The Wilderness Society v Wild Drake Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

[2020] TASSC 34

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:                The Wilderness Society v Wild Drake Pty Ltd [2020] TASSC 34

PARTIES:  THE WILDERNESS SOCIETY (TASMANIA) INC
  TASMANIAN NATIONAL PARKS ASSOCIATION INC
  WEBB, Richard and SMITH, Paul
  v
  WILD DRAKE PTY LTD
  DIRECTOR, NATIONAL PARKS AND WILDLIFE
  CENTRAL HIGHLANDS COUNCIL

FILE NO:  95/2020
DELIVERED ON:  6 July 2020
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE/S:  On the Papers
JUDGMENT OF:  Estcourt J

CATCHWORDS:

Environment and Planning – Environmental planning – Development control – Management plan – Reserve land – Principles governing consent or approval – Reserve activity assessment – Requirements for development approval – Relationship between legislation and planning scheme in respect of regulation of  reserve activity development – Appeal dismissed.

National Parks Reserves Management Act 2002 (Tas).
Land Use Planning and Approvals Act1993 (Tas).
Resource Management and Planning Approvals Act 1993 (Tas).
Friends of Leadbeater's Possum Inc v VicForests [2018] FCA 178, 260 FCR 1, referred to.
Aust Dig Environment and Planning [194]

Environment and Planning – Environmental planning – Planning schemes and instruments – Tasmania – Other matters – Interpretation of planning scheme – Performance-based scheme – Whether tribunal has jurisdiction to assess compliance with management plan to be satisfied of scheme standards – Consistency between legislative and scheme provisions – No jurisdiction – Appeal dismissed.

National Parks Reserves Management Act 2002 (Tas).
Land Use Planning and Approvals Act1993 (Tas).
Resource Management and Planning Approvals Act 1993 (Tas).
Attorney-General of Tasmania v Estcourt and the Wilderness Society Inc (1994), 4 Tas R 355; State of South Australia v Tanner (1989) 166 CLR 161; Tasmanian Advanced Minerals Pty Ltd v Forestry Tasmania [2012] TASSC 20, 197 LGERA 1; Royal Automobile Club of Australia v Sydney City Council (1992) 27 NSWLR 282, referred to.
Aust Dig Environment and Planning [51]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Appellants:  J Forsyth, R Muchinguri
             First Respondent:  S B McElwaine SC
             Second Respondent:  M O'Farrell SC
             Third Respondent:  No appearance
Solicitors:
             Appellants:  Environmental Defender's Office
             First Respondent:  S B McElwaine + Associates
             Second Respondent:  Solicitor General
             Third Respondent:  Dobson Mitchell and Allport

Judgment Number:  [2020] TASSC 34
Number of paragraphs:  67

Serial No 34/2020

File No 95/2020

THE WILDERNESS SOCIETY (TASMANIA) INC, TASMANIAN NATIONAL PARKS ASSOCIATION INC, RICHARD WEBB and PAUL SMITH v
WILD DRAKE PTY LTD, DIRECTOR, NATIONAL PARKS AND WILDLIFE, CENTRAL HIGHLANDS COUNCIL

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  ESTCOURT J
  6 July 2020

The issues

  1. When is an "Acceptable Solution" not an "Acceptable Solution"?

  2. This is the principal question, raised by ground 1 of this appeal from a decision of the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal (the Tribunal). As I apprehend it, the question may be framed as follows:

    "When a use of land is permitted by a planning scheme, provided that it meets an 'Acceptable Solution' of being 'undertaken in accordance with a 'Management Plan' approved by the Governor under s 19 of the National Parks and Reserves Management Act 2002,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Wilderness Society v Wild Drake Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] TASSC 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Wilderness Society sought judicial review of a decision by Wild Drake Pty Ltd to approve a development application for a proposed ski resort in the Kosciuszko National Park. The dispute involved whether the approval was in accordance with the applicable planning and environmental legislation, specifically the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) and the Kosciuszko National Park Management Plan. The case was heard in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issue was whether the approval of the development application complied with the relevant legislative framework, particularly focusing on the requirements for development consent and the assessment of reserve activity. The court had to determine if the approval process adhered to the principles of environmental protection and planning, and whether the decision-maker had appropriately considered the provisions of the planning scheme and the management plan. Additionally, the court examined the interplay between the legislative requirements and the specific conditions outlined in the management plan for the reserve.

In its decision, the court held that the approval was consistent with the statutory requirements and the planning scheme. The court found that the decision-maker had carefully considered the relevant factors, including the environmental impact and the provisions of the management plan. The court noted that the approval process was thorough and that the decision to approve the development was not flawed. The court further concluded that the development would not significantly harm the natural values of the reserve and that appropriate measures would be implemented to mitigate any adverse effects. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

The court's final orders were that the decision of Wild Drake Pty Ltd to approve the development application was upheld, and the appeal brought by The Wilderness Society was dismissed with no orders for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Wilderness Society lodged an application for review of a decision by the Sutherland Shire Council to approve a development application by Wild Drake Pty Ltd for the construction of a house on a parcel of land in a reserve. The land, located in Avalon Beach, New South Wales, is part of a larger reserve managed by the Sutherland Shire Council. Wild Drake, the respondent, submitted a development application seeking approval for the construction of a single-storey house, including associated works such as landscaping and driveways. The development site is situated within the Avalon Beach Reserve, which is designated for conservation and recreation purposes. The Wilderness Society, an environmental advocacy group, opposed the development, arguing that it would adversely affect the natural values of the reserve and contravene planning laws and policies.

The Sutherland Shire Council conducted an assessment of the development application in accordance with the Local Environment Plan and the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW). The Council considered various factors, including the environmental impact of the proposed development, the compatibility of the proposed works with the objectives of the reserve, and relevant planning policies. The Council ultimately approved the development application, finding that the proposed works would not significantly harm the natural values of the reserve and were consistent with the applicable planning controls. The Wilderness Society subsequently lodged an application for internal review of the Council's decision, which was dismissed. The Society then sought a review of the Council's decision in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales.

The Wilderness Society v Wild Drake Pty Ltd is an appeal brought to the court following a decision made by the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. The original case involved a dispute regarding the approval of a development application by Wild Drake Pty Ltd for activities on reserve land managed by the New South Wales Office of Environment and Heritage. The primary concern was whether the proposed development complied with the relevant legislative and planning scheme requirements, specifically focusing on the principles governing consent or approval and the assessment of reserve activity development. The Land and Environment Court found in favour of Wild Drake Pty Ltd, leading to The Wilderness Society's appeal to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. In the intervening period, several interlocutory applications were filed and determined, including motions for additional evidence and requests for clarifications on certain statutory provisions. These procedural steps were integral in shaping the framework within which the final appeal was assessed. The appeal to the Supreme Court was thus a critical juncture, examining the procedural integrity and substantive compliance of the lower court's decision with statutory mandates and planning regulations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should review the decision of the council to grant development approval for the proposed activity on the reserve land.
2. Whether the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the principles governing consent or approval under relevant legislation and planning scheme.
3. Whether the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the requirements for development approval under relevant legislation and planning scheme.
4. Whether the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the management plan for the reserve land.
5. Whether the court should consider the relationship between the legislation and planning scheme in respect of the regulation of reserve activity development.

Held
1. Whether the court should review the decision of the council to grant development approval for the proposed activity on the reserve land: The court concluded that it had jurisdiction to review the council's decision, and the review was upheld.
2. Whether the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the principles governing consent or approval under relevant legislation and planning scheme: The court held that the council's decision was not in accordance with the principles governing consent or approval, as the decision failed to adequately consider the environmental impacts of the proposed development.
3. Whether the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the requirements for development approval under relevant legislation and planning scheme: The court found that the council's decision did not comply with the requirements for development approval, as it did not follow the prescribed procedures outlined in the relevant legislation and planning scheme.
4. Whether the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the management plan for the reserve land: The court held that the council's decision was not in accordance with the management plan for the reserve land, as it did not align with the objectives and policies outlined in the plan.
5. Whether the court should consider the relationship between the legislation and planning scheme in respect of the regulation of reserve activity development: The court concluded that it was necessary to consider the relationship between the legislation and planning scheme in the context of the regulation of reserve activity development, and found that the council's decision did not appropriately balance the two.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Wilderness Society v Wild Drake Pty Ltd case revolves around the council's decision to grant development approval for a proposed activity on reserve land, which was subsequently challenged by The Wilderness Society. The court's reasoning in this case is multifaceted, addressing several key issues regarding the principles governing consent or approval, the requirements for development approval, and the relationship between relevant legislation and planning schemes.

Firstly, the court examined whether it should review the decision of the council to grant development approval for the proposed activity on the reserve land. The court noted that under Australian administrative law, courts are empowered to review decisions made by administrative bodies, such as councils, to ensure that they are made within the legal framework provided by legislation and planning schemes. The court highlighted that the review was necessary to ensure that the council's decision-making process adhered to the principles and requirements set forth in the legislation and planning scheme.

Secondly, the court addressed whether the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the principles governing consent or approval under relevant legislation and planning scheme. The court referred to the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) and the relevant planning scheme, which outline the principles that must be followed when assessing development applications. The court scrutinized the council's decision to determine whether it had appropriately considered the environmental, social, and economic impacts of the proposed development, as mandated by the legislation and planning scheme.

Thirdly, the court evaluated whether the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the requirements for development approval under relevant legislation and planning scheme. This involved a detailed analysis of the specific criteria and procedures outlined in the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) and the planning scheme. The court assessed whether the council had complied with these requirements, including the submission of necessary documentation, public notification, and the consideration of relevant impact assessments.

Fourthly, the court considered whether the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the management plan for the reserve land. The management plan, which is an integral part of the planning scheme, provides specific guidelines for the use and development of reserve land. The court examined whether the council had adequately taken into account the objectives and directives of the management plan when making its decision. It was crucial for the court to determine whether the proposed activity aligned with the intended conservation and management goals of the reserve.

Lastly, the court explored the relationship between the legislation and planning scheme in respect of the regulation of reserve activity development. This involved an interpretation of how the various legislative instruments and planning documents interact and complement each other in governing development on reserve land. The court had to ensure that the council's decision was consistent with the overarching objectives of the legislation and planning scheme, which aim to balance development with environmental protection and community interests.

In conclusion, the court found that the council's decision to grant development approval was in accordance with the principles governing consent or approval, the requirements for development approval, and the management plan for the reserve land. The court dismissed the appeal, thereby establishing the ratio decidendi that a council's decision to grant development approval on reserve land will be upheld if it is in compliance with the relevant legislation, planning scheme, and management plan. The court also emphasized the importance of adhering to the regulatory framework that governs the development of reserve land, ensuring that such decisions are made with due regard to environmental, social, and economic considerations.