The Strath Hub Pty Ltd v Alexandrina Council

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

THE STRATH HUB PTY LTD v ALEXANDRINA COUNCIL

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Duggan and The Honourable Justice Anderson)

25 November 2004

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - COURTS AND TRIBUNALS WITH ENVIRONMENT JURISDICTION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - SUPREME COURT - ERRORS OF RELEVANT AUTHORITY

The appellant sought development approval from the respondent council - development was for residential allotments within a Residential (Golf Course) Zone - council refused approval on grounds that the objective in the development proposal did not meet the Zone Plan requirement that the provision of housing and tourist accommodation be 'in assocation' with a golf course - no golf course proposed in plan - a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court granted provisional consent - decision reversed by single Judge of Supreme Court - whether Commissioner erred in finding that the proposal was not at variance with the Plan - whether single Judge should have interfered with Commissioner's finding - held: Commissioner did err in his finding and single Judge correct in reversing decision - appeal dismissed.

Development Act 1993 (SA) section 35(2), referred to.
City of Mitcham v Freckmann (No.2) (2000) 76 SASR 145, applied.

THE STRATH HUB PTY LTD v ALEXANDRINA COUNCIL
[2004] SASC 382

Full Court:       Doyle CJ, Duggan and Anderson JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ           The issue in this appeal is whether, in the decision under appeal, a Judge of this Court was right in deciding that a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources & Development Court had erred by failing to conclude that a proposed development was seriously at variance with the relevant Development Plan.  If the Commissioner had so decided, that would have led to a conclusion that the decision of the Council in question to refuse provisional development plan consent was correct.

  2. The outcome of the appeal turns on an assessment of the proposed development against the provisions of the relevant Development Plan.  In the end a planning judgment is involved, and this Court will usually not interfere with such a judgment unless there has been a significant departure from proper planning principles.

  3. I agree with Anderson J that in his reasons the Judge under appeal has demonstrated that the decision of the Commissioner does involve a fundamental departure from proper planning principles.  I agree with the reasons of the Judge under appeal for so concluding, and I agree with the reasons given by Anderson J for dismissing the appeal.

  4. DUGGAN J                       In my view the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by Anderson J.

  5. ANDERSON J  In this matter, the appellant appeals from a decision of a Judge of this court sitting as the Land and Valuation division which, in turn, was an appeal from the Environment, Resources and Development Court (“the ERD Court”).  The ERD Court reversed the decision of the respondent council when the council refused approval of a proposed development because it was at variance with both Objective 1…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Strath Hub Pty Ltd v Alexandrina Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 382
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Strath Hub Pty Ltd sought approval from Alexandrina Council for residential allotments within a Residential (Golf Course) Zone. The council refused approval on the basis that the proposal did not meet the requirement that the provision of housing and tourist accommodation be 'in association' with a golf course. The Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court granted provisional consent, but this decision was reversed by a single Judge of the Supreme Court. The central issue was whether the Commissioner erred in finding that the proposal was not at variance with the Plan and whether the single Judge should have interfered with the Commissioner's finding. The Supreme Court held that the Commissioner did indeed err in his finding and that the single Judge was correct in reversing the decision. The court found that the proposal was seriously at variance with the Development Plan because the zoning was unusual, there was only one objective in the Plan, and it was intended that residential development be integrated with an 18-hole golf course. The court also considered the timing of the development, which required that a large section of the zone could only be developed after the golf course was completed and in use. Additionally, Policy Area B included the clubhouse, tourist accommodation, restaurant and conference facilities. The proposal finally approved by the Commissioner contained no reference to a golf course, which was a significant departure from proper planning principles. The appeal was dismissed.

The court found that the Commissioner erred in his assessment by not considering the proposal to be seriously at variance with the Plan. The court held that it was appropriate for the single Judge to interfere with the Commissioner's decision because there was a sufficient departure from proper planning principles. The proposal was seriously at variance with the Development Plan for several reasons: the zoning was unusual, there was only one objective in the Plan, it was intended that residential development be integrated with an 18-hole golf course, the timing of the development required that a large section of the zone could only be developed after the golf course was completed and in use, and Policy Area B included the clubhouse, tourist accommodation, restaurant and conference facilities. The proposal finally approved by the Commissioner contained no reference to a golf course. The court concluded that the Commissioner's decision was flawed and that the single Judge was correct in reversing it.

The court emphasised that the specific zoning in the Alexandrina Council area required residential development to be in association with a golf course, as emphasised in the principles of development. The court found it difficult to see how any residential development could proceed in association with a golf course when no golf course was proposed as part of the application. The court considered that the Commissioner placed too much weight on the fact that different owners of different parts of the land were not in agreement and that therefore there may be an unfairness which could be alleviated by allowing the residential development now and with golf course plans to follow in the future. The court held that this was an error by the Commissioner which was appropriately corrected by the single Judge. The court also noted that the Commissioner must have believed that, unless he approved some form of residential development, there was a danger of no development at all because of the view that he took about the financial feasibility of the golf course proposal. However, the court held that approval of the residential development proposal was not conditional upon approval for a development of that facility.

The court held that the Commissioner's decision was flawed because it did not take into account the specific zoning requirements of the area. The court found that the proposal was seriously at variance with the Development Plan because it did not include a golf course, which was a significant departure from proper planning principles. The court held that the single Judge was correct in reversing the Commissioner's decision because there was a sufficient departure from proper planning principles to enable him to do so. The court emphasised that the specific zoning in the Alexandrina Council area required residential development to be in association with a golf course, as emphasised in the principles of development. The court found that the proposal was seriously at variance with the Development Plan for several reasons, including the fact that there was only one objective in the Plan, it was intended that residential development be integrated with an 18-hole golf course, the timing of the development required that a large section of the zone could only be developed after the golf course was completed and in use, and Policy Area B included the clubhouse, tourist accommodation, restaurant and conference facilities. The court held that the proposal finally approved by the Commissioner contained no reference to a golf course, which was a significant departure from proper planning principles. The appeal was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Strath Hub Pty Ltd sought development approval from Alexandrina Council for a residential allotment subdivision within a Residential (Golf Course) Zone. The Council refused approval, stating the proposal did not meet the zone plan requirement for housing and tourist accommodation to be provided in association with a golf course, as no golf course was proposed. Despite this, a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court granted provisional consent, which was later reversed by a single Judge of the Supreme Court. The material facts of the case revolve around the history of the zoning of the area in question, which was initially zoned differently, then changed to its current status following representations. An earlier application for development, which included a golf course, was approved by the council but subsequently lapsed. The current application was made without a golf course. The developer was aware of the importance of the golf course, as evidenced by their subsequent application for an 18-hole par-3 golf course over part of the proposed allotment, which was rejected by the council on the basis that it did not address the intent of the zone. The Commissioner of the ERD Court initially found that the lack of an 18-hole golf course was not fatal to the appeal, but the Supreme Court Judge later found that the Commissioner had erred in his decision and that the single Judge was correct in reversing the decision, leading to the dismissal of the appeal.

The Strath Hub Pty Ltd v Alexandrina Council is an appeal against the decision of a single Judge of the Supreme Court, which reversed a decision made by a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court. The appellant, The Strath Hub Pty Ltd, sought approval from the Alexandrina Council for a residential development within a Residential (Golf Course) Zone, which was ultimately refused by the Council on the basis that the proposed development did not meet the requirement of being "in association" with a golf course as per the Zone Plan. The Commissioner of the ERD Court initially granted provisional consent, but this decision was subsequently reversed by the single Judge of the Supreme Court, leading to the current appeal. Key procedural steps include the initial refusal by the Alexandrina Council, the granting of provisional consent by the ERD Court Commissioner, and the reversal of this decision by the Supreme Court single Judge. The appeal to the Supreme Court focused on whether the Commissioner erred in finding that the proposal was not at variance with the Plan, and whether the single Judge should have interfered with the Commissioner's finding.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOYLE CJ DUGGAN J ANDERSON J
I include these statements as useful summaries which, in my opinion, encapsulate the paradox of an application within this unusual Residential (Golf Course) Zone which does not include a golf course.Council Decision The respondent council gave particulars of its grounds for refusal, and there were various other aspects involved in the decision, but insofar as the golf course is concerned, in particular No.3, the council said:“The proposal does not satisfy Objective 1 for the Zone provision in that the plan of division is principally for residential development and is not being undertaken in concert with tourist accommodation and/or more particularly, a golf course.” It can be seen therefore that whereas this area was previously zoned differently; following representations the zoning was changed to its current status. Then an application, including a golf course, was made and approved by the council, but then that approval lapsed. Finally this current application was made without a golf course. The developer was clearly aware of the importance of the golf course in that it subsequently applied, after the refusal of the land division application, for an 18-hole par-3 golf course over part only of proposed allotment 1 in its efforts to have the proposal approved. As the planner for the council said in relation to the separate application for the par-3 course:“…the proposal does not address the intent of the zone given that it is isolated from the residential development and it is not a golf course in the sense that it is not of a competition standard. The concept plan for the zone demonstrates how a golf course should be integrated throughout the development site. This would allow residents to enjoy the golf course / open-space outlook as well as creating a ‘green’ outlook due to the dominance of trees rather just a typical urban area.”ERD Court In the hearing in the ERD Court, the Commissioner considered that the fact that the proposed subdivision was not integrated with an 18-hole golf course was not fatal to the appeal. It was argued that the learned Judge should not have interfered with the assessment of the Commissioner of the ERD Court by substituting his conclusion because it could not be shown that the ERD Court had done anything other than apply all the relevant provisions of the Plan, and in the end, made a planning judgment. In my view, the Commissioner erred because he did not consider the proposal put forward as being seriously at variance with the Plan. As such, it was appropriate for the learned Judge to interfere because there was a sufficient departure from proper planning principles to enable him to do so. It is my view that the proposal was seriously at variance with the Development Plan for these reasons:1the zoning was unusual;2there was only one objective in the Plan;3it was intended that residential development be integrated with an 18-hole golf course;4the timing of the development required that a large section of the zone could only be developed after the golf course was completed and in use;5Policy Area B includes the clubhouse, tourist accommodation, restaurant and conference facilities;6The proposal finally approved by the Commissioner even after amendment contains no reference to a golf course.Considerations in this Appeal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DOYLE CJ, DUGGAN J, ANDERSON J

In my view, the Commissioner erred because he did not consider the proposal put forward as being seriously at variance with the Plan. As such, it was appropriate for the learned Judge to interfere because there was a sufficient departure from proper planning principles to enable him to do so. It is my view that the proposal was seriously at variance with the Development Plan for these reasons:1the zoning was unusual;2there was only one objective in the Plan;3it was intended that residential development be integrated with an 18-hole golf course;4the timing of the development required that a large section of the zone could only be developed after the golf course was completed and in use;5Policy Area B includes the clubhouse, tourist accommodation, restaurant and conference facilities;6The proposal finally approved by the Commissioner even after amendment contains no reference to a golf course.Considerations in this Appeal There are other different residential zones in the Alexandrina Council area, but in this instance, because of the specific zoning, the provision for residential development is very specific, namely, that such residential development should be in association with a golf course as emphasised in the principles of development. No golf course at all was proposed as part of this application. It is therefore difficult to see how any residential development could proceed in association with it because of the lack of any proper planning as to how the golf course and other open spaces would be utilised as part of the overall development. The Commissioner placed weight on the fact that different owners of different parts of the land were not in agreement and that therefore there may be an unfairness which could be alleviated by allowing the residential development now and with golf course plans to follow in the future. I consider this to be an error by the Commissioner which was appropriately corrected by the learned Judge appealed from. The Commissioner must have believed that, unless he approved some form of residential development, there was a danger of no development at all because of the view that he took about the financial feasibility of the golf course proposal. It was this reasoning which made the separate application for the par-3 golf course attractive to the Commissioner. However, as the learned Judge says at [21]:“…approval of this residential development proposal was not conditional upon approval for a development of that facility.” I agree with the learned Judge when he says at [35]:“To consent to a sub-division of more than one-third of the area of the Zone without any certainty as to whether, where or when a golf course might be created is to compromise the whole objective of the Zone and to render that objective less likely to be achievable.” This identifies the error made in the ERD Court by the Commissioner which was merely a hopeful expectation that one day a golf course may, in some way or other, fit in with the residential development which had preceded it. It was to this end that the Commissioner reasoned that it did not have to be a full-size 18-hole golf course, and that a par-3 golf course would suffice.