| COURT OF APPEAL | [1999] QCA 487b |
| de JERSEY CJ McMURDO P HELMAN J | |
| Appeal No 10123 of 1999 | |
| PETER ANDREW THOMAS AND | |
| KAREN ELIZABETH THOMAS | Appellant (Plaintiff) |
| and | |
| BRADNAM'S WINDOWS & DOORS PTY LTD | Respondent (Defendant) |
| BRISBANE | |
| ..DATE 23/11/99 | |
| 231199 T3/JAP22 M/T COA 285/99 |
THE CHIEF JUSTICE: A District Court Judge gave summary judgment against two guarantors
of a company's debt. The guarantors, the present applicants, were the directors and
shareholders of the debtor company.
When the summary judgment application came on for hearing they took the point that the
company had just been placed under the administration of two chartered accountants. The
company was itself a defendant to the action.
The guarantee could not be enforced against the applicants as directors of the company in
administration without the leave of the Court because of section 44J subsection 1 of the
Corporations Law. The reference to "the Court" in section 44J(1) is to "the Court" spelt
significantly with a capital "C".
The applicants had submitted that that referred only to the Supreme Court. The learned District
Court Judge was however persuaded that he had jurisdiction and granted leave. He relied on
section 42B of the Corporations (Queensland) Act 1990 which confers jurisdiction with respect
to civil matters under the Corporations Law on the lower Courts.
On the other hand it specifically excepts "superior Court matters" which are defined by section
41 of subsection 1 of that Act to mean civil matters which the Corporations Law "quite clearly
intends (for example, by use of 'the Court') to be dealt with only by a superior Court".
The provision requiring the grant of leave, section 440J(1) refers, as I have said, to "the Court",
using the capital "C" designation. I believe that must be taken to indicate unequivocally that the
granting of leave in such situations as this is confined to the Supreme Court, and I observe that
231199 T3/JAP22 M/T COA 285/99
that accords with what I believe to be established practice.
Further support for this emerges indeed from section 58AA subsection 2 of the Ccorporations
Law itself, which is to similar effect. Regrettably, therefore the order granting leave must be set
aside. In the course of submissions we raised with the parties the question whether this Court,
which is, of course, the Supreme Court, should not now consider exercising a discretion to grant
leave.
The approach taken by the learned District Court Judge based on the observations of Thomas
JA in BBC Hardware Limited v. GT Homes Limited [1997] 2 Queensland Reports 123 seems
unexceptional. However, it is also a matter of practice that on applications for leave of this
character the liquidator or the administrator as the case may be is given the opportunity to be
h
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Thomas v Bradnam's Windows and Doors P/L and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] QCA 487
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The reasoning of the Court of Appeal was based on the interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions and the established practice of the Courts. The Court of Appeal noted that section 44J(1) of the Corporations Law referred to "the Court" with a capital "C", which they interpreted as indicating that leave could only be granted by a superior Court. Furthermore, the Court of Appeal found that it was a matter of practice for the liquidator or administrator to be given the opportunity to be heard on such applications for leave. In light of these factors, the Court of Appeal decided to stand the matter down to allow the administrators to be heard on the question of whether leave should be granted. The Court of Appeal also decided to reserve costs pending its further consideration of the matter. This decision highlights the importance of established practice and statutory interpretation in determining the jurisdiction of the Courts in matters relating to the enforcement of guarantees against directors of companies in administration.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.