OFFICIAL NOTICE
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
Application : No. 759725 in the name of Paul Andrew Cronk
Title: Luminaire
Action: Opposition under section 59 by The Sunnyfield Association and an objection to an extension of time under regulation 5.10(2) to serve evidence in support
Decision: Issued 05 July 2004.
Abstract
Extension of time allowed.
There is a pending amendment to the parent of the current application to claim divisional status from another earlier application. If this is allowed, it will back date the priority date of the presently opposed patent application by approximately 18 months. Because all the alleged citations post-date the earliest priority date of the grandparent, the nature of the evidence required in the current opposition will be significantly different depending on the outcome of the amendment. Therefore, until the amendment to the parent is finalised, it is not clear what evidence the parties would require to they need to mount to challenge the current patent application.
The opponent and public interest lies in deferring evidence until the amendments are resolved.
While it could be argued that the opponent failed to properly complete their case in the first instance by failing to identify all relevant citations prior to the priority date of the "grandparent", the applicant's failure to properly claim a priority date before the substantive decision has caused the current problems and the opponent should not be punished for the applicant's conduct.PATENTS ACT 1990
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
Re:Patent Application No. 759725 by Paul Andrew Cronk, Opposition thereto under section 59 by The Sunnyfield Association and an objection to an extension of time under regulation 5.10(2) to serve evidence in support
BACKGROUND
Patent Application 759725 was filed on 17 April 2000 by Paul Andrew Cronk. It claims divisional status from Australian patent application 716550 and additional status from Australian patent 679737. The current application was advertised accepted on 17 April 2003. On 15 July 2003, a notice of opposition was filed by The Sunnyfield Association followed by the Statement of grounds and particulars on 15 October 2003. Evidence in support was initially due on 15 January 2003. The opponent requested and was granted an extension of time to serve evidence in support until 15 April 2004. On 16 April 2004, the opponent requested a second extension of time until 15 July 2004.
The applicant objected to this second extension of time application and the matter was set for hearing in Canberra on 3 June 2004. Both parties appeared by telephone. The applicant was represented by Mr Fraser Old, patent attorney of Fraser Old & Sohn, Sydney and the opponent was represented by Mr Geoff Davidson, patent attorney of Halford & Co, Sydney.
RELEVANT LAW
According to regulation 5.8(2), the time for serving evidence in answer is three months from the date of service of the evidence in support. This time may be extended under regulation 5.10(2) which states:
"(2)The Commissioner may extend…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Sunnyfield Association v Paul Andrew Cronk and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] APO 14
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the Commissioner had the discretion to grant an extension of time under the relevant regulation, and if so, whether such an extension should be granted in the circumstances of this case. The applicant argued that the request for an extension of time was invalid because it was filed one day late and did not mention the appropriate regulation. The court rejected these arguments, noting that there was no prescriptive requirement for an extension to be filed within a specific time limit and that the form did not need to explicitly mention a particular regulation to be considered approved.
The court considered the interests of both parties and the public interest in determining a serious opposition on its merits. The opponent's interests lay in being able to complete their evidence in support, particularly in light of the potential new priority date arising from the amendment to the parent application. The public interest was served by avoiding a multiplicity of proceedings and the wastage of time and expense that may arise from the presentation and consideration of irrelevant evidence. The court concluded that an extension of time was appropriate in all the circumstances and granted an extension until 15 July 2004 to serve evidence in support. The court also proposed directions to manage the proceedings in both the parent and divisional applications, ensuring that all relevant evidence was considered and that the oppositions were determined concurrently.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case involves an opposition under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990 by The Sunnyfield Association against Patent Application No. 759725 by Paul Andrew Cronk. The opponent also filed an objection to an extension of time under regulation 5.10(2) to serve evidence in support. The matter was set for hearing in Canberra on 3 June 2004. Both parties appeared by telephone, with the applicant represented by Mr Fraser Old, patent attorney of Fraser Old & Sohn, Sydney, and the opponent represented by Mr Geoff Davidson, patent attorney of Halford & Co, Sydney.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the request for an extension of time under regulation 5.10(2) was valid despite being filed one day late and not mentioning the appropriate regulation in the request.
2. Whether an extension of time under regulation 5.10(2) should be granted to allow the opponent to serve evidence in support in light of the pending amendment to the parent application to claim divisional status from the grandparent application.
Held
1. The request for an extension of time under regulation 5.10(2) was valid despite being filed one day late and not mentioning the appropriate regulation in the request.
2. An extension of time under regulation 5.10(2) should be granted to allow the opponent to serve evidence in support in light of the pending amendment to the parent application to claim divisional status from the grandparent application.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the applicant's arguments against the validity of the extension request. The applicant claimed the request was invalid because it was filed one day late and did not mention the appropriate regulation. The court found these arguments unpersuasive, stating that there is no requirement for an extension request to be filed before the end of the prescribed period or to explicitly mention the regulation. The court held that the request was valid and that any late filing or technical issues could be easily rectified.
Next, the court considered the related applications and the amendment to the parent application to claim divisional status from the grandparent application. The court found that this amendment could significantly affect the evidence required in the current opposition, as all the cited references would post-date the earliest priority date of the grandparent application. The court held that it was in the best interest of the opponent, the applicant, and the public to defer serving evidence until the amendment to the parent application was finalised.
The court then applied the relevant legal principles in determining whether to grant the extension of time. The court noted that the decision involved a balancing exercise, in which competing considerations must be taken into account. The court held that the public interest in determining a serious opposition on its merits outweighed the need for efficient and orderly proceedings in this case. The court also found that the applicant's failure to properly claim a priority date before the substantive decision caused the current problems, and the opponent should not be punished for the applicant's conduct.
Based on these considerations, the court granted the extension of time under regulation 5.10(2) until 15 July 2004 to serve evidence in support. The court also issued directions for the proceedings to ensure that matters were properly progressed and that costs followed the event.