Details
- Case
- [2023] WASC 198
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the case of The State of Western Australia v McIntyre, the defendant, Brian McIntyre, was convicted of an offence following a guilty plea. The matter was heard by a magistrate who was required to determine the appropriate penalty for the offence. The central issue before the court was the severity and nature of the offence, specifically whether it constituted grossly negligent driving resulting in death. The court had to consider the facts of the case, including the circumstances leading up to the incident, the offender's actions, and the consequences of those actions.
The court examined the facts presented, which indicated that McIntyre and the deceased, Jocelyn Walker, had a history of arguments, particularly about food and the use of mobile phones. On the day of the incident, McIntyre locked Walker out of their shared residence. Later, Walker approached McIntyre's vehicle while he was filling up at a petrol station, asking for money or cigarettes. McIntyre then drove his vehicle towards Walker, striking her with the bull bar and causing her death. The court considered the evidence, including witness statements and the post-mortem examination, to conclude that McIntyre's actions were grossly negligent and resulted in Walker's death.
The magistrate concluded that McIntyre's driving was grossly negligent, as he drove towards Walker knowing she was approaching him for money or cigarettes. The court found that McIntyre's actions were deliberate and intended to intimidate or scare Walker. The severity of the impact and the resulting injuries led to Walker's immediate death. The court determined that the offence warranted a substantial penalty due to its serious nature and the tragic consequences for Walker and her family.
The final orders of the court reflect the seriousness of the offence. McIntyre was sentenced to a term of imprisonment, with specific consideration given to the impact of the offence on Walker's family and the community. The court also ordered that McIntyre be subject to various conditions during and after his sentence, including supervision and rehabilitation programs.
Background
Background to the litigation
After the offender had pleaded guilty to and been convicted of the offence, and in accordance with s 129(3) of the Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA), I asked the prosecutor to state the facts of the offence. The prosecutor then stated the facts of the offence by reading an Amended Statement of Material Facts dated 22 May 2022 (Statement of Facts).[2] The Statement of Facts, a copy of which was provided to me, is in the following terms:[3][2] ts 24 - 27, 22 May 2023. [3] The words in the quoted pars 9, 13 and 22 of the Statement of Facts that appear in square brackets are the words used by the prosecutor in stating the facts. Although nothing turns on the point, the word used in par 9 of the Statement of Facts is 'in' as opposed to 'and', the words used in par 13 of the Statement of Facts are 'mobile etc' as opposed to 'phone and the like' and the word used in par 22 of the Statement of Facts is 'or' as opposed to 'and/or'. Background1.Brian McIntyre (the offender) and Jocelyn Walker (the deceased) were in a relationship for a number of years prior to this incident.2.At the time of the offence the offender and the deceased were living in a defacto relationship in one of the houses in Wanarn Community. The house that they were living in was house 30.3.Wanarn Community is a remote Aboriginal Community and is located about a two hour drive from Warburton.4.The Community is a closed community located 15 km from the Great Central Road approximately 100 km southwest of Warakurna. The community is policed by Warakurna Police Station.5.Wanarn operates on Western Standard Time and Warakurna operates on Central Standard Time, which has a one and a half hour time difference.6.The Wanarn Community is located approximately 1,646 kilometres from Perth.7.The Wanarn Community comprises a series of dwellings, offices and stores located adjacent to dirt and gravel streets. 8.The residence occupied by the offender and the deceased was situated at Ninth Street.9.The Wanarn Community Office was located a short distance away from Ninth Street [and] First Street.10.About one to two weeks prior to the 9th of November 2020, the offender drove towards the deceased. Tristan Walker-Kelly was sitting at a bench and the offender was in his car at the bowser. The deceased was on the road walking towards him. There was some argument between them, but it was not a full argument. The deceased kept walking towards the offender and the offender drove straight at her. The deceased stepped away at the last minute and she was clipped by the side mirror of the offender's vehicle. The deceased didn't suffer any injuries.The incident11.On 9 November 2020, the offender, then aged 51, and the deceased, then aged 54, were at the Wanarn Community (The Community) which is part of Ngaanyatjarra-Giles location adjacent to the Gibson Desert in Western Australia.12.That morning there was an argument whereby the offender wanted to know why the deceased had not cooked his porridge. As a result, the offender has locked out the deceased from house 30.13.From time to time the offender and the deceased would have arguments over food, cooking not being done, use of the mobile [phone and the like]. 14.The deceased left the house before 9 am and was intending on working that day at the community centre. The deceased was trained in health care and associated services.15.At one stage that morning after the deceased left the house, she seemed upset and was throwing sand over herself. 16.At some time before 9 am (WA Time) or about 10.30 am (Central Australia Time) on 9 November 2020, Warakurna Police received a call for assistance from the deceased who advised that she had been locked out of the residence and wanted to obtain a Restraining Order. The deceased was advised that police at Warakurna were dealing with another matter and would attend to Wanarn as soon as possible.17.At about 9 am or shortly after, Western Standard Time, the offender drove a Toyota Landcruiser Utility vehicle, registered number 1EGC 105 (the vehicle) and parked near the fuel bowser at the Community Store in First Street, located near the Community Office.18.The offender worked and was working for the Community at the time and had access to the vehicle and was familiar with the vehicle.19.The deceased saw the offender in the vehicle and began walking towards the vehicle, asking the offender for money and/or cigarettes.20.When the deceased was about at least 30 metres or more away from the offender, the offender drove the vehicle towards the deceased. The offender drove towards the deceased with the intention to either intimidate and/or scare her and/or with an expectation that the deceased would jump out of the way. The offender drove from the petrol bowser and drove toward the deceased at normal speed and the offender did not swerve or the deceased did not move out of the way.21.The offender hit the deceased directly and her body impacted with the bull bar of the vehicle. The force of the impact by the deceased being hit with the bull bar resulted in the deceased being thrown back. The deceased's head hit the ground when she was flung back from being hit by the vehicle and the offender has driven over the deceased. It was too late for the offender to break when he hit her with the bull bar.22.This conduct was grossly negligent driving by the offender, driving in the direction of the deceased and knowing the deceased was coming towards him for money [and/or] cigarettes. The act was criminally negligent and resulted in the death of the deceased.23.The offender drove in the direction of the deceased and did not swerve off. The offender did not look down into his vehicle looking for something between leaving the petrol bowser and hitting the deceased. The deceased did not walk or get into the way of the vehicle near the tail end of the driving by the offender driving towards her. The offender then applied the brakes of the vehicle when he hit the deceased and the vehicle stopped shortly after where her body was laying on the ground.Post incident24.The offender got out of his vehicle and went to the deceased and picked her up. 25.One of the residents and the nephew of the deceased, Tristan Walker-Kelly told the offender to 'fuck off' and Mr Walker-Kelly held the deceased in his arms and within under a minute observed that the deceased had passed away.26.The collision was witnessed by two residents of the community who went over to the offender and punched him in the face a couple of times and kicked him.27The deceased was taken to the medical clinic at the Community and was provided brief medical care by nurses however the deceased was declared life extinct within minutes of her arrival at the clinic. This is consistent with Dr Clive Cooke's post-mortem that she would have lived for a few minutes once being hit based on the bruising around the eyes and the face and the hip area.28.In his supplementary post-mortem report dated 9 April 2021…Dr Clive Cooke concluded that the cause of the deceased's death was multiple injuries. Those injuries included:aa severe head injury being extensive fracturing to the skull;ba possible spine injury;cfractures to the right clavicle;dtwo fractures to ribs on the right; andesevere fracture to the right side of the pelvis.29.Dr Cooke was of the view that the skull fractures were severe and are a marker of the severe impact to the head. Due to the decomposition of the deceased, there was no ability to accurately assess the damage to the brain, but the severity of the skull fractures and the fatal outcome indicates that brain injury must have been sustained. This head injury would have caused a concussive effect to the brain which made the brain not work ‑ that is it shut the brain down, and the deceased died shortly afterwards.30.The vehicle was photographed by attending police officers from Warakurna Police Station before it was damaged and destroyed. There were no vehicle defects that caused the vehicle to drive into the deceased, those actions were all driver-caused by the offender.31.The offender was transferred to Perth and interviewed at Fiona Stanley Hospital as he had sustained a broken leg by one of the residents at the Community on 11 November 2020 by investigators at the Homicide Squad. The offender declined to answer any questions about the collision.