine fusion; delay in recorded complaint; clinical note three months after accident indicated back pain commenced previous week; claimant denied accuracy of note; discussion of authorities on fallibility of human recollection and caution in accepting notes recorded by medical practitioners; various factors supported claimant’s history that the motor accident caused discal injury to the lumbar spine; clinical examination of claimant; condition had deteriorated sufficient to warrant surgery; Diab v NRMA Ltd applied and discussed; discussion of causation; material contribution between injury and proposed surgery; AAI Limited v Phillips applied; reference made to injury findings; ongoing degenerative process; injury materially contributed to surgery; Held – proposed surgery reasonable and necessary and caused by the accident; original medical assessment revoked.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE

Review Panel assessment of treatment and care

Certificate issued under s 63 of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999

The Review Panel revokes the certificate of Medical Assessor Home dated 21 August 2023 and issues a new certificate determining that:

1.      The following treatment and care:

·        future anterior lumbar interbody fusion surgery (ALIF surgery) proposed by treating surgeon Dr Ralph Mobbs,

RELATES TO THE INJURY CAUSED BY THE MOTOR ACCIDENT.

2.     The following treatment and care:

·        future anterior lumbar interbody fusion surgery (ALIF surgery) proposed by treating surgeon Dr Ralph Mobbs,

is REASONABLE AND NECESSARY in the circumstances.

REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Belinda Thompson (the claimant) was involved in a motor accident on 16 January 2016. The claimant was a front seat passenger when her vehicle was t-boned by the insured vehicle which collided into the passenger side.[1]

    [1] Insurer’s bundle, p 8.

  2. The insurer is liable to pay Ms Thompson any damages under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (the MAC Act).

  3. A medical assessment matter is determined in accordance with Part 3.4 of the MAC Act. This means that the matter is determined at first instance by a Medical Assessor[2] and, pursuant to s 63 of the MAC Act, on review by a review panel.

    [2] Section 60 of the MAC Act.

  4. The present disputes between the parties are whether the treatment provided or to be provided to the injured person is reasonable and necessary in the circumstances and whether any such treatment relates to the injury caused by the motor accident.

  5. These constitute medical assessment matters and medical disputes within the meaning of the MAC Act.[3]

    [3] See ss 57 and 58 of the MAC Act.

  6. The medical disputes were referred to Medical Assessor Home who issued a Medical Assessment Certificate dated 21 August 2023 (the Medical Assessment Certificate).

  7. The specific medical disputes were:

    ·        whether the future anterior lumbar interbody fusion surgery (ALIF surgery) proposed by treating surgeon…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thompson v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICMP 597
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Thompson v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited involves Ms Thompson, a passenger in a motor vehicle accident, who sought compensation for a proposed lumbar spine fusion surgery. The insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, disputed the causal connection between the accident and the proposed surgery, as well as the necessity of the surgery. The dispute was adjudicated in a court that addressed the legal issues concerning the causation and necessity of the surgery in relation to the motor accident.

The court had to determine whether the proposed anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF) surgery was causally related to the motor accident and whether it was reasonable and necessary. The court considered various factors, including the claimant's history, clinical examination, and radiological investigations, alongside the fallibility of human recollection and the reliability of clinical notes. The court applied established legal principles, including those from Diab v NRMA Ltd and AAI Limited v Phillips, to assess causation and the material contribution of the accident to the proposed surgery.

In reaching its decision, the court meticulously evaluated the evidence presented. It acknowledged the claimant's history of back pain and radiculopathy following the accident, supported by clinical examination findings and radiological evidence of disc degeneration. The court held that the proposed surgery was both reasonable and necessary, as it was causally related to the injuries sustained in the motor accident. The insurer's argument regarding the delay in reporting the pain and the accuracy of the clinical notes was addressed with caution, recognising the inherent uncertainties in human memory and the potential for retrospective recording of symptoms. Ultimately, the court found that the injury materially contributed to the need for surgery.

The court revoked the original medical assessment and determined that the proposed surgery was both reasonable and necessary and causally related to the motor accident. The claimant's condition had deteriorated sufficiently to warrant the surgery, and the insurer's objections were overruled.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Thompson was medically examined by Medical Assessor Dixon. The examination report is as follows:“BackgroundThe claimant has worked for NSW Corrective Services from 2002 to the present. At the time of the subject motor vehicle accident, she was a Probation Parole Officer and now works in case management. Social HistoryShe is married and she and her husband live in the Southern Highlands in their own home. Her main hobby was breeding and showing dogs, which she is no longer able to do. She has not been able to groom the dogs or run the dogs on show. She does have difficulty doing heavy household cleaning chores and has difficulty with prolonged standard and meal preparation, cooking and washing up and has difficulty carrying heavy laundry and groceries and doing the garden and cleaning the car. She has difficulty with prolonged driving and does not play sport. She has limited recreational walking on even terrain. She is not able to walk on irregular terrain. She does have some difficulty dressing. History of the motor vehicle accident She was a front seat passenger in a Volvo driven by a sales rep at Lindfield with her husband in the back seat. It was being demonstrated to her as a vehicle for sale. As they were travelling along Powell Street at Killara a vehicle on the left failed to give way and collided with the passenger’s side of the vehicle, pushing it to the opposite side of the road until it impacted on the kerbing. The accident was major in that the front wheel of the Volvo snapped off and although the claimant was wearing a seat belt at the time and all the airbags deployed, she had pain in her lower back and left arm. Police and ambulance attended the scene but she did not require immediate attention. The vehicle was towed away and was later written off. She was able to return to her usual duties apart from right sided back pain which was aggravated by prolonged sitting and repetitive bending and stooping. She had difficulty doing computer based activities and had to stand intermittently. Three months after the accident she developed significant radicular complaint with pain radiating to the posterior right thigh to the dorsum of her right foot with development of sensory changes in the calf and onto the foot. History of treatment since the subject accidentShe was prescribed analgesia and anti-inflammatory and referred for physiotherapy treatment. She continues physiotherapy core strengthening exercises to date. She had a CT of the lumbar spine on 6 March 2017 which showed an L4/5 disc protrusion with canal stenosis and the right lateral stenosis, potentially compressing the L5 nerve root. She took Panadeine Forte for pain relief and a subsequent MRI of the lumbar spine on 13 May 2021 showed moderate disc bulging with L4/5 level disc osteophyte change more marked on the right causing mild bilateral femoral stenosis. She was referred to Dr Ray Mobbs, neurosurgeon, who noted combination of pain at L3/4 and L4/5 levels with facet arthralgia and recommended injections at these levels with PRP injections and post injection hydrotherapy, physiotherapy and therapeutic exercise programme with an exercise physiologist. He also advised the claimant that she may require a spinal fusion. Current SymptomsShe continued to have pain in her lower back with shooting pain in the right buttock radiating to the posterior aspect of her right thigh in the dorsum of her right foot with loss of sensation extending to the 1st and 2nd toes and had difficulty with prolonged sitting and standing.At examination at PIC rooms at 1 Oxford Street on 19 July 2024 she presented in a straight forward manner and there was no embellishment.There was stiffness of her lumbar segment with flexion decreased by one third with slow and jerky recovery with erector spinae muscle spasm with pain on back extension which was decreased by one half and lateral flexion to the right decreased by one third and that to the left by one quarter. Her straight leg raise on the left was 60 degrees and on the right 50 degrees, associated with low back pain and right sciatica. Her knee jerks were present and symmetrical. Her right hamstring jerk was difficult to elicit and her ankle jerks were present. There was 2cm of wasting of her right thigh and 1cm of wasting of her right leg below the knee. There was sensory alteration on the dorsal foot extending towards the right great toe in an L5 distribution. Her sciatic nerve root stress test was positive on the right.She walked with a slow gait and had a limp on the right on toe walking associated low back pain and she was unsteady on heel walking and had to take her weight on the left leg. Her squat test was restricted by one half and associated with back pain and right thigh pain. Her plantar responses were negative, her distal power of the right great toe was grade 4 out of 5.Radiological investigationsHer investigations as noted above include a CT of the lumbosacral spine on 6 March 2017 which showed a disc protrusion L4/5 with central canal narrowing.MRI of the lumbar spine on 3 October 2019 showed degenerative change L3/4 and L4/5 with disc bulge at L3/4 with focal left foraminal protrusion with narrowing and L4/5 right sided disc space loss. Progress MRI of the lumbar spine on 13 May 2021 showed no significant interval change with left L3/4 foraminal stenosis and moderate disc bulge at L4/5. MRI of the right hip on 10 March 2022 showed mild hip OA, gluteal tendinopathy and trochanteric bursitis.The chiropractic documents requested were not available. It was noted in the claimant's third Statutory Declaration that she attended physiotherapy five times during late February to mid-April 2019 and had some chiropractic treatment. The medical disputes were:1. Whether the future anterior lumbar interbody fusion surgery (ALIF) by Dr Ralph Mobbs and Dr Bill Patrick is causally related to the subject motor vehicle accident; and2. Whether future anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF) surgery proposed by the treating neurosurgeon, Dr Ralph Mobbs and Dr Bill Patrick, trauma surgeon, is reasonable and necessary in relation to the subject accident. Based on her findings today, the claimant has deteriorated since she was assessed by Dr Alan Home. She has increased low back pain and right L5 radiculopathy.Today she reported she was taking Tapentadol for pain relief and Mobic as an anti-inflammatory. The conclusion is that the claimant has had deterioration in her lower back since the subject motor vehicle accident. She has low back pain with lumbar stiffness with dysmetria, erector spinae muscle spasm and right sided L5 radiculopathy.This is causally related to injuries received in the subject motor vehicle accident. The proposed ALIF in the lumbar spine by Dr Ralph Mobbs is both reasonable and necessary. The proposed ALIF surgery proposed by Dr Ralph Mobbs is causally related to the injuries received in the subject motor vehicle accident.There appears have been deterioration in the claimant’s back with ongoing radiculopathy, noting the opinion expressed by Associate Professor Shatwell that she tended to take a stoic approach to her injuries and was not one to visit doctors. She showed no inconsistency today and presented in a straight forward manner without embellishment.”