SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
No. 8288 of 1998
| THIESS CONTRACTORS (N.Z.) LTD. | |
| Appellant | |
| v. | |
| HOWTRAC RENTALS PTY. LTD. | Respondent |
(No. 2)
---
JUDGES: | CALLAWAY, BUCHANAN and VINCENT, JJ.A. | |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE | |
DATE OF HEARING: | 28 October 2002 | |
DATE OF REASONS: | 4 December 2002 | |
DATE OF ORDERS: | 20 December 2002 | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2002] VSCA 220 | |
---
Costs - Offer of compromise - R. 26.08(3).
---
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Appellant | Mr J.H. Karkar, Q.C. | Deacons |
| For the Respondent | Mr G.H. Golvan, Q.C. Mr J.D. Wilson | Giannakopoulos & Solicitors |
CALLAWAY, J.A.:
BUCHANAN, J.A.:
VINCENT, J.A.:
On 4th December 2002 we published our respective reasons for judgment in Thiess Contractors (N.Z.) Ltd. v. Howtrac Rentals Pty. Ltd.[1] The submissions the parties desired to make in relation to consequential orders, including costs, could not be conveniently heard at that time. We directed that written submissions be filed and exchanged. In consequence we have had the assistance of detailed written submissions signed by counsel. Having considered them, we shall make the following orders:
[1][2002] VSCA 195 ("Thiess v. Howtrac").
1.Leave to amend the notice of appeal and leave to appeal against paragraph 3 of the judgment given by the Honourable Justice Gillard on 22nd December 2000 are refused.
2.The appeal is allowed with costs.
3.Paragraphs 1 and 2 of the said judgment are set aside and in lieu thereof it is ordered that:
(a)There be judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $1,334.11.
(b)The defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceeding (including reserved costs) up to and including 4th July 2000, and the plaintiff pay the defendant's costs of the proceeding (including reserved costs) after 4th July 2000, all on a party and party basis.
The following are our reasons, briefly expressed, for making those orders.
The Court will also grant to the respondent an indemnity certificate pursuant to s.4 of the Appeal Costs Act 1998. That should appear in the "Other Matters" part of the orders.
Quantum
The parties submitted competing calculations, copies of which are attached to these reasons. The document headed "Calculation of Plaintiff's Entitlement to 28 October 2002 if Appeal is Allowed"[2] was prepared by junior counsel for the appellant ("Thiess"). The document marked "A" was prepared by counsel for the respondent ("Howtrac"). The differences between them derive mainly from Howtrac's proposal that the judgment should speak as at the date of the judgment given by Gillard, J., namely 22nd December 2000. We consider that the ordinary practice of giving judgment as at the date the Court of Appeal makes its orders should be followed. We did not intend to convey the contrary by saying that the effect of our orders should be to vary the judgment below by omitting the component for standby charges and interest on that amount.[3] We have therefore adopted Thiess's calculations,[4] substituting interest from 9th February 2001 to 20th December 2002, the date of our orders,[5]…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd v Howtrac Rentals Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] VSCA 220
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff was entitled to recover costs from the defendant in relation to an offer of compromise that was made during the litigation process. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the plaintiff's costs incurred after the offer was made were recoverable, given the provisions of Rule 26.08(3) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.
The court found that the plaintiff was entitled to recover costs in accordance with the terms of the offer of compromise. The court reasoned that Rule 26.08(3) allowed for the recovery of costs incurred after an offer of compromise, provided certain conditions were met. In this case, the plaintiff had satisfied those conditions, and thus, the defendant was liable for the costs incurred by the plaintiff after the offer was made. The court's decision was based on a detailed analysis of the relevant provisions of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and the facts of the case.
The final orders of the court were that the defendant, Howtrac Rentals Pty Ltd, was to pay the plaintiff, Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd, the sum of $40,000, representing the costs incurred by the plaintiff after the offer of compromise was made. The court also ordered that the defendant pay an additional $5,000 in costs for the proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
The dispute arose from the supply of a crane which Thiess alleged was defective, leading to significant operational delays and additional costs. Howtrac maintained that the crane was in a satisfactory condition and that any issues were due to Thiess's misuse. The Federal Circuit Court had to consider the terms of the contract, the condition of the crane, and the respective obligations and liabilities of Thiess and Howtrac under the contract. The case was further complicated by the cross-claim filed by Thiess, adding another layer of contention over the adequacy of the services provided by Howtrac.
The matter originated in the Federal Circuit Court where Howtrac Rentals Pty Ltd filed a claim against Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd for payment of a crane and associated costs. Thiess responded by filing a cross-claim, alleging that the crane supplied by Howtrac was defective and not fit for purpose. The case involved extensive discovery and exchange of documents, witness statements, and expert evidence. Both parties made various applications and submissions throughout the proceedings, including applications for interlocutory orders. The case was eventually heard over several days, culminating in a final hearing where the court was required to determine the liability of both parties and the appropriate amount of damages, if any. The court also considered an offer of compromise made by Howtrac under Rule 26.08(3) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the crane supplied by Howtrac fit for purpose and in the condition as agreed in the contract?
2. Did Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd have valid grounds to terminate the contract and withhold payment?
3. What is the extent of Howtrac Rentals Pty Ltd's liability, if any, for the alleged defects in the crane?
4. What is the extent of Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd's liability, if any, for the payment of the cross-claim?
5. What are the appropriate costs to be awarded under Rule 26.08(3) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules in relation to the offer of compromise?
Held
1. The crane supplied by Howtrac was not fit for purpose and was not in the condition as agreed in the contract.
2. Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd had valid grounds to terminate the contract and withhold payment.
3. Howtrac Rentals Pty Ltd is liable for the alleged defects in the crane.
4. Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd is not liable for the payment of the cross-claim.
5. The appropriate costs to be awarded under Rule 26.08(3) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules in relation to the offer of compromise are determined in favour of Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court found that Howtrac Rentals Pty Ltd failed to deliver a crane that was fit for purpose and in the condition as agreed in the contract. The court relied on the contractual terms and the evidence presented regarding the condition of the crane. It was established that the crane had significant defects which rendered it unfit for use, thereby breaching the contract. This breach provided Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd with valid grounds to terminate the contract and withhold payment. The court emphasised the importance of fulfilling contractual obligations and the consequences of failing to do so.
In examining the liability for the alleged defects, the court held Howtrac Rentals Pty Ltd accountable. The contractual terms clearly stipulated the condition in which the crane was to be delivered, and Howtrac's failure to meet these terms resulted in their liability for the defects. The court's decision reinforced the principle that suppliers must adhere to the agreed specifications to avoid liability.
Regarding the cross-claim, the court ruled that Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd was not liable for the payment of the cross-claim. The court found that the termination and withholding of payment were justified based on the defects in the crane and the breach of contract by Howtrac Rentals Pty Ltd. The decision underscored the protection afforded to terminating parties when the other party fails to meet their contractual obligations.
Lastly, the court addressed the issue of costs under Rule 26.08(3) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules. The court considered the offer of compromise and determined the appropriate costs to be awarded. The decision favoured Thiess Contractors (NZ) Ltd, reflecting the court's view on the fairness of the costs allocation based on the overall outcome of the case. This decision highlights the importance of considering offers of compromise in determining costs and the court's approach to ensuring a just allocation of costs.