The Recyclers (NSW) Pty Ltd v Ayoub (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read


Supreme Court

New South Wales

Case Name: 

The Recyclers (NSW) Pty Ltd v Ayoub (No 5)

Medium Neutral Citation: 

[2016] NSWSC 864

Hearing Date(s): 

17 June 2016

Decision Date: 

17 June 2016

Jurisdiction: 

Equity - Expedition List

Before: 

Stevenson J

Decision: 

Tutor liable for costs of first defendant; costs specified at $225,000

Catchwords: 

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – tutor – whether determination by court that party is competent to give evidence under s 13 Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) has consequence that the person is not under legal incapacity and tutor’s appointment “invalid” – Pt 7 Div 4 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) – COSTS – against non-party – tutor – general rule that tutor liable to pay costs awarded against party represented – COSTS – gross sum costs order – whether order should be made where complex allegations made by party without substantive evidence – where party has constantly been in default of court’s orders – where party’s conduct suggests costs assessment process likely to be protracted – quantification of such costs

Legislation Cited: 

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
Felons (Civil Proceedings) Act 1981 (NSW)
Guardianship Act 1987 (NSW)
Mental Health Act 2007 (NSW)
NSW Trustee and Guardian Act 2009 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)

Cases Cited: 

Hamod v New South Wales [2011] NSWCA 375
Masterman-Lister v Brutton & Co [2003] 1 WLR 1511
Spina v Permanent Custodians Ltd [2009] NSWCA 206
Stokes v McCourt [2014] NSWSC 61
The Recyclers (NSW) Pty Limited v Ayoub (No 3) [2016] NSWSC 576
The Recyclers (NSW) Pty Ltd v Ayoub [2016] NSWSC 144
Yakmor v Hamdoush (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 284; 76 NSWLR 148

Category: 

Costs

Parties: 

The Recyclers (NSW) Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
Aus Wide Recycling Pty Ltd (Applicant/Second Defendant)
George Faddoul (Applicant)
Michael Ayoub by his tutor Paul Joseph Donnelly (Respondent/ First Defendant)
Illawarra Motor Auction Pty Ltd (Respondent /Third Defendant)
Milana South Coast Pty Ltd (Respondent/Fourth Defendant)
Paul Joseph Donnelly (Respondent)

Representation: 

Counsel:
A J McInerney SC with D Robertson (Applicants)
S Haddad (Respondents)
 
Solicitors:
MJF Legal Pty Ltd (Applicants)

File Number(s): 

SC 2015/299325

EX TEMPORE Judgment (Revised)

  1. On 9 May 2016 I ordered that the amended defence of the first, third and fourth defendants and the first cross-claim be dismissed with costs: The Recyclers (NSW) Pty Ltd v Ayoub (No 3) [2016] NSWSC 576. The procedural history of this matter is set out in that judgment. This judgment assumes familiarity with that detail. I shall use the same abbreviations here as in that judgment.

  2. There is no dispute that Mr Ayoub, Illawarra and Milana are jointly and severally liable for the costs order I made.

  3. By notice of motion filed on 11 May 2016, Aus Wide and its director, Mr George Faddoul (who was the second cross-defendant), seek the following orders:

    “1.   An order that the first defendant’s tutor, Mr Paul Joseph Donnelly, is also liable to pay the costs ordered against the first, third and fourth defendants on 9 May 2016.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Recyclers (NSW) Pty Ltd v Ayoub (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 864
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of The Recyclers (NSW) Pty Ltd v Ayoub (No 5), the plaintiff, The Recyclers (NSW) Pty Ltd, pursued legal action against the defendant, Ayoub, involving issues related to the competency of a party to give evidence and the implications of this competency on the appointment of a tutor under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). The dispute also encompassed matters regarding the costs incurred by the defendant's tutor, who was not a party to the proceedings. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The central legal issues addressed by the court included whether the determination that a party was competent to give evidence under section 13 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) had the consequence that the person was not under legal incapacity and thus rendered the tutor's appointment "invalid". Furthermore, the court considered the implications of the general rule that a tutor is liable to pay costs awarded against the party they represent, especially in cases where the tutor is not a party. Another issue was whether a gross sum costs order should be made where complex allegations were made by a party without substantive evidence, and the party had consistently been in default of the court’s orders, suggesting that the costs assessment process would likely be protracted.

The court examined the statutory and procedural frameworks to conclude that the determination of a party's competency to give evidence did not necessarily invalidate the appointment of a tutor. The court held that the competency to give evidence under the Evidence Act did not automatically render the appointment of a tutor invalid, thus distinguishing between the two roles. Regarding costs, the court ruled that a gross sum costs order could be appropriate in cases where the allegations were complex and unsubstantiated, and the party's conduct had been persistently non-compliant with court orders, indicating a likely protracted costs assessment process. The court emphasised the need for careful consideration of the circumstances before making such an order.

The final orders of the court included the clarification of the relationship between a party's competency to give evidence and the validity of a tutor's appointment, and a decision on the appropriateness of a gross sum costs order under the given circumstances. The court's ruling provided clear guidance on these procedural and substantive issues, ensuring that future litigation would benefit from the court's considered analysis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established