Theodorou v Ord Minnett Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Theodorou v Ord Minnett Holdings Pty Ltd [2024] FedCFamC2G 530

File number(s): SYG 1229 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS
Date of judgment: 12 June 2024
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – whether applicant who was employed by respondent as a Private Client Adviser was covered by cl B6 of Schedule B to the Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2010 (Award) – held covered – whether commission payments respondent made to the applicant could be set off against obligations respondent had to make payments under the Award – set off not available – declarations of contravention made.
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 763A(1), 763B(1), 766A, 766B, 911A, 911B, 916A, 946A(1), 947B, 947C

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 16(1), 16(2), 44(1), 45, 46(1), 46(2), 47, 48(1), 87, 90, 99, 116, 136, 137, 143, 147(3), 535(1), 535(2), 535(3)

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) regs 1.09, 1.12, 3.42

Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2010 cls 4.1, 4.2, 13.1, 13.2, 20.1, 24.3, Sch B, B.6

CommSec Award 2006 cls 4.1, 9    

Cases cited:

ACE Insurance Ltd v Trifunovski (No 2) [2012] FCA 793

Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited v Finance Sector Union of Australia [2001] FCA 1785

Automatic Fire Sprinklers Pty Ltd v Watson [1946] HCA 25; (1946) 72 CLR 435

Brown v Listaglen Pty Ltd [1994] IRCA 158

Christopher Barker & Sons v Commissioners of Inland Revenue [1919] 2 KB 222

Curro v Beyond Productions Pty Ltd (1993) 30 NSWLR 337

Finance Sector Union of Australia v Comsec Trading Limited and Others - PR960317 [2005] AIRC 637

Kucks v CSR Ltd (1996) 66 IR 182

Miles v Wakefield Metropolitan District Council [1987] AC 539

Minister of State for the Army v Dalziel (1944) 68 CLR 261

Pacific Publications Pty Ltd v Cantlon (1983) 4 IR 415

Poletti v Ecob [1989] FCA 492

R v Darling Island Stevedore & Lighterage Co Ltd ; Ex parte Halliday and Sullivan (1938) 60 CLR 601

Ray v Radano [1967] AR (NSW) 471

Re City of Wanneroo v Michael Lindsay Holmes [1989] FCA 369

Steal v Smith (1817) 1 B & Ald 94

Sunrise Brokers LLP v Rodgers [2015] ICR 272

Vines v Djordjevitch (1955) 91 CLR 512

Wolfer v Computer Associates Pty Ltd [1995] IRCA 185

WorkPac Pty Ltd v Rossato [2020] FCAFC 84

Division: Fair Work
Number of paragraphs: 165
Date of hearing: 19 and 20 October 2022, and 1 December 2022
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr A Britt
Solicitor for the Applicant: WilliamsonBarwick
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J Darams
Solicitor for the Respondent: Lander & Rogers Lawyers

ORDERS

SYG 1229 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

EVANGELOS ROBERT THEODOROU

Applicant

AND:

ORD MINNETT HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED ACN 062 323 728

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS

DATE OF ORDER:

12 JUNE 2024

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.By failing to pay to the applicant on a weekly or, in the alternative a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Theodorou v Ord Minnett Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 530
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Theodorou v Ord Minnett Holdings Pty Ltd, the applicant, Mr Theodorou, sought to determine whether he was covered by the Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2010 (Award) and if the commission payments made by the respondent could be set off against the obligations under the Award. The court had to decide whether the applicant's employment as a Private Client Adviser was covered by cl B6 of Schedule B to the Award, and whether the commission payments could be set off against the respondent's obligations under the Award.

The court found that the applicant's employment was covered by the Award, as the tasks he performed were regulated by an award and were not traditionally uncovered by awards. The court held that the services provided by the respondent through its Wealth Advice business, including direct investment advice, portfolio management, and portfolio administration and managed accounts, were financial services within the meaning of the Corporations Act. Consequently, the respondent's Wealth Advice business was subject to the disclosure and other requirements prescribed by Chapter 7 of the Corporations Act.

Regarding the set off issue, the court found that the set off was not available as the commission payments could not be considered as a debt or sum of money due from the applicant to the respondent. The court held that the commission payments were a form of remuneration and could not be set off against the respondent's obligations under the Award. The court further found that the respondent had contravened the Award by failing to pay the minimum wages and annual leave loading to the applicant.

The court made declarations of contravention of the Award and ordered the respondent to pay the applicant the minimum wages and annual leave loading, along with interest, within 28 days from the date of the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There are three principal items of evidence that describe Ord Minnett’s Wealth Advice business.Mr Deva’s evidence The first is the evidence given by Mr George Deva, who is a director of Ord Minnett Ltd (a subsidiary of Ord Minnett), and who occupies the position of “Head of Private Wealth”. Mr Deva deposes as follows (emphasis added):[3]The Respondent is a wealth management company. Its business is centred around providing full-service stockbroking to its clients. Full-service stockbroking means that our advisers offer advice on buying and selling equities, making recommendations, providing and conducting research, and creating tailored investment plans for our clients. This can be contrasted to online-only or execution-only stockbrokers, which offer no recommendations or advice regarding the appropriateness of their customers’ investment decisions.[3] Affidavit G Deva 28.03.2022, [7] Mr Deva says that the full range of services Ord Minnett offers include “Private Wealth . . . whose Private Client Advisers primarily provide advice on stockbroking on ASX . . . and international exchanges on all the major stock markets around the world”; advice on investments; research; corporate finance; institutional broking; intermediary service; private capital; and “the administration of portfolios (delivered through platforms owned by the Respondent such as Portfolio Administration and Reporting Service [PARS] or the Unified Managed Account [UMA])”.[4] Mr Deva further says:[5]In addition to providing full-service stockbroking, the Private Wealth arm of the Respondent also provides advice on portfolio construction, superannuation and self-managed superannuation funds, estate planning, significant investor visas, deceased estates and sequential equities strategy. These additional services leverage on the Respondent’s expertise in providing advice and producing its own research on equities.[4] Affidavit G Deva 28.03.2022, [9][5] Affidavit G Deva 28.03.2022, [10] Mr Deva does not refer to marketing or other documents it is reasonable to expect Ord Minnett has issued or published which describes its Wealth Advice business, and the services it offers through that business. As will appear in a moment, however, there are documents in evidence which show that although Ord Minnett does provide through its Wealth Advice business “[d]omestic and international full-service broking and securities trading”, it is but one of the services it provides, the others being direct investment advice, portfolio management, and portfolio administration and managed accounts.[6] For these reasons, Mr Deva’s evidence is of limited value in identifying the nature of Ord Minnett’s business, and in particular, the nature of its Wealth Advice business.[6] Affidavit E R Theodorou 24.12.2021, [5]; exhibit ERT-1, tab 4, page 70, [2.4]The Information Memorandum The second item of evidence that describes Ord Minnett’s Wealth Advice business is a document titled “Information Memorandum” (Information Memorandum) that was prepared by Ord Minnett Investments Limited in around the second half of 2019 in support of an invitation to persons to apply for fully paid ordinary shares in that company.[7] The Information Memorandum provides a detailed description of Ord Minnett’s businesses as at 30 June 2019; and I find it constitutes the best evidence of the nature of the businesses Ord Minnett conducted, at least as at around 30 June 2019 and, by inference, from at least around 2013. The Information Memorandum states as follows:[7] Affidavit E R Theodorou 24.12.2021, [12]; exhibit ERT-1, tab 4(a)Ord Minnett is an Australian based financial services firm offering clients a diverse range of services encompassing two broad subsectors of the “financial services industry”, these being “Private Wealth Management”, and “Corporate Advisory and Equities”.[8][8] Affidavit E R Theodorou 24.12.2021, [5]; exhibit ERT-1, tab 4, page 58, [1.1](b)Whilst Australian investors have access to a range of investment opportunities, “the primary focus of Ord Minnett is providing investors access to investment products via equity markets both domestic and global”.[9][9] Affidavit E R Theodorou 24.12.2021, [5]; exhibit ERT-1, tab 4, page 58, [1.2](c)The Australian Private Wealth industry is serviced by a broad range of financial service providers, offering an extensive range of financial services with the goal of assisting clients in achieving their financial objectives. These services generally comprise of investment advice, securities broking, financial planning, and portfolio management for individuals, trusts, self-managed superannuation funds, non-for-profit organisations, and other private clients.[10][10] Affidavit E R Theodorou 24.12.2021, [5]; exhibit ERT-1, tab 4, page 59, [1.3.1](d)Operators in the Australian Private Wealth sector are “typically segmented into four primary groups, being Banks, Stockbrokers, Independently managed Super funds and Independent financial advisers”.[11][11] Affidavit E R Theodorou 24.12.2021, [5]; exhibit ERT-1, tab 4, page 59, [1.3.1](e)Ord Minnett has become one of Australia’s leading financial services companies, “advising clients on all aspects of finance including full-service stockbroking, financial planning, funds management, portfolio services and corporate finance”.[12][12] Affidavit E R Theodorou 24.12.2021, [5]; exhibit ERT-1, tab 4, page 68, [2.2](f)Ord Minnett’s operations are split into three key operating segments, these being “Wealth Advice”, “Capital Markets”, and “Other lines of business”.[13] The Information Memorandum contains a table that provides information in relation to each of the three segments of Ord Minnett’s operations, with the Wealth Advice segment including the following information:[14][13] Affidavit E R Theodorou 24.12.2021, [5]; exhibit ERT-1, tab 4, page 69, [2.4][14] Affidavit E R Theodorou 24.12.2021, [5]; exhibit ERT-1, tab 4, page 70, [2.4]

Decision

Reasons for decision

Thus, even if Mr Theodorou’s role or activities were those of a stockbroker, the work he performed as an employee of Ord Minnett is not of a nature that was not regulated at all by an award; and his role was not one that was not “traditionally covered at all by awards”, as I have construed that expression. Thus, if Mr Theodorou were to bear the onus of proving that the Proviso did not apply to his employment, he would have discharged that burden.Conclusion I am satisfied that the Award covered Mr Theodorou’s employment with Ord Minnett. That means that, subject to any set off to which Ord Minnett may be entitled, Ord Minnett failed to comply with the following clauses of the Award:(a)Clause 13.1(a) of the Award, which provides that the Employer must pay a “full-time adult employee . . . a minimum rate for their classification as set out in the table below”, the minimum rate for a Level 6 classification being a minimum annual salary of $56,290 at a minimum weekly rate of $1,082.50.(b)Clause 24.3 of the Award, which provides for the payment of a 17.5% loading for annual leave. There is in evidence a report prepared by “Acknowledge Accounting” (Calculation Report) that has calculated the minimum wages and annual leave loading to which Mr Theodorou would have been entitled under the Award for the period 1 July 2015 to 13 December 2019.[131] Ord Minnett has not submitted that the calculations are incorrect, and I am therefore prepared to find the calculations are correct.[131] Affidavit A G Barwick 23.12.2021, [17]; annexure AGB-13CLAIMS UNDER NES It is common ground that if the Award applied to Mr Theodorou’s employment, he would have been entitled to receive amounts pursuant to s 90, s 99, and s 116 of the FW Act. Section 90 provides as follows:(1)If, in accordance with this Division, an employee takes a period of paid annual leave, the employer must pay the employee at the employee’s base rate of pay for the employee’s ordinary hours of work in the period.(2)If, when the employment of an employee ends, the employee has a period of untaken paid annual leave, the employer must pay the employee the amount that would have been payable to the employee had the employee taken that period of leave. “Annual leave” is a reference to the entitlement to annual leave provided for by s 87 of the FW Act. The expression “base rate of pay” of an employee is defined in s 16(1) of the FW Act to mean “the rate of pay payable to the employee for his or her ordinary hours of work”. That is subject to s 16(2), which applies to a “pieceworker”. Given the findings I have made, it is not necessary to consider whether Mr Theodorou was a “pieceworker”. The Calculation Report has calculated Mr Theodorou’s annual leave entitlements, untaken annual leave entitlements, public holiday entitlements, personal or carer’s leave entitlements, and compassionate leave entitlements. Ord Minnett has not submitted that the calculations are incorrect, and I am therefore prepared to find the calculations are correct.SET OFF

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Each of the services Ord Minnett provides through its Wealth Advice business is a “financial service” within the meaning of s 766A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act). That means that Ord Minnett’s Wealth Advice business is subject to the disclosure and other requirements prescribed by Chapter 7 of the Corporations Act; and it is necessary to describe the main features of those regulatory requirements as they apply to Ord Minnett because those requirements may be relevant to identifying and characterising the tasks Mr Theodorou performed when Ord Minnett employed him. The expression “financial service”, as defined in s 766A of the Corporations Act, includes providing “financial product advice”, and dealing in a “financial product”. “Financial product” is defined in s 763A(1) of the Corporations Act to mean “a facility through which, or through the acquisition of which, a person”, among other things “makes a financial investment” or “manages financial risk”. Under s 763B(1) of the Corporations Act, a person (investor) makes a “financial investment” if:(a)the investor gives money or money’s worth (the contribution) to another person and any of the following apply:(i)the other person uses the contribution to generate a financial return, or other benefit, for the investor;(ii)the investor intends that the other person will use the contribution to generate a financial return, or other benefit, for the investor (even if no return or benefit is in fact generated);(iii)the other person intends that the contribution will be used to generate a financial return, or other benefit, for the investor (even if no return or benefit is in fact generated); and(b)the investor has no day‑to‑day control over the use of the contribution to generate the return or benefit. “Financial product advice” is defined in s 766B(1) of the Corporations Act to mean:a recommendation or a statement of opinion, or a report of either of those things, that:(a)is intended to influence a person or persons in making a decision in relation to a particular financial product or class of financial products, or an interest in a particular financial product or class of financial products; or(b)could reasonably be regarded as being intended to have such an influence. Subsection 766B(2) of the Corporations Act provides there are two types of financial product advice, namely, “personal advice”, and “general advice”. Subsection 766B(4) provides that “[g]eneral advice” is “financial product advice that is not personal advice”; and “personal advice” is defined in s 766B(3) to mean:financial product advice that is given or directed to a person (including by electronic means) in circumstances where:(a)the provider of the advice has considered one or more of the person’s objectives, financial situation and needs (otherwise than for the purposes of compliance with the Anti‑Money Laundering and Counter‑Terrorism Financing Act 2006 or with regulations, or AML/CTF Rules, under that Act); or(b)a reasonable person might expect the provider to have considered one or more of those matters.