The Union Pastoral Company Pty Ltd (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

The Union Pastoral Company Pty Ltd (Migration) [2020] AATA 2618 (27 May 2020)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REVIEW APPLICANT:  The Union Pastoral Company Pty Ltd

VISA APPLICANT:  Mr Oybek Niyazov

CASE NUMBER:  1820552

DIBP REFERENCE(S):  BCC2018/1261454

MEMBER:Amanda Mendes Da Costa

DATE:27 May 2020

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the application for a Temporary Business Entry (Class UC) visa for reconsideration, with the direction that the applicant meets the following criteria for a Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)) visa:

·Public Interest Criterion 4020(1) for the purposes of cl.457.224(1) of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.

Statement made on 27 May 2020 at 1.43pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Temporary Business Entry (Class UC) visa – Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)) – bogus document/false information – work reference – consistent evidence – decision under review remitted

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958, ss 5, 20, 65, 351

Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2, cl 457.224; Schedule 4, PIC 4020

CASES

Arora v MIBP [2016] FCAFC 35

Batra v MIAC [2013] FCA 274

Khan v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FCA 75

Trivedi v MIBP [2014] FCAFC 42

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration on 26 June 2018 to refuse to grant the applicant a Temporary Business Entry (Class UC) visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The applicant applied for the visa on 16 March 2018. The delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that the applicant did not satisfy the requirements of cl.457.224 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations) because the delegate was not satisfied that the applicant met Public Interest Criteria (PIC) 4020(1).

  3. The review applicant was represented at the hearing on 29 January 2020 by Mr Barry Crimmins, the Human Resources Manager of the review applicant. Mr Crimmins gave evidence and presented arguments on behalf of the company. The Tribunal also received oral evidence from Mr Oybek Niyazov (the visa applicant). A further hearing took place on 3 April 2020 to enable Mr Bahtiyor Mavlyanov (the owner and manager of the farm in Uzbekistan where the visa applicant is employed) to give evidence. The Tribunal hearing was conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the Uzbek and English languages.

  4. The review applicant was represented in relation to the review by its registered migration agent.

  5. Given that Mr Crimmins was located in Warrnambool, the migration agent was in Adelaide and the visa applicant and Mr Mavlyanov were located in Uzbekistan, both hearings were conducted by telephone. Mr Crimmins chose not to participate in the second hearing (due to work commitments) but provided the Tribunal with prior written consent to the review applicant’s migration agent representing the company at the second hearing.

  6. The documents provided by the review applicant for the purpose of the review included the following:

    ·Statement of Oybek Niyazov dated 21 January 2020.

    ·Statements of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Union Pastoral Company Pty Ltd (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 2618
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by The Union Pastoral Company Pty Ltd against a decision regarding a Temporary Business Entry (Class UC) visa, Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)). The core of the dispute revolved around whether the applicant had provided a bogus document or false and misleading information in support of their visa application, thereby engaging Public Interest Criterion (PIC) 4020. The case was heard by Amanda Mendes Da Costa.

The legal issues before the court were whether the applicant had provided a bogus document or information that was false or misleading in a material particular, as defined by PIC 4020(1) and section 5(1) of the Migration Act 1958. The court was required to determine if the discrepancies identified by the Department between the applicant's interview responses and the provided employment reference constituted a failure to meet this criterion, and whether the delegate had adequately articulated which specific document or information was considered false or misleading and its relevance to the visa criteria.

The court reasoned that while PIC 4020 can be engaged even if the applicant was unaware the information was untrue, an element of fraud or deception by some person is necessary. The court considered the applicant's submissions that inconsistencies in farm size, animal numbers, employee numbers, and distance from town were due to approximations, changes over time, or the farm's size. Furthermore, the court noted that the applicant did not know the farm owner by name, referring to him as "boss," and that the phone number provided for farm management was not understood by the acting manager due to a language barrier. Crucially, the court found that the delegate had not clearly identified the "bogus" document or articulated which information was false or misleading and how it related to the visa criteria.

Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration. The Tribunal directed that the applicant met PIC 4020(1) for the purposes of cl.457.224(1) of Schedule 2 to the Regulations, indicating that the initial refusal based on this criterion was not upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

While PIC 4020 refers to information that is false, in the sense of purposely untrue, it is not necessary for the Minister (or the Tribunal on review) to conclude that the applicant was aware the information was purposely untrue in order for PIC 4020 to be engaged. However, an element of fraud or deception by some person is necessary to attract the operation of the provision: Trivedi v MIBP [2014] FCAFC 42.Background On 16 March 2018 the applicant provided an employment reference from the Kelajak Avlod dairy farm (in Andijan, Uzbekistan) in support of his visa application. This reference was purportedly authored and signed by the head of the farm, Bahtiyor Mavlyanov. In this reference, Mr Mavlyanov attested to the visa applicant’s employment at the farm. The reference was referred to the Department office overseas for verification of authenticity. On 17 May 2018 a Departmental officer attempted to contact the telephone number listed on the employment reference. The call was answered by a man who could not speak either Russian or English. On the same day, the Departmental officer contacted the applicant to conduct an interview in relation to the applicant’s employment claims. The officer had the following concerns about the applicant’s responses:·The applicant stated the Kelajak Avlod farm was 20 hectares in size, when in the employment reference Mr Mavlyanov stated it was 16.3 hectares.·The applicant stated the farm had 200 sheep and 500 milking cows, when the employment reference stated that there were 200 cattle and 1,000 sheep.·The applicant stated there were 8–9 employees at the farm and during the morning shift, he worked with 2 other employees. However, the employer stated there were two shifts with 10 employees in each shift.·The applicant stated he worked 38 hours per week, whilst the employer stated 45 hours per week.·The applicant stated the farm was located 15 minutes by car from Andijan (20 km) but according to a map and open sources, the journey was 33 km from Andijan, a journey of 37–40 minutes by car. The applicant claimed he was employed at the farm in September 2016 and attended weekly meetings with the head of the farm but was unable to recall the man’s name. The applicant stated he worked with his immediate supervisor, Lochinbek, and provided his telephone number. However, this number belonged to the head of the farm, whose name the applicant could not recall. The Departmental officer called this number but it was out of service. Based on the results of the interview, the Departmental officer found that the reference document provided by the applicant was ‘non-genuine’, given the contradictions between the document and the applicant’s account in his interview. The delegate found that the applicant had provided a document which was bogus and had provided false and misleading information to the Department. On 23 January 2020 the Department provided a certificate to the Tribunal pursuant to s.376 of the Act, in which it certified that the disclosure of the information contained in folios ADD2020/366309 of its file for the applicant would be contrary to the public interest because it would disclose the Department’s investigation planning and methods to detect breaches of the law. This information consists of notes taken by a Departmental officer of an interview with the applicant which took place on 17 May 2018 and information regarding the Department’s internal investigation methods.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in this review is whether the visa applicant meets Public Interest Criterion 4020 (PIC 4020) as required by cl.457.224 for the grant of the visa. Broadly speaking, this requires that:·there is no evidence that the applicant has given, or caused to be given, to the Minister, an officer, the Tribunal, a relevant assessing authority or Medical Officer of the Commonwealth, a bogus document or information that is false or misleading in a material particular in relation to the application for the visa or a visa that the applicant held in the 12 months before the application was made: PIC 4020(1); and·the applicant and each member of the family unit has not been refused a visa because of a failure to satisfy PIC 4020(1) during the period starting 3 years before the application was made and ending when the visa is granted or refused, unless the applicant was under 18 at the time the application for the refused visa was made: PIC 4020(2) and (2AA); and·the applicant satisfies the Minister as to his or her identity: PIC 4020(2A); and ·neither the applicant nor any family unit member has been refused a visa because of a failure to satisfy PIC 4020(2A) during the period starting 10 years before the application was made and ending when the visa is granted or refused, unless the applicant was under 18 at the time the application for the refused visa was made: PIC 4020(2B) and (2BA). The requirements in PIC 4020(1) and (2) can be waived if there are certain compelling or compassionate reasons justifying the granting of the visa: PIC 4020(4). However, this waiver does not apply to the identity requirements in PIC 4020(2A) and (2B). PIC 4020 is extracted in the attachment to this decision.Has the applicant given, or caused to be given, a bogus document or information that is false or misleading in a material particular? The term ‘information that is false or misleading in a material particular’ is defined in PIC 4020(5) and the term ‘bogus document’ is defined in s.5(1) of the Act (see the attachment to this decision). In contrast to the definition of ‘information that is false or misleading in a material particular’ in PIC 4020(5), the reference in the definition of bogus document to a document that was obtained because of a ‘false or misleading’ statement has no requirement that it be relevant to a criterion for the grant of the visa: Arora v MIBP [2016] FCAFC 35; Batra v MIAC [2013] FCA 274. The requirement in PIC 4020(1) not to provide a bogus document or false or misleading information applies whether or not the Minister became aware of the bogus document or information that is false or misleading in a material particular because of information given by the applicant: PIC 4020(3). It also applies whether or not the document or information was provided by the applicant knowingly or unwittingly.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Based on the above, the applicant does satisfy PIC 4020(1) for the purposes of cl.457.224(1).DECISION The Tribunal remits the application for a Temporary Business Entry (Class UC) visa for reconsideration, with the direction that the applicant meets the following criteria for a Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)) visa:·Public Interest Criterion 4020(1) for the purposes of cl.457.224(1) of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.Amanda Mendes Da CostaMemberATTACHMENTMigration Regulations 1994Schedule 44020(1) There is no evidence before the Minister that the applicant has given, or caused to be given, to the Minister, an officer, the Tribunal during the review of a Part 5 reviewable decision, a relevant assessing authority or a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth, a bogus document or information that is false or misleading in a material particular in relation to:(a)the application for the visa; or(b)a visa that the applicant held in the period of 12 months before the application was made.(2)The Minister is satisfied that during the period:(a)starting 3 years before the application was made; and(b)ending when the Minister makes a decision to grant or refuse to grant the visa;the applicant and each member of the family unit of the applicant has not been refused a visa because of a failure to satisfy the criteria in subclause (1).(2AA)However, subclause (2) does not apply to the applicant if, at the time the application for the refused visa was made, the applicant was under 18.(2A)The applicant satisfies the Minister as to the applicant’s identity.(2B)The Minister is satisfied that during the period:(a)starting 10 years before the application was made; and (b)ending when the Minister makes a decision to grant or refuse to grant the visa;neither the applicant, nor any member of the family unit of the applicant, has been refused a visa because of a failure to satisfy the criteria in subclause (2A).(2BA)However, subclause (2B) does not apply to the applicant if, at the time the application for the refused visa was made, the applicant was under 18.(3)To avoid doubt, subclauses (1) and (2) apply whether or not the Minister became aware of the bogus document or information that is false or misleading in a material particular because of information given by the applicant.(4)The Minister may waive the requirements of any or all of paragraphs (1)(a) or (b) and subclause (2) if satisfied that:(a)compelling circumstances that affect the interests of Australia; or(b)compassionate or compelling circumstances that affect the interests of an Australian citizen, an Australian permanent resident or an eligible New Zealand citizen;justify the granting of the visa.(5)In this clause:information that is false or misleading in a material particular means information that is:(a)false or misleading at the time it is given; and(b)relevant to any of the criteria the Minister may consider when making a decision on an application, whether or not the decision is made because of that information. …Migration Act 1958s.5 Interpretation(1) In this Act, unless contrary intention appears:…bogus document, in relation to a person, means a document that the Minister reasonably suspects is a document that:(a)purports to have been, but was not, issued in respect of the person; or(b)is counterfeit or has been altered by a person who does not have authority to do so; or(c)was obtained because of a false or misleading statement, whether or not made knowingly. …

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal also questioned Mr Mavlyanov about the telephone call to the farm’s mobile phone in May 2018. He confirmed that he had been on leave when that call was made and Mr Lochinbek Iminov had been acting as farm manger in his absence. He further confirmed that Mr Iminov does not speak either English or Russian.Statement of Hoa Oan (registered migration agent) Mr Oan is the visa applicant’s previous migration agent. He states that the Department issued his client with an s.57 notice (inviting him to comment on adverse information) prior to the delegate’s decision to refuse his visa application. Due to a server error, the email containing the s.57 notice was not received by him. This meant that the visa applicant did not have an opportunity to respond to the notice. Although Mr Oan attempted to communicate this to the Department, the delegate’s decision had already been made and it was too late for the visa applicant to explain his position to the Department.Statement of Lochinbek Iminov Mr Iminov has been employed at the Kelajak Avlod farm since 2013 in the position of shift leader. He was managing the farm in the absence of the owner (Bahtiyor Mavlyanov) in May 2018 when he received a telephone call from a person (female) from Russia. Due to his inability to speak either the English or Russian languages, he could not understand this person and thought she telephoned the farm by mistake. Mr Iminov states that the visa applicant has been employed on the farm since September 2016. His duties are the feeding and milking of cows, preparing cows for milking, caring for newborn calves, mending broken fences and taking care of ill animals. Mr Iminov describes the visa applicant as a curious and purposeful worker.Statement of Ergashev Golib Mr Golib has been employed at the Kelajak Avlod farm and has been working with the visa applicant since 2016. He and the visa applicant work the same shift and complete their work tasks together. The visa applicant has taught him many things as he is a more experienced farm worker. Mr Golib describes the visa applicant as a diligent worker who is conscientious, innovative and never quits his tasks.Holmatov Avazbek Mr Avazbek has been employed at the Kelajak Avlod farm since 2017 and has been working with the applicant during that period. Due to his relative inexperience, the visa applicant has been responsible for training him. They work together on the same shift – performing the same tasks which include milking cows in the morning and evening, feeding stock and caring for newborn calves. Review applicant’s submissions The review applicant’s submissions may be summarised as follows:·In his interview with the Departmental officer, the applicant indicated that he could not recall the exact size of the farm and was then asked to provide an approximate answer and gave the response of approximately 20 hectares. The farm’s size increased in 2018 to 19.3 hectares.·Although the reference letter of Mr Mavlyanov was provided to the Department in 2018, the letter was actually written in 2017. This explains the difference in the number of animals on the farm, which changed in the 15 months between the writing of the reference and its submission to the Department. This also applies to the differences between the information given by the visa applicant regarding the number of employees on the farm and the figures given in the reference of Mr Mavlyanov.·The visa applicant’s assessment of the distance of the farm from the town of Andijan was an approximation, and the difference between his information and that contained in other sources is explainable given the size of the town and the region in which it is situated.·The visa applicant referred to Mr Mavlyanov as “boss” and did not know him by name.·The phone number given by the visa applicant to the Departmental officer in the interview was for the farm management. Given that Mr Lochinbek (who does not speak English) was the shift supervisor when the Departmental officer made the telephone call to the farm on 17 May 2018, it is understandable that Mr Lochinbek was unable to communicate with them. ·The delegate does not identify the ‘bogus’ document or documents which he finds have been provided by the visa applicant nor does he articulate which of the information provided by the applicant was false or misleading and how that information is relevant to any of the visa criteria. ·When interviewed by the Departmental officer, the visa applicant was employed on a full-time basis at the Kelajak Avlod dairy farm as a farm worker and had been employed in that position since September 2016.·The visa applicant’s employment history is supported by the letters of support from his work colleagues (including Mr Mavlyanov) and contract of employment and salary certificate.·The inconsistencies in the information provided in the reference letter and the visa applicant’s interview with a Departmental officer do not amount to the provision of false or misleading information by him.·The statements of Mr Mavlyanov dated 6 July 2018 and 21 January 2020 confirms that the visa applicant’s current employment is at Kelajak Avlod farm.