The Public Trustee of Queensland v Cole

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

The Public Trustee of Queensland v Cole & Ors [2019] QSC 298

PARTIES:

THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND as executor of the estate of GILLIAN MARY RUTH COLE deceased

(applicant)

v
JOSEPH FAUENA THOMAS COLE
CHRISTOPHER MURRAY LEMAUOSAMOA COLE

(first respondents)

BELLA SINA NANIA-COLE
KYLANI LEILUA NANIA-COLE
SAMUELU DAVID COLE

(second respondents)

RACHAEL LEE FALZON
DANIEL KANE BARTLETT
TANIA MARIA BARTLETT

(third respondents)

OSCAR FALZON
CARTER FALZON
KAYLA NIKITA HARRISON
JADE SHAKYA HARRISON

(fourth respondents)

FILE NO/S:

10666 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

6 December 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15 November 2019

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDERS:

1.     The time for making an application for an order to rectify the Will of Gillian Mary Ruth Cole (deceased) is extended to 2 October 2019.

2.     A copy of the application and supporting material having come into the possession of the first respondent Christopher Murray Lemauosamoa Cole on 3 October 2019, possession of the documents on that day is service of the documents on that day.

3.     The last Will of the deceased dated 3 July 2012 is rectified so Clause 9 reads:

“I Give -

The whole of my estate to my great nieces and great nephews and my intended husband’s great nephews and great nieces living at my death in equal shares”.

4.     A certified copy of this order shall be attached to the Order to Administer with the Will made on 7 April 2017 on court file BS 2655/17.

5.     The applicant’s costs of the application be paid out of the estate on an indemnity basis.

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – MAKING OF A WILL – STATUTORY POWER OF RECTIFICATION – where the applicant seeks an order for rectification of the deceased’s will – where the deceased’s will disposed her estate to her great nieces and nephews and her intended husband’s great nephews and nieces – where there was evidence that the deceased’s intention was to dispose her estate to her great nieces and great nephews and her intended husband’s great nephews and great nieces – whether the will should be rectified to reflect that intention

Succession Act 1981(Qld), s 31, s 33, s 33C

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 105, r 117, r 125

Byrnes v Kendle (2011) 243 CLR 253, cited
Farrelly v Phillips (2017) 128 SASR 502, cited
Marley v Rawlings [2015] AC 129, cited
Palethorpe v The Public Trustee of Queensland [2011] QSC 335, cited
Perrin v Morgan [1943] AC 399, cited
Re Bryden [1975] Qd R 210, cited
Re Finch (deceased) [2018] 3 Qd R 370, cited
Rose v Tomkins [2018] 1 Qd R 549, cited
Terence John McCorley and David John Lewis (as executors of the Will ofVera Rachel Pakleppa deceased) v Norman Pakleppa [2005] QSC 83, cited

The Public Trustee of Queensland v Smith [2009] 1 Qd R 26, cited

COUNSEL:

R D Cumming for the applicant

No appearance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Public Trustee of Queensland v Cole and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 298
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of The Public Trustee of Queensland v Cole, the court was tasked with determining whether the will of Gillian Mary Ruth Cole should be rectified to reflect her true intentions. The deceased left a will dated 3 July 2012 which, due to a clerical error, did not accurately reflect her intentions regarding the distribution of her estate. The will intended to dispose of the estate to her great nieces and nephews, as well as her intended husband’s great nephews and nieces, but incorrectly referred to her intended husband’s nieces and nephews. The applicant, the Public Trustee of Queensland, sought either a declaration of the proper construction of the will or, alternatively, an order for rectification to align with the deceased's true intentions.

The legal issues before the court included whether the will was ambiguous or contained a clerical error that warranted rectification under the Succession Act 1981. Specifically, the court had to decide if the discrepancy in the will's language could be corrected to reflect the deceased's true intentions, considering the provisions of Section 33 of the Succession Act. The court also needed to examine the admissibility of evidence regarding the deceased's intentions in light of Section 33C of the Act.

The court determined that the will contained a clerical error and that the language used was ambiguous in light of the surrounding circumstances, thus justifying rectification under Section 33 of the Succession Act. The court found that the deceased's intention was to leave her estate to her great nieces and nephews and her intended husband’s great nieces and nephews. The court considered the evidence provided, including the testimony of those who were familiar with the deceased’s intentions, and concluded that the will should be rectified to reflect these intentions. Accordingly, the court extended the time for making an application for rectification, rectified the will as requested, and ordered that a certified copy of the order be attached to the Order to Administer with the Will. The court also directed that the applicant’s costs be paid from the estate.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The time for making an application for an order to rectify the Will of Gillian Mary Ruth Cole (deceased) is extended to 2 October 2019.

2. A copy of the application and supporting material having come into the possession of the first respondent Christopher Murray Lemauosamoa Cole on 3 October 2019, possession of the documents on that day is service of the documents on that day.

3. The last Will of the deceased dated 3 July 2012 is rectified so Clause 9 reads:

“I Give -

The whole of my estate to my great nieces and great nephews and my intended husband’s great nephews and great nieces living at my death in equal shares”.

4. A certified copy of this order shall be attached to the Order to Administer with the Will made on 7 April 2017 on court file BS 2655/17.

5. The applicant’s costs of the application be paid out of the estate on an indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Gillian Mary Ruth Cole, deceased (the deceased) left a will made on 3 July 2012 (the Will). The applicant was granted an Order to Administer with the Will on 7 April 2017. An issue has arisen as to the construction of the Will. The applicant seeks a declaration as to the proper construction of the Will, or in the alternative, rectification to reflect the deceased’s true intentions.Background At the time of her death, the deceased was married to Ross Douglass[1] Bryce (Mr Bryce). The deceased and Mr Bryce had been a couple for many years but had not married by the time the deceased made the Will.[1] On his death certificate Mr Bryce’s second given name appears as Douglas not Douglass. The Will was made by the deceased in contemplation of her marriage to Mr Bryce. The pair later married. Relevantly, the Will provided:“1. Cancellation of previous WillsI CANCEL my earlier Wills.2. Intended MarriageThis Will is made in contemplation of my marriage with ROSS DOUGLASS BRYCE but is not conditional on the marriage taking place.3. Appointment of ExecutorI APPOINT THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND to be the executor and trustee (“my Trustee”) of this Will. 4. Survival of Beneficiaries I DIRECT that to share in my estate a person must survive me for 30 days and the word “survive” is to be read accordingly.…8. Disposal of my EstateI GIVE -The whole of my estate to my intended husband ROSS DOUGLASS BRYCE but if this gift fails then the following provisions for distribution shall apply instead.9. Further Disposal of my EstateI GIVE -The whole of my estate to my great nieces and nephews and my intended husband’s great nephews and nieces living at my death in equal shares.” Mr Bryce died on 23 February 2013, pre-deceasing the deceased who died on 2 February 2017. Therefore, by force of clause 4 of the Will, the deceased’s estate passes pursuant to clause 9, not clause 8. The relationship of “nephew” or “niece” to the deceased is that of child of a sibling of the deceased. The relationship of “great nephew” or “great niece” to the deceased is that of child of a niece or nephew of the deceased. The same applies to relationships of Mr Bryce. The deceased had two brothers but no sisters. The two brothers are Paul Cole and David Cole. Paul has no children. David has two: Joseph and Christopher, both of whom are therefore nephews of the deceased. Joseph has no children, but Christopher has three: Bella Nania-Cole, Kylani Nania-Cole and Samuelu Cole. Bella and Kylani are great nieces of the deceased and Samuelu is her great nephew. Mr Bryce has only one sibling, a sister Lynn Bartlett. She has three children: Rachael Falzon, Daniel Bartlett and Tania Bartlett. Rachael and Tania are nieces of Mr Bryce and Daniel is his nephew. Daniel has no children but Rachael has two: Oscar Falzon and Carter Falzon. Tania also has two children: Kayla Harrison and Jade Harrison. Oscar and Carter are the great nephews of Mr Bryce and Kayla and Jade are his great nieces.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 33C[18] of the Succession Act 1981 is in these terms:[18] Part of Part 2 Division 5. “33C Use of evidence to interpret a will(1) In a proceeding to interpret a will, evidence, including evidence of the testator’s intention, is admissible to help in the interpretation of the language used in the will if the language makes the will or part of it—(a) meaningless; or(b) ambiguous on the face of the will; or(c) ambiguous in the light of surrounding circumstances.(2) However, evidence of the testator’s intention is not admissible to establish any of the circumstances mentioned in subsection (1)(c).(3) This section does not prevent the admission of evidence that would otherwise be admissible in a proceeding to interpret a will.” Subdivision 5 of Division 4 of Part 2 concerns rectification. Section 33 provides:“33 Court may rectify a will(1) The court may make an order to rectify a will to carry out the intentions of the testator if the court is satisfied that the will does not carry out the testator’s intentions because—(a)a clerical error was made; or(b) the will does not give effect to the testator’s instructions.(2) An application for an order to rectify a will may only be made within 6 months after the date of death of the testator.(3) However, the court may, at any time, extend the time for making an application under subsection (2) if—(a) the court considers it appropriate; and(b) the final distribution of the estate has not been made.(4) If the court makes an order to rectify a will, the court may direct that a certified copy of the order be attached to the will.(5) If the court gives a direction under subsection (4), the court must hold the will until the certified copy is attached to it.”The relevant principles of construction The purpose of construing a will is to objectively ascertain the intention of the testator[19] from the words of the will.[20] Part of the process in construing the meaning of the words used in the will is to consider the words in “their documentary, factual and commercial context”.[21][19] Perrin v Morgan [1943] AC 399, Fell v Fell (1922) 31 CLR 268 at 273-274.[20] Perrin v Morgan [1943] AC 399 at 406.[21] Marley v Rawlings [2015] AC 129 at [19]-[20], Farrelly v Phillips (2017) 128 SASR 502, the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia adopting the general approach described in Byrnes v Kendle (2011) 243 CLR 253 at [95]-[116]. Evidence of the context against which the will was made is often, in succession cases, described as “the armchair principle”.[22] The armchair principle does not permit of the admission of evidence of the subjective intention of the testator. [22] The Public Trustee of Queensland v Smith [2009] 1 Qd R 26 at [24]. Section 33C of the Succession Act allows the admission of evidence of the subjective intention of the testator in certain circumstances[23] and preserves the common law rules which allow for the admission of extrinsic evidence in aid of interpretation. In ThePublic Trustee of Queensland v Smith,[24] Atkinson J explained the operation of s 33C and its relationship with the common law principles of construction in this way:[23] Section 33C(1).[24] [2009] 1 Qd R 26.“[22] The circumstances in which extrinsic evidence may be used and the purpose for which it may be used are now governed by s 33C of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld) (‘the Act’) which was extensively amended with effect from 1 April 2006. Section 33C sets out what extrinsic evidence is admissible in interpreting a will: [Her Honour set out s 33C which appears in paragraph [35] above] [23] This provision gave effect to a recommendation found in Chapter 6 Part 5 of the Consolidated Report to the Standing Committee of Attorneys General on the Law of Wills produced by the National Committee for Uniform Succession Laws published by the Queensland Law Reform Commission as Miscellaneous Paper 29 in December 1997. [24] As a result, in addition to the circumstances set out in s 33C(1), s 33C(3) continues to allow the admission of extrinsic evidence in the construction of wills in the three circumstances which obtained prior to the introduction of s 33C in its present form on 1 April 2006. The three rules of construction which have been retained are:(1) The ‘armchair principle’ which permits the court to sit in the testator’s armchair to take account of his or her ‘habits of speech and of his or her family, property, friends and acquaintances’ in order to determine what the testator meant by the words of a will. The ‘armchair principle’ does not, however, allow direct evidence to be given of the testator’s intention by, for example, allowing evidence of the instructions to the solicitor. (2) The ‘equivocation’ exception. This rule of construction provides that ‘evidence of the testator's actual intention, while not ordinarily admissible to assist in the construction of a will, is admissible where there is what is described as ‘equivocation’ in the will, that is, where a description, usually of a person, is equally capable of referring to more than one person.’ This rule is sometimes referred to as the ‘latent ambiguity rule’ where there are, for example, two legatees of the same name. (3) The equitable presumption rule. Evidence of a testator’s intention may be given when a presumption arises in equity that a legacy in a will is in satisfaction of payment due under another instrument such as a deed.[25] In addition to these three circumstances in which extrinsic evidence may be led are the three circumstances set out in s 33C of the Act: (1) when the language used in the will makes the will or part of it meaningless; (2) when the language used in the will makes the will or part of it ambiguous on the face of the will;In both of these circumstances extrinsic evidence, including evidence of the testator’s intention, is admissible to help in the interpretation of the language used in the will. (3) when the language used in the will makes the will or part of it ambiguous in the light of the surrounding circumstances, then extrinsic evidence, but not evidence of the testator’s intention in order to establish any of those circumstances, is admissible to help in the interpretation of the language used in the will.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established