|
BRISBANE
28th June, 1991
Re: Appeal against decision of Land Court -
Valuation of Land Act.
(AV90-174).
The Valuer-General
ats
Queensland ClubJ U D G M E N T
This appeal is brought by the Valuer-General against the determination of the Land Court which fixed the unimproved value of land owned by the respondent and situated on the corner of Alice and George Streets, Brisbane, in the sum of $2,435,000 for rating and taxing purposes. The Valuer-General valued the land in the sum of $4.4 million. The valuation was made under the provisions of the Valuation of Land Act 1944 - 1987 (the Act). The date as at which the value is required to be ascertained is 31st March, 1989 (the relevant date).
The relevant land has an area of 3,990 square metres. It is improved land. It houses the Queensland Club. This establishment possesses characteristics which by the Town Plan for the City of Brisbane (the Plan), (the relevant part becoming effective in February, 1989), is part of the heritage of the City. The aim of the Plan is to conserve the building in its entirety. It is one of some 77 buildings included (in whole or in part) in the Table of Heritage Buildings following Section 22 (Heritage) of the Plan and being that part of the Plan, the subject of the arguments before the lower Court and before this Court. The respondent argues that Heritage is a matter of relevance in ascertaining unimproved value in that, assuming the land were unimproved land at the relevant date, the owner would be restrained from achieving what he could achieve in the absence of Heritage and under the zoning of the land "Special Development (City Residential)". The sum determined in the lower Court is an agreed sum and represents the unimproved value of the land on the assumption that Heritage is a matter going to unimproved value in the circumstances of this case. Alternatively it is agreed that if Heritage does not apply, the appropriate value is the sum of $4.4 million.
Section 22 deals with Heritage. We make no attempt, nor is it relevant that we attempt, to examine the provisions as they may relate or interrelate to particular lands embraced in some way within the veil of Heritage. But some general remarks are made in order to distinguish the particular matter before the Court. What the Council of the City has recognised is contained within the introduction to this part of the Plan as follows:"The Council recognises that places within the City, because of a number of factors including their architectural or historical characteristics, become part of the heritage of the City.
These areas, where these places group together and take on an overall heritage character, may include a particular part of the City or a street frontage of a building or a series of buildings that are held in high community esteem. In each case it is necessary to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Valuer-General v Queensland Club and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1991] QLAC 18
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the statutory framework, particularly Section 12 of the Valuation of Land Act 1944-1987, which requires the unimproved value to be determined "assuming that the improvements did not exist." The court explored relevant case law, including Toohey's case and Tetzner v. Colonial Sugar Refining Co. Ltd, to understand the implications of the statutory language. The respondent argued that the restrictions on land use due to heritage status should be factored into the unimproved value, while the Valuer-General contended that the restrictions should only be considered if they would have existed even if the improvements had not been made.
The court concluded that statutory restrictions affecting the land's use, such as those stemming from its heritage status, must be taken into account in determining the unimproved value. The court found that the Valuer-General's approach had no foundation in law, as it ignored the impact of the heritage restrictions on the land's potential value. The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Land Court was affirmed. The court further ruled that the respondent was entitled to costs of the appeal, considering the matter as a test case that would benefit all parties involved.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi