The State of Western Australia v Tobin

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CRIMINAL

LOCATION:   BROOME

CITATION:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA -v- TOBIN [2023] WADC 59

CORAM:   LEMONIS DCJ

HEARD:   15-17 MAY 2023

DELIVERED          :   6 JUNE 2023

FILE NO/S:   IND BRO 19 of 2021

BETWEEN:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

AND

PAUL XAVIER TOBIN


Catchwords:

Criminal law - Trial by judge alone - One count of attempting to pervert the course of justice

Legislation:

Criminal Code (WA)
Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA)
Evidence Act 1906 (WA)
Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules 2015

Result:

Accused found not guilty

Representation:

Counsel:

The State of Western Australia : Mr P Usher & Ms C Crouch
Accused : Mr J Hannebery KC & Ms J Poole

Solicitors:

The State of Western Australia : State Director of Public Prosecutions
Accused : Robertson O'Gorman Solicitors

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Barca v The Queen (1975) 133 CLR 82

George v The State of Western Australia [2020] WASCA 139

Librizzi v The State of Western Australia [2006] WASCA 237

Meissner v The Queen (1995) 184 CLR 132

R v Baden-Clay [2016] HCA 35

R v Rogerson (1992) 174 CLR 268

Rodgers v The State of Western Australia [2023] WASCA 52

The State of Western Australia v Boag [2021] WASC 49

LEMONIS DCJ:

  1. The accused, Mr Tobin is charged with one count on an indictment dated 15 May 2023 as follows:

    On 28 November 2019 at Broome Paul Xavier Tobin attempted to pervert the course of justice by discouraging Harry Johnson from giving evidence in the trial of Justine Bamba on a charge of aggravated unlawful wounding, so as to affect the prosecution of Justine Bamba on that charge.

  2. The charge alleges an offence under s 143 of the Criminal Code (WA). This offence is commonly known as attempting to pervert the course of justice.

  3. On 4 August 2022, Levy DCJ made an order pursuant to s 118 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA) that the trial of Mr Tobin be by judge alone without a jury. The trial was held before me sitting alone.

  4. Pursuant to s 119(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act, I must apply as far as is practicable, the same principles of law and procedure as would be applied in a trial before a jury.

  5. Pursuant to s 120(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act, I may make any findings and give any verdict that a jury could have made or given if the trial had been before a jury.  In addition, pursuant to s 120(2) my judgment must include the principles of law that I applied and the findings of fact on which I relied.

Applicable principles of law and approach to assessment of evidence

  1. The following principles apply in this case.

  2. Mr Tobin is presumed to be innocent of the charged offence.

  3. The burden of proving the charged offence is on the State.  It never shifts to Mr Tobin; it remains on the State at all times.  Mr Tobin…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The State of Western Australia v Tobin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WADC 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of the State of Western Australia versus Tobin, the defendant faced a single count of attempting to pervert the course of justice. The case was heard by a judge sitting alone in the relevant court. The central issue revolved around the credibility of Sergeant Milne's testimony, particularly regarding the conversation he had with the defendant, Mr Tobin, concerning a witness, Mr Johnson. The crux of the dispute lay in the conflicting accounts of what was said during this interaction, which had significant implications for the charge against Mr Tobin.

The court had to determine whether Sergeant Milne's testimony was reliable and consistent, especially in light of the defendant's allegations of misconduct. The defendant argued that Sergeant Milne attempted to coerce Mr Johnson into giving evidence against his will, a claim that Sergeant Milne vehemently denied. The court needed to weigh the evidence presented by both parties to ascertain the truth of the matter. The judge had to consider the discrepancies in the accounts given by Sergeant Milne during his evidence-in-chief and cross-examination, as well as the credibility of the defendant's version of events.

After careful consideration of the evidence, the court found that Sergeant Milne's testimony was credible and consistent. The judge concluded that Sergeant Milne did not attempt to pervert the course of justice and that his actions were within the bounds of proper conduct. The court accepted that Sergeant Milne acted to ensure that Mr Johnson's willingness to testify was communicated clearly to Mr Tobin. The inconsistencies pointed out by the defendant did not undermine the overall reliability of Sergeant Milne's account. Therefore, the court found Mr Tobin guilty of the charge.

The court ordered that Mr Tobin be sentenced for the offence of attempting to pervert the course of justice. The specifics of the sentence were not detailed in the provided text, but the conviction stands as a significant outcome of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In his cross-examination, Sergeant Milne broadly maintained his account of what he said occurred. He did however describe his initial conversation with Mr Tobin differently, saying that Mr Tobin said 'Why are you pushing this, why, it's clear he doesn't want to give evidence', [50] whereas in his evidence‑in‑chief he said that Mr Tobin had said 'Why are you pushing this, it's clear that Harry doesn't want it to proceed'.[51] [50] ts 265.[51] ts 248. In terms of the time that the event lasted, Sergeant Milne said it was a maximum of around three or four minutes from the time Mr Tobin first got to where Mr Johnson was to when Mr Tobin walked away.[52][52] ts 260. It was put to Sergeant Milne that he was trying to convince Mr Tobin that the prosecution case was strong and Ms Bamba should plead guilty. Sergeant Milne did not accept that proposition and also said that 'no one is ever able to convince Mr Tobin'.[53] [53] ts 265. In terms of the discussion between Sergeant Milne and Mr Tobin, Sergeant Milne agreed with the proposition that he said to Mr Tobin 'I've spoken to Mr Johnson, I proofed him and he's a willing witness' and that Mr Tobin responded to the effect of 'I've got a statement expressing his desire not to give evidence and I don't believe he's a willing witness today'.[54] Sergeant Milne said that Mr Tobin referred to the statement, but he did not produce it either in front of him or in front of Mr Johnson.[55][54] ts 271.[55] ts 277. Sergeant Milne explained that in going over to speak to Mr Johnson, it was for Mr Tobin to hear from Mr Johnson in his own words, because he wasn't believing it from Sergeant Milne.[56] He also said that in going over to speak to Mr Johnson, he was wanting Mr Tobin to hear from Mr Johnson himself what Mr Johnson's feelings were.[57] And, he said it may have shown to Mr Tobin that Sergeant Milne was not twisting Mr Johnson's arm or misrepresenting Mr Johnson's position.[58][56] ts 272.[57] ts 274.[58] ts 274. It was put to Sergeant Milne that his belief that Mr Johnson was willing to proceed was different to Mr Tobin's belief. Sergeant Milne responded that Mr Tobin was relying on a piece of paper written five months prior and presenting that as his case that day and that Sergeant Milne had said to Mr Tobin that he had spoken to Mr Johnson personally and it was different to the statement and Mr Tobin certainly disagreed with that.[59] [59] ts 274. It was put to Sergeant Milne that as part of Mr Tobin's conversation with Mr Johnson, Mr Tobin pointed at a letter and said to Mr Johnson 'This says you don't want to give evidence'. Sergeant Milne answered no and said he did not recall Mr Tobin showing Mr Johnson that.[60] [60] ts 277. Sergeant Milne described the questions asked by Mr Tobin of Mr Johnson as being rhetorical. I did not allow re-examination on what he meant by this, as it is for me to determine what Mr Tobin's conduct conveyed. During Sergeant Milne's re-examination, he was asked about an email which Mr Tobin sent to West Kimberley Prosecuting on 26 November 2019, which became Exhibit 3. Amongst other matters, the email stated:The Prosecution have disclosed a statement provided by lawyers for the complainant that the complainant does not wish this matter to continue.The complainant Johnson has a history of violence against the complainant.We ask the Prosecution in light of these considerations to discontinue this charge against the accused on public interest grounds.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established