The Trust Company Limited v Valuer-General

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: The Trust Company Limited v Valuer-General [2021] QLC 9
PARTIES: The Trust Company Limited
(appellant)
v
Valuer-General
(respondent)
FILE NOs: LVA302-19
LVA483-19
LVA720-19
PROCEEDING: Appeal against objection decision on a valuation under the Land Valuation Act 2010
DELIVERED ON: 12 March 2021
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD ON: 12 & 13 November 2020
HEARD AT: Brisbane
PRESIDENT: FY Kingham
ORDERS:

LVA302-19

I allow the appeal for LVA302-19.1.   

1,050,000.I find the correct value of the property at 116 Benfer Rd, Victoria Point is $2.   

LVA483-19

I allow the appeal for LVA483-19.1.   

I find the correct value of the property at 86-88 Coachwood Drive, Flagstone is $1,070,000.2.   

LVA720-19

I allow the appeal for LVA720-19.1.   

$1,250,000.I find the correct value of the property at 385-387 Chatswood Road, Shailer Park is 2.   

Costs

For all three appeals:1.   

by 4:00pm, Friday 26 March 2021, if any party wishes to make submissions on costs, they must file and serve written submissions limited to three pages and costs will be decided on the papers; anda.   

if no party files submissions by that time, each party must bear their own costs of the hearing.b.   

CATCHWORDS:

STATUTES – ACTS OF PARLIAMENT – INTERPRETATION – GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION – where parties did not agree about the operation of s 22 of the Land Valuation Act 2010 –whether it is necessary to make adjustment to site market value when there is an existing development approval – where the appellants contended a value must be assigned to the development approval so that it may be removed – where the Value-General disagreed with this approach – whether the Valuer-General’s approach includes the development approval as part of the unencumbered estate in fee simple – where the Court held that the existing use assumption does not affect the hypothetical estate in fee simple – where the Court considered it incongruent with the plain words used in s 22 to exclude the value of the development approval ­– where the appellants argued the Valuer-General's approach wrongly included the value of an intangible improvement as part of the site value – where the Valuer-General did not assert this – where extrinsic material indicates an intention to exclude the added value of a development approval in valuing a property – where the Court considered added value must mean a value other than that inherent in the authorisation of the use – where the Court held that s 22 does not require the valuers to adjust the value of the subject properties to remove the value of their development approval

VALUATION OF LAND – METHODS OF VALUATION – GENERALLY – where the subject properties are used for childcare centres – where the valuers agreed on the direct comparison method but disagreed about whether valuation should be on a rate per square metre of land or a rate per number of approved long day care places – where the Land Valuation Act 2010 does not prescribe a statutory methodology for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Trust Company Limited v Valuer-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QLC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Trust Company Limited sought judicial review of three property valuations conducted by the Valuer-General under the Land Valuation Act 2010. The Trust Company argued that the Valuer-General had misapplied the statutory provisions in valuing certain properties, leading to undervaluation. The primary issue was whether the Valuer-General correctly assessed the site market value of properties with existing development approvals, specifically whether the value of these approvals should be included in the valuation. Additionally, the dispute encompassed the appropriate method for valuing the properties, particularly whether the valuation should be based on a rate per square metre or a rate per number of approved long day care places. The Court of Appeal had to determine whether the Valuer-General's approach aligned with the statutory requirements and industry practices.

The Court examined the language of section 22 of the Land Valuation Act 2010, concluding that the existing use assumption did not affect the hypothetical estate in fee simple. The Court found it incongruent with the plain words of the statute to exclude the value of the development approval. Furthermore, the Court held that section 22 does not mandate valuers to adjust the value of the subject properties to remove the value of their development approval. Regarding the valuation method, the Court found that the evidence did not establish the appellants' chosen method as an industry practice. Instead, the Court endorsed the valuer for the Valuer-General, whose methodology was deemed more conventional and better suited to assessing the potentiality of the land.

In summary, the Court allowed the appeals, finding that the Valuer-General's valuations were incorrect due to the misapplication of the statutory provisions. The Court established the correct values for the properties in question and outlined the procedure for determining costs, stipulating that if no party files submissions on costs by a specified date, each party must bear their own costs of the hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

LVA302-19

I allow the appeal for LVA302-19.1.

1,050,000.I find the correct value of the property at 116 Benfer Rd, Victoria Point is $2.

LVA483-19

I allow the appeal for LVA483-19.1.

I find the correct value of the property at 86-88 Coachwood Drive, Flagstone is $1,070,000.2.

LVA720-19

I allow the appeal for LVA720-19.1.

$1,250,000.I find the correct value of the property at 385-387 Chatswood Road, Shailer Park is 2.

Costs

For all three appeals:1.

by 4:00pm, Friday 26 March 2021, if any party wishes to make submissions on costs, they must file and serve written submissions limited to three pages and costs will be decided on the papers; anda.

if no party files submissions by that time, each party must bear their own costs of the hearing.b.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Trust Company Limited, together with other appellants, appealed against the valuations of three properties determined by the Valuer-General. The properties were used for childcare centres, and the dispute centred around the valuation of these properties under the Land Valuation Act 2010. The appellants' valuers used a valuation method based on a rate per number of approved long day care places, while the Valuer-General's valuers used a rate per square metre of land. The appellants contended their method was consistent with industry practice and reflected the highest and best use of the properties. They argued that the Valuer-General's valuation method failed to consider the value of the development approval, which should have been factored into the valuation of the properties. The Valuer-General maintained that the existing development approval should be included in the unencumbered estate in fee simple, without the need to separately assign a value to it. This resulted in a disagreement over whether the value of the development approval should be excluded from the site value as an added value or be included as part of the estate in fee simple.

The matter came before the court on appeals against the decisions of the Valuer-General in three separate cases, namely LVA302-19, LVA483-19, and LVA720-19. The appeals were consolidated for hearing and determination. The appellants submitted that the Valuer-General's valuation of the properties was incorrect and that their proposed valuation method should have been adopted. The Valuer-General defended the valuation of the properties and maintained that the chosen methodology was appropriate. The court considered the evidence and arguments presented by both parties and subsequently delivered its decision, allowing the appeals in part and setting aside the Valuer-General's valuation in favour of the court's own assessment of the correct value of the properties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether s 22 of the Land Valuation Act 2010 requires the valuers to adjust the value of the subject properties to remove the value of their development approval.
2. Whether the valuers should adopt a rate per square metre of land or a rate per number of approved long day care places as the appropriate valuation method for the subject properties.
3. Which comparable sales should be considered and how they should be analysed in assessing the valuations made by the respective valuers.

Held
1. The court held that s 22 of the Land Valuation Act 2010 does not require the valuers to adjust the value of the subject properties to remove the value of their development approval.
2. The court held that the valuers should adopt a rate per square metre of land as the appropriate valuation method for the subject properties, as opposed to a rate per number of approved long day care places.
3. The court held that the respondent’s valuer was correct in their selection and analysis of comparable sales, rejecting the appellants’ valuations due to the rejected methodology used by their valuer.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the interpretation of s 22 of the Land Valuation Act 2010 and whether it required an adjustment to the site market value when there was an existing development approval. The appellants argued that a value must be assigned to the development approval so that it may be removed, but the court disagreed. The court reasoned that the existing use assumption does not affect the hypothetical estate in fee simple and that it was incongruent with the plain words used in s 22 to exclude the value of the development approval. The court found that added value must mean a value other than that inherent in the authorisation of the use, and extrinsic material indicated an intention to exclude the added value of a development approval in valuing a property. Therefore, the court held that s 22 does not require the valuers to adjust the value of the subject properties to remove the value of their development approval.
The court then turned to the valuation method used by the valuers. Although the valuers agreed on the direct comparison method, they disagreed on whether the valuation should be on a rate per square metre of land or a rate per number of approved long day care places. The court found that the evidence did not establish the appellants' valuation methodology as an industry practice, and that the statutory valuation must consider that land may be used for any purpose for which it could be used at the date of valuation. The court held that the method used by the valuer for the respondent was conventional and better suited to assess the potentiality of the land.
Finally, the court addressed the issue of the comparable sales. The valuers did not agree on all the comparable sales for each appeal, nor did they agree on how the comparable sales should be analysed. The court rejected the appellants’ valuations because it rejected the methodology used by their valuer. The court considered the appellants’ valuer’s evidence about what sales are comparable and how they should be analysed in assessing the valuations made by the respondent’s valuer, whose methodology the Court did accept. The court’s acceptance of the respondent’s valuer’s methodology led to the rejection of the appellants’ valuations and the acceptance of the respondent’s valuations.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the interpretation of s 22 of the Land Valuation Act 2010 does not require the valuers to adjust the value of the subject properties to remove the value of their development approval. The court also established that the appropriate valuation method for the subject properties was a rate per square metre of land, as opposed to a rate per number of approved long day care places, and that the respondent’s valuer was correct in their selection and analysis of comparable sales.