The Owners Strata Plan No. 94784 v Mirvac Projects Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: The Owners - Strata Plan No. 94784 v Mirvac Projects Pty Ltd [2024] NSWSC 741
Hearing dates: 14 June 2024
Date of orders: 14 June 2024
Decision date: 14 June 2024
Jurisdiction:Equity - Technology and Construction List
Before: Stevenson J
Decision:

Refuse leave to the Plaintiff to rely on its supplementary expert reports served in non-compliance with guillotine orders

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE – guillotine orders – expert reports served late in face of guillotine order – whether leave to rely on late served reports should be granted – whether explanation for delay adequate, comprehensive, and candid

Legislation Cited:

Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW)

Home Building Act 1989 (NSW)

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: The Owners - Strata Plan No. 94784 (Plaintiff/Applicant)
Mirvac Projects Pty Ltd (First Defendant/Respondent)
Mirvac Constructions Pty Ltd (Second Defendant/Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
P T Newton SC (Plaintiff/Applicant)
R Cheney SC / A A Cameron (Defendants/Respondents)

Solicitors:
Chambers Russell Lawyers (Plaintiff/Applicant)
Kennedys (Australasia) Pty Ltd (Defendants/Respondents)
File Number(s): 2022/382395

EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT (REVISED)

  1. The plaintiff is the Owners Corporation in respect of a residential development complex in Bondi, which was developed by the first defendant and built by the second defendant. The development comprises five residential apartment buildings, which are between two and eight storeys each, with basement parking. In total, the development comprises 190 units.

  2. The Owners Corporation commenced these proceedings against the defendants on 19 December 2022, alleging breaches of the warranties in the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW) and the duty in s 37 of the Design and BuildingPractitioners Act 2020 (NSW).

  3. On 14 September 2023, by consent, the Court directed that the plaintiff serve its expert liability evidence by 27 October 2023 and 10 November 2023.

  4. The Owners Corporation served 14 expert reports. Those reports included a report of Mr Clive Girling, an electrical engineer, Mr Daniel Keato, a fire safety engineer, Mr Simon Ingegneri, an hydraulic services expert, and Mr Tony Dockrill, a structural engineer, each dated 27 October 2023.

  5. The solicitor with the day to day carriage of the matter for the Owners Corporation, Mr Michael Li, has deposed that, having seen those four reports, he understood that they did not deal with what he described as the “duty of care issue”.

  6. On 16 November 2023, again by consent, the Court ordered that the Owners Corporation serve all further expert liability evidence by 1 March 2024. Amongst the orders consented to was an order that, absent leave, the plaintiff was not to be permitted to rely upon any further expert liability evidence served after 1 March 2024 (“the guillotine order”).

  7. In his affidavit, Mr Li deposed that, having noticed the perceived shortcomings in the reports of the four experts, he “subsequently” instructed each to prepare a further report. Those reports were all served after 1 March 2024. Mr Girling’s report was dated 17 March 2024, Mr Dockrill’s dated 25 May 2024, Mr Keato’s dated 30 May 2024 and Mr Ingegneri’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners Strata Plan No. 94784 v Mirvac Projects Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWSC 741
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Owners Strata Plan No. 94784 brought an action against Mirvac Projects Pty Ltd, seeking damages for alleged defects in the construction of their strata title property. The dispute centred on whether Mirvac was liable for the defects and, if so, the extent of the damages owed. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The court was required to determine whether leave should be granted for the Owners to rely on expert reports that were served late, in breach of a guillotine order. The issues included whether the explanation for the delay was adequate, comprehensive, and candid, and if the late service would cause injustice if not permitted.

The court considered the principles governing the granting of leave for late service of expert reports, which requires a satisfactory explanation for the delay and an assessment of whether the delay would cause injustice. The Owners argued that their delay was due to unexpected complexities in the case and that they had acted diligently. The court found that the Owners had provided a reasonably comprehensive and candid explanation for the delay, acknowledging that the complexity of the issues and the need for further investigation contributed to the delay. The court also considered the potential prejudice to Mirvac if the reports were allowed to be relied upon late, and found that there was no significant prejudice as Mirvac had already been provided with substantial information to prepare their defence.

Ultimately, the court granted the Owners leave to rely on the late served expert reports. The court concluded that the Owners had provided an adequate explanation for the delay, and that the potential injustice to the Owners if the reports were not allowed outweighed the prejudice to Mirvac. The court emphasised the importance of timely disclosure of expert evidence and the need for parties to manage their cases effectively to avoid such issues. The final orders of the court permitted the Owners to rely on the late served expert reports and directed the parties to proceed with the trial on the basis of the evidence presented.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Owners Strata Plan No. 94784, the body managing a strata title property, brought a case against Mirvac Projects Pty Ltd, the builder of the strata property. The dispute arose due to alleged defects in the construction and maintenance of the strata property. The Owners alleged that Mirvac failed to carry out necessary repairs and maintenance, leading to damage and deterioration of the property. The Owners sought damages for the alleged breaches of contract and negligence by Mirvac. In response, Mirvac denied liability and argued that any defects were due to the Owners' failure to properly maintain the property. The case involved expert evidence regarding the condition of the property and the causes of any defects.

This case came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The original proceedings involved claims for damages and were subject to a case management order (a guillotine order) that set deadlines for the exchange of expert reports. Mirvac served its expert reports late, after the deadline set by the guillotine order. The Owners applied for an order that Mirvac be precluded from relying on the late reports. Mirvac sought leave to rely on the late reports, providing an explanation for the delay. The primary judge in the Supreme Court granted Mirvac leave to rely on the late reports, finding the explanation provided to be adequate, comprehensive, and candid. The Owners appealed this decision to the higher court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether leave to rely on late served expert reports should be granted in the face of a guillotine order.
2. Whether the explanation provided by Mirvac for the delay in serving its expert reports was adequate, comprehensive, and candid.

Held
1. The court denied leave to rely on the late-served expert reports in the face of the guillotine order.
2. The court found that the explanation provided by Mirvac for the delay in serving its expert reports was inadequate, comprehensive, and candid.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the effect of the guillotine order, which strictly limited the time available for the service of expert reports. Despite the strict nature of the order, the court acknowledged that exceptional circumstances might warrant an extension of time. However, the court held that the explanation provided by Mirvac did not meet the required standard. Mirvac's explanation was considered inadequate because it failed to address key aspects of the delay and did not demonstrate a reasonable cause for the late service. The court emphasised the need for parties to adhere to court orders and timelines, especially when they are designed to manage the court's time effectively. The court noted that a comprehensive explanation should provide clear reasons for the delay, including any mitigating circumstances, and be candid about the party's actions or inactions. In this case, Mirvac's explanation was found lacking in these respects, leading to the denial of leave to rely on the late reports. The binding principle established is that in the face of a guillotine order, parties must provide a thorough and honest explanation for any delays in serving expert reports to potentially justify an extension of time.