The Men's Gallery Australia Pty Ltd v Platinum 253 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by The Men’s Gallery Australia Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application 1026410(41)(43) MG Men’s Gallery Logo in the name of Platinum 253 Pty Ltd.

Delegate:

Iain Thompson

Representation:

2008 ATMO 32

Opponent: Graeme Clarke, Senior Counsel instructed by Gary Prince of Gary Prince, Solicitor.

Applicant: Written submissions by Hodgkinson McInnes Patents

Decision:

Section 52 opposition – Section 60 – trade marks deceptively similar – evidence of actual confusion – use of opposed trade mark likely to deceive or confuse – section 60 established.

Costs

Awarded against applicant

Background

  1. Trade mark application 1026410 MG Men’s Gallery Logo was filed on 22 October 2004 (‘the relevant date’) by Platinum 253 Pty Ltd of Level 1, 285 George Street, Sydney, (‘the applicant’) in respect of the services “Entertainment services” (Class 41) and “Restaurant services” (Class 43) and, after examination and amendment, its acceptance for possible registration was advertised on 21 September 2006.  Current details of the application are set out below:

    Application Number:  1026410

    Priority Date:  22 October 2004

    Goods & Services:  Class: 41 Theatre restaurants (entertainment services)

    Class: 43 Theatre restaurants (provision of food and drink)

    (‘the opposed trade mark’)

    Trade Mark:  

    Endorsement:  Provisions of paragraph 44(3)(a) applied.

  2. Subsection 44(3), below, allows acceptance for registration under certain established circumstances in respect of applications which prima facie conflict with prior applications or registrations under subsections 44(1) or 44(2):

    3)If the Registrar in either case is satisfied:

    (a)that there has been honest concurrent use of the 2 trade marks; or

    (b)that, because of other circumstances, it is proper to do so;

    the Registrar may accept the application for the registration of the applicant’s trade mark subject to any conditions or limitations that the Registrar thinks fit to impose. If the applicant’s trade mark has been used only in a particular area, the limitations may include that the use of the trade mark is to be restricted to that particular area.

  3. The Men's Gallery Australia Pty Ltd, of 241 King Street, Melbourne, Victoria, (‘the opponent’), lodged Notice of Opposition (‘the Notice’) to registration on 18 December 2006.

  4. The evidence of the parties consists of the following declarations:

No.

Declarant

Position

Date Made

Exhibits

Evidence in Support

#1

Peter Iwaniuk

Sole Director and shareholder of opponent

15 December 2006

PI-1 to PI-9

Evidence in Answer

#2

Clair Fitzpatrick

Trade Mark Attorney

10 May 2006

A to B

#3

Christian Paris Hardin

General Manager of opponent

10 May 2006

(Exhibit A of #2 with exhibits A to C)

#4

Christian Paris Hardin

General Manager of opponent

24 August 2006

(Exhibit B of #2)

Evidence in Reply

#4

Peter Iwaniuk

Sole Director and shareholder of opponent

21 November 2006

PI-1

#5

Selwyn Greenberg

Chartered Accountant – Principal of Greenberg & Co – Chartered Accountants & Business Consultants

18 September 2007

SG

#6

Dave Goddard

Employee of IBSA Pty Ltd (software and web page designers)

20 November 2007

DG

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Men's Gallery Australia Pty Ltd v Platinum 253 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ATMO 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Men's Gallery Australia Pty Ltd (the opponent) opposed the registration of a trade mark by Platinum 253 Pty Ltd (the applicant). The dispute concerned the applicant's attempt to register a logo trade mark, which the opponent argued should be refused registration. The matter was heard by Iain Thompson, a Hearing Officer for Trade Marks Hearings.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the opponent had established grounds for opposing the applicant's trade mark application under section 60 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). This section relates to the use of a trade mark that is identical or deceptively similar to a registered trade mark, and whether that use has caused or is likely to cause confusion among the public. The court was required to assess the evidence presented by both parties regarding the use and marketing of their respective trade marks.

The Hearing Officer found that the opponent had successfully established its opposition under section 60. The evidence demonstrated that the opponent had been operating a well-established "gentleman's club" in Melbourne under the trade mark "The Men's Gallery" since 1993, offering entertainment, bar, and restaurant services. The opponent had also registered its trade mark and engaged in extensive marketing efforts, including advertising in various publications and at Tullamarine airport, and had a significant weekly attendance. In contrast, the applicant's evidence was found to be deficient, with photocopied declarations lacking explanation and containing initial errors regarding the opponent's trade mark. The Hearing Officer concluded that the opponent's established use and marketing of its trade mark were sufficient to warrant refusal of the applicant's application.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer refused to register the applicant's trade mark application and awarded costs against the applicant in favour of the opponent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The opposed application was filed before significant amendment to section 60, which came into force on 23 October 2007, and thus the pre-amendment version of the section applies.[1][1] Apple Computer Inc v Todaytech Group Ltd [2007] ATMO 40; Health World Limited v Shin-Sun Australia Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 100 (21 February 2008)Evidence The evidence shows that the opponent has run a ‘gentleman’s club’ in Melbourne’s central business district known as The Men’s Gallery since 1993. This club runs various entertainments under its trade mark, pitched at a predominantly male market, which include table and other exotic dancing, five liquor bars, restaurant services and three function rooms. Mr Iwaniuk who is the director and sole shareholder of the opponent says (in his declaration #1) that he travelled extensively in the USA in order to garner ideas for his club that was to cater to the business end of the market. The opponent employed thirty staff and approximately two hundred showgirls each week and the declarant states that similar staffing levels have continued. Mr Iwaniuk says the opponent markets services under the trade mark towards business men and professionals and in particular those from interstate. Some evidence of this marketing is a flier directed to taxi drivers that offers all taxi drivers complimentary [sic] entry and free coffee, tea or soft drinks. Other promotional material in evidence was apparently designed for placement in hotels, such as pamphlets and ‘Concierge Passes’ to be given by hotel concierges or reception staff to guests to enable free entry to the opponent’s club. The opponent established a website in 1994 ( advertised in a free magazine called Destination Melbourne, distributed at Tullamarine airport; and placed advertisements in publications such as Truth, The Herald Sun and the Sunday Age as well as magazines such as Penthouse, Eros and Picture. Examples of these advertisements are in evidence. It has also advertised on billboards in or around Tullamarine airport. The opponent has also registered its trade mark, details of which appear below:Registration Number: 678935Priority Date: 23 November 1995Goods & Services: Class: 41 Entertainment services including table dancingTrade Mark: The declarant attests that up to 5,000 clients attend the club each week, many of who are from interstate or from country Victoria. The applicant’s evidence in answer comprises two declarations by Mr Christian Hardin who has been General Manager of the applicant since 2004. These are photocopied declarations and not originals with no explanation in the attorney’s covering declaration of why this is so and are weighted accordingly. The declarations both erroneously start by making reference to the opposed trade mark as being the words MEN’S GALLERY SYDNEY but both declarations make intermittent and general allusion to the logo form of the trade mark which is here opposed. As evidence of the start date for the use of the trade mark the first declaration in answer looks to a Business Names Extract at Exhibit A. A simple entry on a business names register is not evidence per se of the public use of a trade mark although it might add some degree of corroboration to other materials. However, a fortiori, it cannot have any possible bearing on whether a logo form trade mark such as that which is here opposed has been used. Clarity is not added within the second declaration in answer where the declarant states:A graphic designer was employed to design several logo versions of the trade mark. These were completed done [sic] and presented to responsible officers of the applicant company who chose the MG MEN’S GALLERY Sydney version as the most appealing and it has been used continuous [sic] in Australia since that time without complaint.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The opponent has established its section 60 ground.Decision Section 55 of the Act provides:Unless the proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application; having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. I have found the opposition has been established on the ground under section 60 of the Act argued at the hearing. I refuse to register application 1026410.Costs Both parties made a claim for costs. As there is nothing before me suggesting that costs should not follow the general rule, I award costs against the applicant in accord with Schedule 8 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995.Iain ThompsonHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings13 May 2008

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established