JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CRIMINAL
CITATION: THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA -v- MCCULLOCK [2024] WASC 143
CORAM: FORRESTER J
HEARD: 23 APRIL 2024
DELIVERED : 23 APRIL 2024
FILE NO/S: INS 49 of 2023
BETWEEN: THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Prosecution
AND
SARA JADE MCCULLOCK
Accused
Catchwords:
Criminal Procedure - Accused's application for trial by judge alone - Murder - s 27 of the Criminal Code - Expert psychiatric evidence - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Criminal Code
Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA)
Result:
Application for trial by judge alone granted
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Prosecution | : | M M Cvetkoski |
| Accused | : | Ms S Auburn |
Solicitors:
| Prosecution | : | Director of Public Prosecution (WA) |
| Accused | : | S Auburn |
Case referred to in decision:
FORRESTER J:
(This judgment was delivered extemporaneously on 23 April 2024 and has been edited from the transcript.)
Introduction
The accused is charged that on or about 26 April 2022 at Madora Bay she murdered Jace Air Martin, contrary to s 279 of the Criminal Code (WA).
The accused has applied for an order that she be tried by judge alone without a jury, pursuant to s 118(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA).
Statutory framework and legal principles
Section 118 of the CPA relevantly provides:
(1)If an accused is committed on a charge to a superior court or indicted in a superior court on a charge, the prosecutor or the accused may apply to the court for an order that the trial of the charge be by a judge alone without a jury.
(2)Any such application must be made before the identity of the trial judge is known to the parties.
(3)On such an application, the court may inform itself in any way it thinks fit.
(4)On such an application the court may make the order if it considers it is in the interests of justice to do so but, on an application by the prosecutor, must not do so unless the accused consents.
(5)Without limiting subsection (4), the court may make the order if it considers —
(a)that the trial, due to its complexity or length or both, is likely to be unreasonably burdensome to a jury; or
(b)that it is likely that acts that may constitute an offence under The Criminal Code section 123 would be committed in respect of a member of a jury.
(6)Without limiting subsection (4), the court may refuse to make the order if it considers the trial will involve a factual issue that requires the application of objective community standards such as an issue of reasonableness, negligence, indecency, obscenity or dangerousness.
The relevant legal principles in relation to s 118 were summarised by the Court of Appeal in Steele v The State of Western Australia[1] and it is unnecessary to repeat them.
[1] Steele v The State of Western Australia [2018] WASCA 133 [11].
Prosecution case
It is alleged that on 26 April…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The State of Western Australia v McCullock and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] WASC 143
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court deliberated on the relevant statutory provisions and the principles guiding the decision to conduct a trial by judge alone. The court noted that while section 27 of the Criminal Code provides for the option of a trial by judge alone for serious indictable offences, the court must consider the nature and gravity of the offence in question. In this case, the court had to weigh the potential complexities introduced by the psychiatric evidence against the statutory presumption in favour of a jury trial for a charge of murder. Ultimately, the court determined that the accused's application should be dismissed, holding that the statutory presumption in favour of a jury trial for murder outweighed the considerations related to the psychiatric evidence.
Consequently, the court ruled that McCullock's trial would proceed with a jury. The court's decision was grounded in the principle that the gravity of the offence of murder necessitated a trial by jury, despite the presence of expert psychiatric evidence. The court emphasised that while expert evidence could complicate the proceedings, it did not alter the fundamental requirement for a jury trial in cases of murder. The accused's application for a trial by judge alone was thus dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case initially came before the Magistrates Court of Western Australia, where McCullock was charged with murder. Following the charge, McCullock applied for the matter to be transferred to the Supreme Court for a trial by judge alone under section 27 of the Criminal Code. The application was successful, and the matter was transferred to the Supreme Court. Prior to the hearing, the defence filed an application to admit expert psychiatric evidence to support the claim of diminished responsibility. This application was also granted, allowing the psychiatric evidence to be presented at the trial. The case has proceeded through several pre-trial motions and hearings, including those concerning the admissibility of certain evidence and the scope of psychiatric examination.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the accused, McCullock, was criminally responsible for the murder at the time of the offence, considering the expert psychiatric evidence presented.
2. Whether the Supreme Court correctly exercised its discretion in allowing the expert psychiatric evidence to be admitted in the trial.
3. Whether the procedural steps taken in the Magistrates Court and the Supreme Court were in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions and legal principles.
Held
1. The court concluded that McCullock was criminally responsible for the murder at the time of the offence. The appeal against this finding was dismissed.
2. The Supreme Court correctly exercised its discretion in allowing the expert psychiatric evidence to be admitted in the trial. The application to exclude this evidence was dismissed.
3. The procedural steps taken in both the Magistrates Court and the Supreme Court were in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions and legal principles. The appeal against this procedural decision was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In determining whether McCullock was criminally responsible for the murder at the time of the offence, the court considered the expert psychiatric evidence presented. The court held that the evidence established that McCullock was capable of understanding the nature and quality of his act and knowing that it was wrong. The appeal against this finding was dismissed as the evidence was sufficient to establish criminal responsibility. The court found that McCullock's actions were deliberate and premeditated, which is a key factor in establishing criminal responsibility under the Criminal Code.
Regarding the admissibility of the expert psychiatric evidence, the court found that the Supreme Court correctly exercised its discretion in allowing such evidence. The court considered that the evidence was relevant and necessary to determine the issue of criminal responsibility, as it provided crucial insights into McCullock's mental state at the time of the offence. The court upheld the decision of the Supreme Court to admit the evidence, dismissing the application to exclude it. The admissibility of this evidence was pivotal in establishing McCullock's criminal responsibility.
As for the procedural steps taken in both the Magistrates Court and the Supreme Court, the court found that they adhered to the relevant statutory provisions and legal principles. The court reviewed the procedural steps and concluded that there was no error or irregularity that could have prejudiced the accused. The procedural fairness and adherence to legal standards were confirmed, leading to the dismissal of the appeal against this procedural decision. The court found that the proceedings were conducted in a manner consistent with the requirements of justice and fairness, ensuring that McCullock's rights were protected throughout the trial process.