The Royal Children's Hospital v Robert Alexander

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

The Royal Children’s Hospital v Robert Alexander [2011] APO 94

Patent Applications:               2006206051 and 2006222481

Titles:[Virus Recovery Medium, use thereof and Viral Diagnostic Kit including same] and [Viral Diagnostic Method and well for use in same]

Patent Applicant:                   Dr Robert Alexander

Requestor:  The Royal Children’s Hospital

Delegate:  Karen Ayers

Decision Date:  10 November 2011

Hearing Date:  10 August 2011, in Melbourne

Catchwords:  PATENTS - requests under sections 32 and 36 – inventorship –employer-employee relationship- whether employment contract had an implied term to assign inventions to employer - whether applicant had a duty to invent- whether invention was conceived in the course of employment.

Representation:  Patent applicant:  Actuate Legal, Melbourne

Requestor:Norton Rose, Australia

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Applications:               2006206051 and 2006222481

Titles:[Virus Recovery Medium, use thereof and Viral Diagnostic Kit including same] and [Viral Diagnostic Method and well for use in same] respectively

Patent Applicant:                   Dr Robert Alexander

Date of Decision:                   10 November 2011

DECISION

1. Under section 32, the Commissioner has the power to direct an application to proceed in a different name if she finds that another party is entitled to the invention. In this case, I have found that The Royal Children’s Hospital (RCH) has successfully argued that they are solely entitled to the invention claimed in application 2006206051 (viral recovery medium) because of an employee-employer relationship with Dr Alexander. Subject to any appeal of this decision, I direct patent application 2006206051 to proceed in the name of The Royal Children’s Hospital.

2.   Dr Alexander is solely entitled to the application described and claimed in 2006222481 (well device).   There was no motivation for Dr Alexander to improve the well device in the course of his employment.     

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

3.   Patent applications 2006206051 (the first application) and 2006222481 (the second application) were filed under the provisions of the PCT on 13 January 2006 and 10 March 2006 respectively.   The first application claimed priority from an Australian provisional application (2005900169) filed on 14 January 2005.  The second application claimed priority from another provisional application (2005901141) filed on 10 March 2005.  Both provisional applications and their corresponding standard applications were filed in the name of Dr Robert Alexander. 

4.   The first application (‘051) was published as WO 2006/074524 on 20 July 2006 and entered the national phase in Australia on 13 June 2007.  It is currently undergoing examination with a first report issued on 6 September 2010.  The second application (‘481) was published as WO 2006/094364 on 14 September 2006 and entered national phase on 30 August 2007.  It also is currently undergoing examination before the Commissioner with a first report being issued on 10 September 2010. 

5. On 23 December 2009, a third party (The Royal Children’s Hospital – hereafter RCH) filed requests under sections 32 and 36 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) in relation to both the first and second applications. RCH claimed entitlement to the invention based on an employee-employer relationship and requested that the applications proceed in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Royal Children's Hospital v Robert Alexander and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] APO 94
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The decision involves a dispute between Dr Robert Alexander and The Royal Children’s Hospital (RCH) over the ownership of two patent applications related to viral diagnostic methods and kits. The first application, 2006206051, pertains to a virus recovery medium, while the second application, 2006222481, relates to a well device suitable for use in a viral diagnostic method. The dispute was referred to the Australian Patent Office, where the Commissioner was tasked with determining the rightful owner of the inventions. RCH argued that Dr Alexander, who was employed as a senior scientist in their Virology Laboratory, conceived the inventions during his employment, thereby making RCH the rightful owner. Dr Alexander, on the other hand, contended that he was the sole inventor and that the inventions were not made in the course of his employment with RCH. The Commissioner, Karen Ayers, concluded that RCH was entitled to the first application, 2006206051, as it was conceived in the course of Dr Alexander’s employment. However, Dr Alexander was found to be the sole owner of the second application, 2006222481, as there was no clear motivation for him to improve the well device in the course of his employment. The decision hinged on whether Dr Alexander had a "duty to invent" and whether the inventions were made in the course of his employment. The Commissioner found that Dr Alexander had a "duty to invent" in his role as Head of Virology, but this duty was limited to instances where there was a clear motivation to identify improvements. The invention related to the virus recovery medium was found to be within the scope of Dr Alexander’s duties, while the well device invention did not meet this criterion. Consequently, the Commissioner directed that patent application 2006206051 should proceed in the name of The Royal Children’s Hospital, while Dr Alexander was deemed the sole owner of application 2006222481. The decision underscores the importance of establishing a "duty to invent" and the specific circumstances under which an employee’s inventions may be attributed to their employer.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established