The Queen v Cerantonio & Ors (Rulings 1-11)

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

CRIMINAL DIVISION

S CR 2017 0078; S CR 2017 0079
S CR 2017 0080; S CR 2017 0081
S CR 2017 0082; S CR 2017 0104

Between:

THE QUEEN

-and-

ROBERT EDWARD CERANTONIO
PAUL JAMES DACRE
ANTONINO ALFIO GRANATA
SHAYDEN JAMIL THORNE
KADIR KAYA &
MURAT KAYA

Accused

---

JUDGE:

Croucher J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATES OF HEARING:

27, 30 & 31 October and 1-3 November 2017

DATE OF RULINGS:

8 December 2017

DATE OF REASONS:

12 December 2017

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

R v Cerantonio & Ors (Rulings 1-11)

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2017] VSC 725

Second revision, 31 January 2018, at paragraph [107] & footnotes 19, 21, 29 & 32

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Pre-trial rulings – Six men charged jointly with offence of engaging in conduct preparatory to offence of entering a foreign country with intention of engaging in a hostile activity in that country – Ruling 1: Statement of elements of offence charged – ‘Ruling’ 2: Whether particulars of alleged preparatory acts should be confined – Ruling 3: Whether inadequacy in particulars alleging accused agreed to “involve themselves in the Islamic insurgency in the southern Philippines with one or more of the objectives set out in s 117.1 in order to bring about Islamic rule there” – Ruling 4: Whether, to fall within definition of “engaging in a hostile activity”, alleged intended conduct in foreign country must be of “violent military-type”, or hostile, irrespective of intended objective of conduct – Ruling 5: Whether charge requires particularization as to which accused were allegedly to enter foreign country with intent to engage in a hostile activity – Ruling 6: Whether there must be agreement among relevant accused as to same intended conduct in foreign country with same intended objective/s thereof – Ruling 7: Whether matters listed in s 100.1(3) of Code must be included in indictment – Ruling 8: Whether, if action falling within subparagraph (b)(i) of definition of “engage in a hostile activity” is relied on as intended objective, indictment must also allege, pursuant to subparagraph (b)(ii) of same definition, how that action, if engaged in in Australia, would constitute a “serious offence” – Ruling 9: Whether particular effectively alleging agreement to agree to commit an offence is inapt – Ruling 10: Whether words “or elsewhere” and “or any other” should be deleted from indictment as surplusage – ‘Ruling’ 11: Whether particulars of intended objectives of intended conduct should be confined – Criminal Code (Cth), ss 11.2A, 100.1, 101.2, 101.4, 101.5, 101.6, 117.1, 119.1 & 119.4; Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic), ss 159 & 199 & Schedule 1, clauses 1 & 2.

Appearances:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Crown Mr N Robinson QC with
Ms R Sharp and
Ms C Fitzgerald
Solicitor to Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions
For Robert Cerantonio Mr M Cahill SC with
Dr G Boas
Stary Norton Halphen
Criminal Lawyers

For Paul Dacre

Mr J McMahon SC with
Ms G Morgan

Slades & Parsons

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Queen v Cerantonio & Ors (Rulings 1-11) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] VSC 725
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of The Queen v Cerantonio & Ors, the court addressed various preliminary issues in the case against six men accused of planning to engage in hostile activities in a foreign country. The defendants were charged under the Criminal Code with offences related to preparing to enter a foreign country with the intention of engaging in hostile activities. The court was tasked with providing rulings on a series of complex legal questions that would shape the trial process.

The legal issues before the court encompassed the elements of the offence, the adequacy of particulars in the indictment, and the interpretation of specific provisions within the Criminal Code. Key questions included whether the particulars of preparatory acts should be confined, the nature of the objectives required for the offence, and the necessity of detailing which accused were to enter the foreign country with hostile intentions. The court also examined the requirement for agreement among the accused on the intended conduct and objectives, the inclusion of matters listed in the Code, and the sufficiency of the indictment in relation to the intended objectives of the hostile activities.

In its reasoning, the court provided detailed analysis and interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions, applying established legal principles to each issue. The court ruled that certain particulars in the indictment needed to be more precisely defined to ensure clarity and fairness to the accused. It also clarified the scope of the offence, emphasizing that the intended conduct did not necessarily need to be of a "violent military-type" to constitute a hostile activity. Furthermore, the court determined that the indictment must include specific details regarding the accused's agreement and the intended conduct, and that the listed matters in the Code must be incorporated into the indictment. The court also addressed the necessity of particularizing which accused were to enter the foreign country and the objectives of the intended activities.

The final orders included specific directions for the prosecution to amend the indictment to reflect the court's rulings, ensuring that the particulars were precise and adequate for the purposes of a fair trial. The court's decisions provided clarity on several complex issues, ensuring that the trial would proceed with a well-defined legal framework.