The Owners – Units Plan No 666 v Quaid and Anor (Unit Titles)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

THE OWNERS – UNITS PLAN NO. 666 v QUAID & ANOR (Unit Titles) [2020] ACAT 87

UT 29/2019

Catchwords:               UNIT TITLES – whether the owners corporation’s legal costs in the proceedings meet the double reasonableness test for section 31 expenses – whether reasonable steps were taken by corporation to resolve the dispute before commencing proceedings

Legislation cited:        Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 ss 31, 95, 125

Cases cited:In the Matter of Ruling Tribunal Section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 [2017] ACAT 56

The Owners – Units Plan No 3182 v Black & Anor [2018] ACAT 6

Tribunal:  Senior Member E Ferguson

Date of Orders:  29 October 2020

Date of Reasons for Decision:         29 October 2020

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL           UT 29/2019

BETWEEN:

THE OWNERS – UNITS PLAN NO. 666

Applicant

AND:

JACK QUAID

First Respondent

SUSAN QUAID

Second Respondent

TRIBUNAL:     Senior Member E Ferguson

DATE:29 October 2020

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The application for expenses claimed under section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 is dismissed.

………………………………..

Senior Member E Ferguson

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. The owners corporation of Units Plan 666 (the corporation) applied to the tribunal for orders in relation to a range of unapproved alterations the respondents had made without the consent of the executive in contravention of Article 4(1) of the Articles of the Unit Plan. The application was made pursuant to the tribunal’s jurisdiction to resolve unit title disputes under section 125 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (UTM Act).

  2. At the hearing on 17 January 2020 I upheld the application and made orders requiring the respondents to remedy the contravention.

  3. As part of the same application the applicant sought to recover legal professional costs and disbursements, and the fee for lodging the application, which it incurred in bringing the proceedings as expenses pursuant to section 31 of the UTM Act.

  4. I reserved my decision on the corporation’s section 31 claim and asked the parties to provide written submissions and evidence to enable me to determine the issue on the papers. My decision in relation to the section 31 issue and reasons are set out below.

Introduction

  1. It is not uncommon for costs incurred by a corporation in tribunal proceedings for the recovery of unpaid unit title levies to be recovered in the same proceedings as ‘expenses’ under section 31 of the UTM Act. Unpaid unit title levies and expenses to which section 31 apply are both recoverable as statutory debts.[1] The Tribunal does not require separate applications as both fall within the tribunal’s jurisdiction to determine debt applications, subject to jurisdictional limits relating to the amount claimed.[2]

    [1] Section 95 of the UTM Act

    [2] Part 4 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Act 2008

  2. The corporation in this case applied to resolve a unit title dispute and sought to recover its expenses of those proceedings as part of the same application. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners – Units Plan No 666 v Quaid and Anor (Unit Titles... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] ACAT 87
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Owners – Units Plan No 666 (the corporation) applied to the tribunal for orders in relation to unapproved alterations made by the respondents, Quaid and Anor, without the consent of the executive, in contravention of Article 4(1) of the Articles of the Unit Plan. The corporation also sought to recover legal professional costs and disbursements, and the fee for lodging the application, which it incurred in bringing the proceedings as expenses pursuant to section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (UTM Act). The legal issues before the tribunal were whether the expenses claimed by the corporation met the double reasonableness test and if reasonable steps were taken by the corporation to resolve the dispute before commencing proceedings.

The tribunal considered the material presented in proceedings and the materials subsequently submitted by the parties. The tribunal found that the corporation had not taken reasonable steps to resolve the dispute before commencing proceedings. Specifically, the tribunal found that the respondents had been informed that the alterations required the consent of the executive, but they did not obtain such consent. The tribunal further found that the corporation had commenced proceedings against the respondents without first taking reasonable steps to resolve the dispute. As a result, the tribunal decided not to make an order for recovery of the corporation’s expenses in the proceedings pursuant to section 31.

The tribunal orders that:
1. The application for expenses claimed under section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 is dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The application for expenses claimed under section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

To prove a debt pursuant to section 31 a corporation must establish, amongst other things, that the expenses claimed meet the double reasonableness test established in In the Matter of Ruling Tribunal Section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (Ruling Tribunal Decision), that is that:…it was reasonable for the owners corporation to incur expenses of the type described and the amount of each component of the expenses sought is reasonable.[4][4] In the Matter of Ruling Tribunal Section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 [2017] ACAT 56 at order 1; [55], [104] After considering the material presented in proceedings and the materials subsequently submitted by the parties, I decided not to make an order for recovery of the corporation’s expenses in the proceedings pursuant to section 31 because I found they had not been reasonably incurred. In particular, I found that the corporation had commenced proceedings against the respondents without first taking reasonable steps to resolve the dispute. The reasons for my decision are set out below. The respondents bought their unit in early 2017.Over the following two years they undertook certain work without the approval of the executive committee. I have previously determined that the respondents’ failure to obtain approval for that work contravened Article 4(1) of the Corporation’s Rules which provides under the heading “Erections and Alterations”:A unit owner shall not, except in accordance with the written permission given by the Executive Committee, and in accordance with the written permission given by the Executive Committee, and in accordance with the provisions of any law in force in the Territory applicable in the circumstances, erect or alter any structure in or in the unit or the common property. The respondents submitted that they kept the strata manager and members of the executive informed both before and after commencing work and no objection was raised, nor were they informed that they required the consent of the executive for the works. The strata manager in a sworn statement said that “I have advised Mr and Mrs Quaid that any additions or erections to a unit requires the consent of the Executive Committee.” In August 2018 another unit owner reported to the strata manager that the respondents had made certain exterior changes to their unit. On 7 November 2017 the strata manager wrote to the respondents in the following terms:The Executive Committee of Units Plan 666 note and confirm that additions/erections to the external walls at Lot 1 Wentworth Court have been undertaken without the consent of the Owners Corporation [in accordance with the requirements of the Unit Titles [Management] Act 2011 and the OP 666 Rules.Can you please forward the Committee, within fourteen days of this notice, all plans submitted to the ACT Building Controller approving the above additions/erections.Your assistance in this matter is appreciated. The respondents say they never received the letter, which was addressed to their unit. However, the applicant at paragraph 7 of its submissions pointed out that the lack of response to the letter was also discussed at meetings of the executive committee on 3 December 2018 and 18 February 2019, the latter of which the first respondent attended. It seems likely that, at least by 18 February 2019, the respondents were aware that a letter had been sent and had, at least, a general idea of its contents.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The owners corporation of Units Plan 666 (the corporation) applied to the tribunal for orders in relation to a range of unapproved alterations the respondents had made without the consent of the executive in contravention of Article 4(1) of the Articles of the Unit Plan. The application was made pursuant to the tribunal’s jurisdiction to resolve unit title disputes under section 125 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (UTM Act). At the hearing on 17 January 2020 I upheld the application and made orders requiring the respondents to remedy the contravention. As part of the same application the applicant sought to recover legal professional costs and disbursements, and the fee for lodging the application, which it incurred in bringing the proceedings as expenses pursuant to section 31 of the UTM Act. I reserved my decision on the corporation’s section 31 claim and asked the parties to provide written submissions and evidence to enable me to determine the issue on the papers. My decision in relation to the section 31 issue and reasons are set out below. It is not uncommon for costs incurred by a corporation in tribunal proceedings for the recovery of unpaid unit title levies to be recovered in the same proceedings as ‘expenses’ under section 31 of the UTM Act. Unpaid unit title levies and expenses to which section 31 apply are both recoverable as statutory debts.[1] The Tribunal does not require separate applications as both fall within the tribunal’s jurisdiction to determine debt applications, subject to jurisdictional limits relating to the amount claimed.[2] [1] Section 95 of the UTM Act[2] Part 4 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Act 2008 The corporation in this case applied to resolve a unit title dispute and sought to recover its expenses of those proceedings as part of the same application. The expenses claimed were within the jurisdictional limit of the tribunal.[3] As the claims arise from different jurisdictions of the tribunal, separate unit titles dispute and debt applications would generally be required, but in this case no disadvantage was suffered by determining the claims as part of the same proceedings and unnecessary costs to both the parties and the tribunal were avoided. [3] Part 4 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Act 2008 To prove a debt pursuant to section 31 a corporation must establish, amongst other things, that the expenses claimed meet the double reasonableness test established in In the Matter of Ruling Tribunal Section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (Ruling Tribunal Decision), that is that:…it was reasonable for the owners corporation to incur expenses of the type described and the amount of each component of the expenses sought is reasonable.[4][4] In the Matter of Ruling Tribunal Section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 [2017] ACAT 56 at order 1; [55], [104] After considering the material presented in proceedings and the materials subsequently submitted by the parties, I decided not to make an order for recovery of the corporation’s expenses in the proceedings pursuant to section 31 because I found they had not been reasonably incurred. In particular, I found that the corporation had commenced proceedings against the respondents without first taking reasonable steps to resolve the dispute. The reasons for my decision are set out below.