ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
THE OWNERS UNITS PLAN 2737 v RYAN & ANOR (Unit Titles) [2016] ACAT 43
UT 16/2015
Catchwords: UNIT TITLES – rules infringement notice – removal of courtyard tree – interpretation of units plan - is air space above unit subsidiary common property – what is a ‘nuisance or substantial annoyance’ – order necessary to resolve dispute
Legislation cited: Unit Titles Act 2001 ss 9, 19
Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 ss 107, 109, 129
Default Rules 5, 7
Tribunal: Ms M-T. Daniel - Member
Date of Orders: 24 July 2015
Date of Reasons for Decision: 13 May 2016
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ) UT 16/2015
BETWEEN:
THE OWNERS-UNITS PLAN 2737
Applicant
AND:
PATRICK RYAN AND MARGARET RYAN
Respondents
JOYCE LORRAINE THOMSON
Party Joined
TRIBUNAL: Ms M-T. Daniel - Member
DATE:24 July 2015
The Tribunal made the following ORDERS:
ORDERS
The respondents are to remove the central tree (variety Albizzia julibrissin) from their courtyard within 3 months of this order.
…………signed…………..
Ms M-T. Daniel – Member
REASONS FOR DECISION
These proceedings were initiated by an application by the Owners Corporation of Unit Plan 2737 (the Owners Corporation) for orders under section 129 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (the UTM Act) requiring the respondents Mr and Ms Ryan to comply with a rules infringement notice.
The conduct of the matter and hearing
The manner in which the parties to this matter, who were largely self-represented, prepared and conducted the case must be commended.
The application was filed on 7 April 2015, and the matter came on for directions on 8 May 2015. On that day, directions were made to prepare the matter for a hearing, which was listed to take place on 3 July 2015. At the directions hearing it was identified that Ms Thomson, a neighbour who was particularly affected by the subject matter of the rules infringement notice, had an interest in the proceedings and subsequently Ms Thompson was joined to these proceedings as a party.
In accordance with the directions each party filed and exchanged well prepared evidence in advance of the hearing. The material filed was relevant, comprehensive and timely.
At the hearing on 3 July I heard evidence from the parties, and was provided with written submissions. Together with the parties I attended the site to view the area and trees in question.
Subsequent to the view, at my request, the parties filed a complete copy of the registered units plan and other information.
The hearing resumed on 24 July 2015. At the conclusion of the hearing I made final orders for removal of the central tree, and gave brief oral reasons for my decision. I indicated to the parties that for their future reference I would provide written reasons for the decision. These are those reasons.
The Facts
From the written and oral evidence provided at the hearing, and my own observation of the units and trees at…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners Units Plan 2737 v Ryan & Anor (Unit Titles) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] ACAT 43
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the air space above the Ryans' unit constituted subsidiary common property. The registered units plan indicated that the air space above each unit was subsidiary common property. The court accepted that the trees constituted a nuisance or substantial annoyance, as they had grown to a size that obstructed the balcony of the unit above the Ryans' unit. The court considered the evidence provided by the parties and the site visit it undertook. The court held that the trees constituted a nuisance or substantial annoyance and ordered the Ryans to remove the central tree from their courtyard within three months of the order.
The court ordered the Ryans to remove the central tree (variety Albizzia julibrissin) from their courtyard within three months of the order. The court found that the Ryans had planted the tree in their courtyard in 2006, and that it had grown to a size that obstructed the balcony of the unit above their unit. The court held that the air space above the Ryans' unit constituted subsidiary common property and that the trees constituted a nuisance or substantial annoyance. The court ordered the Ryans to remove the tree within three months of the order, and noted that the Ryans had the right to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court of Western Australia.
Orders
Orders of the court
The respondents are to remove the central tree (variety Albizzia julibrissin) from their courtyard within 3 months of this order.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
These proceedings were initiated by an application by the Owners Corporation of Unit Plan 2737 (the Owners Corporation) for orders under section 129 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (the UTM Act) requiring the respondents Mr and Ms Ryan to comply with a rules infringement notice. The manner in which the parties to this matter, who were largely self-represented, prepared and conducted the case must be commended. The application was filed on 7 April 2015, and the matter came on for directions on 8 May 2015. On that day, directions were made to prepare the matter for a hearing, which was listed to take place on 3 July 2015. At the directions hearing it was identified that Ms Thomson, a neighbour who was particularly affected by the subject matter of the rules infringement notice, had an interest in the proceedings and subsequently Ms Thompson was joined to these proceedings as a party. In accordance with the directions each party filed and exchanged well prepared evidence in advance of the hearing. The material filed was relevant, comprehensive and timely. At the hearing on 3 July I heard evidence from the parties, and was provided with written submissions. Together with the parties I attended the site to view the area and trees in question. Subsequent to the view, at my request, the parties filed a complete copy of the registered units plan and other information. The hearing resumed on 24 July 2015. At the conclusion of the hearing I made final orders for removal of the central tree, and gave brief oral reasons for my decision. I indicated to the parties that for their future reference I would provide written reasons for the decision. These are those reasons. From the written and oral evidence provided at the hearing, and my own observation of the units and trees at the view, I am satisfied of the following facts. The respondents own and occupy a ground floor unit in the complex, unit G03. Unit GO3 has a north facing courtyard which is a unit subsidiary. There is also an east facing courtyard which is a unit subsidiary. The party joined owns and occupies the first floor unit directly above unit G03, unit 103. Unit 103 has a north facing balcony which projects out over part of the northfacing courtyard of unit G03. In 2006 the owners corporation gave the respondents written permission to plant two trees in their courtyard. In fact, three trees were planted and flourished. The three trees are of the variety Albizia julibrissin, commonly called the silk tree. The silk trees are deciduous, and produce a significant amount of foliage during their growing season. In 2010 the silk trees first started to impact on the balcony, and thus the residents, of unit 103. It was suggested that the trees should be pruned to a height below the first floor balcony. While this was initially resisted by the respondents, by 2013 lawyers had become involved, and the trees were pruned later in 2013 as requested. Undaunted, the trees grew back. On 11 March 2015, the owners corporation issued a rules infringement notice to the respondents under section 109 of the UTM Act requiring the silk trees to be pruned to the level of the first floor balcony within 14 days, failing which application would be made to the Tribunal. That notice was not complied with, and so the current proceedings were instituted.