The Trust Company Limited v Valuer-General

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: The Trust Company Limited v Valuer-General [2020]
QLC 39
PARTIES:

The Trust Company Limited
ACN 004 027 749
(appellant)

v

Valuer-General

(respondent)

FILE NOs: LVA326-18
LVA328-18
LVA355-18
DIVISION: General Division
PROCEEDING: Appeals under s 155 of the Land Valuation Act 2010 against objection decision
DELIVERED ON: 13 November 2020
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD ON: 7, 8 September 2020
Submissions closed 23 October 2020
HEARD AT: Brisbane
MEMBER: WA Isdale
ORDERS:

1.     Appeal LVA326-18 is allowed.

2.     The valuation as at 1 October 2017 of Lot 50 on RP907502 property identification number 40147372 having an area of 2,310 m2 and located at 106 Helensvale Road, Helensvale is One Million, One Hundred and Fifty Thousand Dollars ($1,150,000).

3.     Appeal LVA328-18 is allowed.

4.     The valuation as at 1 October 2017 of Lot 348 on RP869217 property identification number 7007745 having an area of 2,246 m2 and located at 182 Monterey Keys Drive, Helensvale is One Million and Eighty Thousand Dollars ($1,080,000).

5.     Appeal LVA355-18 is allowed.

6.     The valuation as at 1 October 2017 of Lot 110 on RP170978 property identification number 510748 having an area of 4,414m2 and located at 46 Mirambeena Drive, Pimpama is One Million, Four Hundred and Thirty Thousand Dollars ($1,430,000).

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – VALUATION OF LAND – SITE VALUE – METHOD OF ASSESSING - COMPARABLE SALE – PREFERENCE OVER OTHER METHODS – where the highest and best use of the subject properties are childcare centres - where the appellant valued a childcare place – where the appellant used the value of the childcare place to arrive at the site value – where this method is analogous to carrying capacity of land – where the respondent adopted a methodology using comparative sales to arrive at the site value on a rate per m2 basis – whether the Court should accepted the novel methodology of appellant.

REAL PROPERTY – VALUATION OF LAND – OBJECTIONS AND APPEALS – QUEENSLAND – where the Court preferred a rate per m2 methodology to value the site – whether the Court should consider alternative methodologies in arriving at the site value.

EVIDENCE – EXPERT EVIDENCE – where an expert valuer sought to rely on lay opinions of valuers not called to give evidence – where lay opinions presented as affidavits – whether lay opinions of assistance in arriving at valuation methodology.

Land Valuation Act 2010, ch 4

Valuer-General v Body Corporate for Tennyson Reach Community Title Scheme 39925 [2018] QLAC 7, cited
Multiplex 240 Queen Street Landowner Pty Ltd & Anor v Department of Natural Resources, Mines and Water [2006] QLC 30, cited
PH Clough v Valuer-General (1981-82) 8 QCLCR 70, cited

APPEARANCES:

JD Byrnes instructed by Colin Biggers and Paisley for the appellant

DA Quayle instructed by In-House Legal for the Valuer-General

Background

  1. The respondent routinely valued these sites as at 1 October 2017, as required by the Land Valuation Act 2010 (the Act). The appellant objected to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Trust Company Limited v Valuer-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QLC 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Trust Company Limited sought to challenge the valuation of three parcels of land in Queensland, each intended for use as childcare centres, arguing that the valuer-general had erred in his assessment methodology. The case was heard by the Queensland Land Court, which had to determine whether the valuer-general's comparative sales method was appropriate or if the appellant's methodology, which valued the childcare place and then used that value to arrive at the site value, should be preferred.

The primary legal issue was whether the Court should accept the appellant's novel methodology, which was analogous to the carrying capacity of the land, over the valuer-general's rate per m2 methodology based on comparative sales. A secondary issue was whether the Court should consider alternative methodologies in arriving at the site value.

The Court found that the valuer-general's methodology, which used comparative sales, was not the only acceptable method for valuing land intended for a specific use. The Court held that the appellant's methodology, which involved valuing the childcare place and then using that value to determine the site value, was a valid and acceptable alternative. The Court noted that the appellant's methodology was analogous to assessing the carrying capacity of land and provided a reasonable basis for determining the value of the land for its highest and best use as childcare centres. The Court also found that the lay opinions presented as affidavits were of assistance in arriving at the valuation methodology.

The Court allowed the appeals and set the valuations of the three parcels of land as specified in the orders section. The Court held that the appellant's methodology was a valid and acceptable alternative to the valuer-general's methodology and that the valuer-general's methodology did not provide a reasonable basis for determining the value of the land for its highest and best use as childcare centres.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal LVA326-18 is allowed.

2. The valuation as at 1 October 2017 of Lot 50 on RP907502 property identification number 40147372 having an area of 2,310 m2 and located at 106 Helensvale Road, Helensvale is One Million, One Hundred and Fifty Thousand Dollars ($1,150,000).

3. Appeal LVA328-18 is allowed.

4. The valuation as at 1 October 2017 of Lot 348 on RP869217 property identification number 7007745 having an area of 2,246 m2 and located at 182 Monterey Keys Drive, Helensvale is One Million and Eighty Thousand Dollars ($1,080,000).

5. Appeal LVA355-18 is allowed.

6. The valuation as at 1 October 2017 of Lot 110 on RP170978 property identification number 510748 having an area of 4,414m2 and located at 46 Mirambeena Drive, Pimpama is One Million, Four Hundred and Thirty Thousand Dollars ($1,430,000).

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established