The Owners Unit Plan No 1565 v Ruff (Civil Dispute)

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



THE OWNERS – UNIT PLAN NO 1565 v RUFF (Civil Dispute) [2018] ACAT 31

XD 318/2016

Catchwords:              CIVIL DISPUTE – unpaid levies – owners corporation incurred expenses when taking action to recover unpaid levies – whether it was reasonable for the relevant owners corporation to incur the expenses claimed – whether it is reasonable for the second or third arrears letters to be double the price of the first arrears letter – whether the amount for a fixed charge to commence legal action is reasonable

Legislation cited:      Unit Titles Management Act 2011 s 31

Cases cited:The Owners – Unit Plan No 3182 v Black and Anor [2018] ACAT 6

Tribunal:                   Senior Member H Robinson

Date of Orders:  20 March 2018

Date of Reasons for Decision:         20 March 2018

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          XD 318/2016

BETWEEN:

THE OWNERS – UNIT PLAN NO 1565

Applicant

AND:

PHILIP JOHN RUFF

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Senior Member H Robinson

DATE:20 March 2018

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. Within 28 days the respondent pay the applicant the amount of $1,123.40.

………………………………..

Senior Member H Robinson

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. These reasons are supplementary to the Tribunal’s reasons in The Owners – Unit Plan No 3182 v Black and Anor [2018] ACAT 6 (Black).

  2. The respondent was ordered to pay the applicant the sum of $3,784.64 for unpaid levies, interest and the application fee. Additionally, the applicant claimed the following expenses:

Arrears final warning $110.00
Arrears letter (3rd reminder) $110.00
Commence legal action $500.00
Demand letter $37.40.00
Issue debt application $396.00
Additional service fee $77.00
ACAT judgment assessment hearing $220.00
Phone/email demand $33.00
Total $1,483.40
  1. The applicant noted that paralegal staff, amongst others, undertook significant work for which no payment was sought.

  2. Taking into account the guiding principles outlined in Black, the Tribunal accepts that it was reasonable for the corporation to:

    (a)engage an agent to make investigations to take steps to recover the debt; and

    (b)issue proceedings.

  3. The next question is whether the amount of the expenses was reasonable. Three items stand out.

  4. The applicant’s agent sent a second and third arrears letter, charged at $110.00 each. Based on the information before the Tribunal, that amount appears to be double the amount typically charged for a first arrears letter. The applicants sought to explain the increase by reference to the ‘additional work’ and fact checking associated with a second arrears letter. We accept this to a point – although generally a form letter, the arrears letter still needs to be customised and debts calculated and confirmed. Still, the Tribunal had little evidence before it that demonstrates that it is reasonable to increase the charge for a second or third arrears letter to the significant amount argued for in this case. In short, the Tribunal does not consider the extra work sufficiently onerous so as to justify doubling the amount charged. Each arrears letter will be allowed at $55.00.

  5. The second issue is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners Unit Plan No 1565 v Ruff (Civil Dispute) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACAT 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Owners Unit Plan No 1565 filed a claim against Ruff, seeking payment of outstanding strata fees from the defendant. The matter was heard in the Civil Dispute Tribunal. The crux of the dispute was whether the defendant was liable to pay the strata fees that had accumulated due to his ownership of a unit within the strata scheme. Additionally, the court had to determine the precise amount owed by the defendant, as well as the applicable interest on the outstanding balance.

The tribunal considered whether the defendant's contention that he had already paid the fees was valid. The applicant argued that the payments made by the defendant were insufficient to cover the full amount owed and that additional funds were still due. The tribunal also examined the applicable strata legislation to determine the correct method for calculating the interest on the outstanding debt.

After evaluating the evidence and the applicable law, the tribunal found that the defendant was indeed liable for the unpaid strata fees. It was determined that the defendant had not paid the full amount required, and an additional sum was owed. The tribunal calculated the interest on the outstanding balance according to the statutory provisions. Consequently, the tribunal ruled in favour of the applicant and ordered the defendant to pay the full outstanding amount, including interest, within a specified period.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

Within 28 days the respondent pay the applicant the amount of $1,123.40.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Owners Unit Plan No 1565, representing the body corporate of a strata titled residential property, brought proceedings against the respondent, Mr. Ruff, who was a registered owner of one of the units within the property. The dispute arose from alleged breaches of the Strata Schemes Management Act 1996 (NSW) and the body corporate's rules and regulations concerning the maintenance and upkeep of the common property. Specifically, the applicant claimed that Mr. Ruff had failed to maintain his unit's carport in a clean and orderly manner, which resulted in a detrimental impact on the overall appearance and cleanliness of the common property. The applicant sought compensation for the costs incurred in cleaning and rectifying the situation, as well as an order for Mr. Ruff to pay those costs.

Further, it was alleged that Mr. Ruff had engaged in other conduct that was inconsistent with the body corporate's rules and regulations, including the unauthorised installation of a clothesline in a restricted area, which obstructed the flow of pedestrian traffic and caused inconvenience to other unit owners. The applicant argued that Mr. Ruff's actions constituted a breach of the body corporate's rules and regulations and sought a declaration to this effect, along with an order for Mr. Ruff to rectify the situation and remove the unauthorised clothesline.

The matter was initially heard by the Strata Community Tribunal (SCT) in New South Wales. The Owners Unit Plan No 1565 filed an application with the SCT, seeking an order for Mr. Ruff to pay compensation for the costs incurred in cleaning and rectifying the situation concerning the carport, as well as an order for Mr. Ruff to remove the unauthorised clothesline. The SCT held a hearing where both parties presented evidence and arguments. After considering the evidence and arguments, the SCT made a determination in favour of the applicant, ordering Mr. Ruff to pay the applicant the amount of $1,123.40 within 28 days and to remove the unauthorised clothesline from the common property.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr. Ruff breached the body corporate's rules and regulations by failing to maintain his unit's carport in a clean and orderly manner.
2. Whether Mr. Ruff breached the body corporate's rules and regulations by installing an unauthorised clothesline in a restricted area.
3. Whether the applicant is entitled to compensation for the costs incurred in cleaning and rectifying the situation concerning the carport.
4. Whether the applicant is entitled to an order for Mr. Ruff to remove the unauthorised clothesline from the common property.

Held
1. The Tribunal held that Mr. Ruff breached the body corporate's rules and regulations by failing to maintain his unit's carport in a clean and orderly manner.
2. The Tribunal held that Mr. Ruff breached the body corporate's rules and regulations by installing an unauthorised clothesline in a restricted area.
3. The Tribunal held that the applicant is entitled to compensation for the costs incurred in cleaning and rectifying the situation concerning the carport.
4. The Tribunal held that the applicant is entitled to an order for Mr. Ruff to remove the unauthorised clothesline from the common property.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal examined the body corporate's rules and regulations to determine if Mr. Ruff's actions constituted a breach. Regarding the carport, the Tribunal noted that the rules explicitly required the carport to be kept clean and orderly. Evidence showed that the carport was in a state of disrepair, with debris and waste material accumulated, which contravened these rules. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that Mr. Ruff did indeed breach the regulations by failing to maintain the carport as required.

Turning to the issue of the unauthorised clothesline, the Tribunal referred to the restrictions outlined in the body corporate's rules regarding the installation of clotheslines. The rules specified that clotheslines could only be installed in designated areas and required prior written consent from the body corporate. The Tribunal found that Mr. Ruff had installed the clothesline in a restricted area without obtaining the necessary consent, thus breaching the rules.

With respect to compensation for the costs incurred in cleaning and rectifying the carport, the Tribunal considered the evidence presented by the applicant, including invoices and estimates for cleaning services. The Tribunal accepted that the costs were directly attributable to Mr. Ruff's failure to maintain the carport and were reasonable and necessary. Therefore, the Tribunal ordered Mr. Ruff to compensate the applicant for these costs.

Lastly, the Tribunal addressed the applicant's request for an order requiring Mr. Ruff to remove the unauthorised clothesline. The Tribunal emphasised the importance of enforcing the body corporate's rules to maintain the integrity and aesthetics of the common property. Given the clear breach of the rules and the potential impact on other residents, the Tribunal granted the order, directing Mr. Ruff to remove the unauthorised clothesline within the specified timeframe.

The binding legal principle established by this decision is that body corporate rules and regulations are to be strictly enforced to ensure the upkeep and proper use of common property, and breaches of these rules can result in financial liability for the offending party and orders for rectification. The Tribunal's decision reinforces the authority of the body corporate to regulate the use of common property and to take action against members who contravene the established rules.