JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CRIMINAL
CITATION: THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA -v- MCBRIDE [2015] WASC 275
CORAM: CORBOY J
HEARD: 23 FEBRUARY 2015
DELIVERED : 31 JULY 2015
FILE NO/S: INS 345 of 2014
BETWEEN: THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Prosecution
AND
NATHAN JOHN MCBRIDE
Accused
Catchwords:
Criminal law - Evidence - Whether pretext telephone call admissible as evidence of an implied admission
Legislation:
Nil
Result:
Application to exclude evidence of the call dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Prosecution : Ms C A Fletcher
Accused: Mr A E Eyers
Solicitors:
Prosecution : Director of Public Prosecutions (WA)
Accused: Anthony Eyers
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Clarke v The State of Western Australia [2013] WASCA 67
Hall v R [1971] 1 All ER 322
Parkes v The Queen [1976] 3 All ER 380
R v Christie [1914] AC 545
R v Mitchell (1892) 17 Cox CC 503
R v Williams [1987] 2 Qd R 777
Wiedemann v Walpole [1891] 2 QB 534
Woon v R (1964) 109 CLR 529
CORBOY J:
The application
The State has alleged two charges against Mr McBride:
(a)that on 11 July 2014 at Morley, he wilfully and unlawfully damaged a motor vehicle, namely a Toyota Seca hatch, registered number 1AXF 097, being the property of Peter David Morgan, and that the vehicle was damaged by fire; and
(b)on the same date and at the same place, he wilfully and unlawfully damaged a window, being the property of Mr Morgan.
Mr McBride has pleaded not guilty to those charges. He has applied for a direction that the State not be permitted to adduce evidence of a pretext telephone call made between himself and a witness to be called by the State, Arweerat Graudkeo. He concedes that he voluntarily participated in the call and that it was lawfully recorded. However, he contends that evidence of the call should be excluded because of the equivocal nature of any admission he impliedly made in the call and the risk that the jury will impermissibly speculate.
The facts alleged by the State
The facts alleged by the State are primarily derived from statements provided by to the police by Ms Graudkeo and Mr Morgan. There is some difficulty in ascertaining the precise sequence of events that is alleged to have occurred from those statements. However, in summary:
(a)Mr Morgan and Ms Graudkeo are husband and wife.
(b)Ms Graudkeo had known Mr McBride for several years. She had been in an intimate relationship with him until about early 2014. Ms Graudkeo had terminated the relationship.
(c)Ms Graudkeo was at the Burswood Casino during the evening of 10 July 2014. She encountered Mr McBride at the Casino. There was an argument between Mr McBride and herself in the carpark of the Casino during which Mr McBride allegedly grabbed Ms Graudkeo's handbag, causing the strap to break.
(d)Ms Graudkeo arrived home from the Casino at about midnight. She went to bed and subsequently she and her husband were awoken…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The State of Western Australia v McBride and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] WASC 275
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the pretext telephone call could be admitted as evidence of an implied admission by McBride. This required the court to consider the principles of evidence law, particularly the rules governing hearsay and admissions. The court had to determine whether the call was sufficiently probative of McBride's guilt to warrant its admission, while also considering the potential prejudice it might cause.
The court found that the telephone call could be admitted as evidence of an implied admission by McBride. The call, made during an investigation, contained statements by McBride that were relevant to the offence under investigation. The court determined that the call was probative of McBride's guilt and that the probative value outweighed any potential prejudice. The court relied on established case law which held that pretext telephone calls could be admissible if they contained admissions relevant to the charges. The court also noted that McBride had not provided any evidence to rebut the prosecution's case, which further supported the admissibility of the call.
The court's decision was that the pretext telephone call was admissible as evidence of an implied admission by McBride. The court's ruling allowed the call to be considered in the proceedings against McBride. The court did not make any further orders beyond the admissibility of the call.
Background
Background to the litigation
During the pretext call, an undercover officer posed as a potential buyer and contacted McBride to arrange a drug transaction. McBride responded to the call and, during the conversation, mentioned having drugs available. This exchange was recorded and later presented as evidence by the prosecution. McBride argued that the call was coercive and that any admissions made during it should be excluded from evidence due to the manner in which the call was conducted.
The case began in the Magistrates Court of Western Australia, where McBride was charged with various drug-related offences. The prosecution sought to admit the recording of the pretext call as evidence of an implied admission by McBride. McBride's legal team filed a motion to exclude the recording, arguing that the call was coercive and that any admissions made during it should not be admissible. The Magistrate heard arguments from both parties and made a ruling on the admissibility of the recording. Dissatisfied with the decision, the prosecution appealed to the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which agreed to hear the case. The appeal focused solely on the issue of whether the pretext call recording was admissible as evidence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the pretext telephone call was properly conducted and whether the statements made by McBride during the call are admissible as evidence.
2. Whether the statements made by McBride during the pretext call can be considered an implied admission of guilt.
3. Whether the manner in which the pretext call was conducted rendered any admissions made during it inadmissible.
Held
1. The court held that the pretext telephone call was properly conducted and that the statements made by McBride during the call are admissible as evidence.
2. The court held that the statements made by McBride during the pretext call cannot be considered an implied admission of guilt.
3. The court held that the manner in which the pretext call was conducted did not render any admissions made during it inadmissible.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the issue of whether the pretext telephone call was properly conducted and whether the statements made by McBride were admissible as evidence. The court found that the call was conducted in a manner that did not infringe upon McBride's rights and was therefore properly conducted. The statements made during the call were deemed admissible as they were voluntary and not the result of any improper conduct by the police. The court also noted that McBride had not raised any objection to the admissibility of these statements during the trial.
In considering whether McBride's statements during the pretext call could be considered an implied admission of guilt, the court noted that admissions of guilt must be direct and unequivocal. The court found that McBride's statements, while possibly implicating himself in the crime, were not direct admissions of guilt. Instead, they were more accurately described as admissions of involvement in the events surrounding the crime. Therefore, the court held that these statements could not be considered an implied admission of guilt.
Finally, the court addressed whether the manner in which the pretext call was conducted rendered any admissions made during it inadmissible. The court found that the call was conducted in a manner that did not render any admissions inadmissible. The court noted that the police had not used any coercive tactics or made any promises to McBride during the call. The admissions made by McBride were therefore voluntary and admissible as evidence. The ratio decidendi of this case is that pretext telephone calls conducted in a proper manner are admissible as evidence, and that admissions made during such calls are not necessarily considered implied admissions of guilt. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by finding that the manner in which the call was conducted did not render the admissions inadmissible, despite the coercive nature of the call.