Thomas Borthwick & Sons (Australia) Pty Ltd v Osborne

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

99.107

COURT OF APPEAL

de JERSEY CJ McPHERSON JA FRYBERG J

Appeal No 6746 of 1998

THOMAS BORTHWICK & SONS

(AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD Appellant (Defendant)
and
EUNICE MARGARET OSBORNE Respondent (Plaintiff)

BRISBANE
..DATE 07/04/99
THE CHIEF JUSTICE: This appeal is brought against
an order under Order 35 Rule 21 of the Rules of
the Supreme Court granting the plaintiff leave to
deliver interrogatories for the examination of the
defendant.
The order was made by a learned Chamber Judge on
14 July 1998. The appellant's appeal having been
instituted, the interrogatories were not answered
and following preliminary intimations towards the
end of 1998, the plaintiff's solicitors notified
the appellant's solicitors on 19 February 1999
that the plaintiff no longer required the

appellant to answer the interrogatories.

The appeal was based on contentions that the
appellant should have been given the opportunity
to be heard before His Honour, picking up the
words of Order 35 Rule 21 paragraph 1 which
indicate that application without notice to any
other person might be made "subject to an order of

the Court or a Judge".

The second contention was that the learned Judge
should not have been satisfied that there was "not
likely to be available to the applicant at the
trial any other reasonably simple and inexpensive
way of proving the matter sought to be elicited by
interrogatory".
It is worth noting, as the Court of Appeal pointed
out in Suncorp General Insurance Limited v.
Ranger, No 4583 of 1998 in an unreported judgment
delivered on 17 August that year, that special
circumstances should be demonstrated before the
Court sanctions departure from that second limb of
Rule 21,

paragraph 1.

In any event, further ventilation of those
contentions is now academic. Mr Alldridge who
appeared for the appellant urged us nevertheless
to embark upon a determination on the merits
because as he suggested it would be helpful to
litigants in the relevant part of Queensland were
these points determined or perhaps on one view, in
light of Ranger's case, again confirmed by the

Court of Appeal.

It would however in my opinion be contrary to the
way this Court should proceed for us now to make
supposedly authoritative determinations or further
determinations on points which have become in

truth academic.

The only issue now remaining is the issue of costs
and in that regard, one has in mind Order 91 Rule
16 headed "Costs when further proceedings become
unnecessary" and the Full Court's approach in The
Queen v. The Gold Coast City Council ex parte
Raysun Pty Ltd (1971) QWN 13.
One should in these circumstances form some
judgment as to the prima facie reasonableness of
the appellant's appeal. I have reached the view
that it lacked any apparently reasonable basis. I
draw that from the way in which the primary Judge
was approached.

Counsel for the appellant did not seek to be heard before His Honour upon the hearing of an otherwise ex parte application on the basis for example that he might…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thomas Borthwick & Sons (Australia) Pty Ltd v Osborne and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QCA 107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Thomas Borthwick & Sons (Australia) Pty Ltd v Osborne, the appellant, Thomas Borthwick & Sons (Australia) Pty Ltd, appealed against an order granting the respondent, Eunice Margaret Osborne, leave to deliver interrogatories to the appellant for the purpose of examination. The appellant argued that the Chamber Judge should have allowed it to be heard before making the order and that the judge should not have been satisfied that there were no other reasonably simple and inexpensive ways of proving the matter sought to be elicited by the interrogatories. However, the appeal became academic as the respondent later notified the appellant that she no longer required the appellant to answer the interrogatories.

The court had to decide whether the appellant should have been given the opportunity to be heard before the judge when the order was made, and whether the judge was correct in being satisfied that there were no other reasonably simple and inexpensive ways of proving the matter sought to be elicited by the interrogatories. The court held that it would not be appropriate to make determinations on these points as they had become academic. Instead, the court considered the issue of costs and found that the appellant's appeal lacked any apparently reasonable basis. The court ordered that up to 19 February 1999, each party's costs be costs in the proceedings and that the appellant pay the respondent's costs to be taxed from and after 19 February 1999.

The court dismissed the appeal and ordered that up to 19 February 1999, each party's costs be costs in the proceedings and that the appellant pay the respondent's costs to be taxed from and after 19 February 1999. The judges agreed with the decision and the orders were made accordingly.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.