The Licensee v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

The Licensee v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2019] QCAT 224

PARTIES:

THE LICENSEE

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR029-19

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

12 August 2019

HEARING DATE:

20 and 21 May 2019

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member A Fitzpatrick

ORDERS:

1.   The Decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission made 8 January 2018 is confirmed.

2.   Leave is granted to both parties for legal representation in the proceeding.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – BUILDERS –LICENCES AND REGISTRATION – where decision made to suspend licence because of failure to meet minimum financial requirements – where applicant filed an application to review – construction of MFR Policy – whether Related Entity loan is a current asset

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 3, s 35(3), s 76
Queensland Building and Construction Commission (Minimum Financial Requirements) Regulation 2018 (Qld), current as at 1 January 2019, current as at 2 April 2019, current as at 31 December 2019, s 12, s 22
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20, s 43(2)(b)(ii), s 66

Allina Pty Ltd v FCT (1991) 28 FCR 203
Bridge v Mattis (1953) AR (NSW) 49
Commonwealth v Baume (1905) 2 CLR 405
Metropolitan Gas Co v Federated Gas Employees’ Industrial Union (1924) 35 CLR 449

Re Pacific Film Laboratories Pty Ltd and Collector of Customs (1979) 2 ALD 144

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

BWJ Kidston instructed by Hall Lawyers Pty Ltd

Respondent:

C Hill, in-house Solicitor, Queensland Building and Construction Commission

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 1 February 2019 an order was made granting a stay of a decision of the Respondent made 8 January 2019 to suspend the Licensee’s carpentry licence for failure to meet Minimum Financial Requirements necessary to hold that licence.

  2. Reasons for the decision to grant the stay were delivered on 7 February 2019.

  3. An order pursuant to section 66 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (‘QCAT Act’) has been made in the matter. The parties have therefore been de-identified.

  4. I note that although both parties have been legally represented throughout in this matter, no leave has been sought. A query in relation to this point was raised with the Tribunal after the hearing by the Respondent. I am of the view that no leave for legal representation is required as this matter falls within s43(2)(b) (ii) of the QCAT Act. In any event, if I am wrong, leave is now granted to both parties for legal representation with respect to all appearances to date and for the balance of this proceeding.

    Decision the subject of the review and scope of the review

  5. On 20 May 2019 this Tribunal heard the Licensee’s application to review the 8 January 2019 decision.

  6. The parties are agreed that the scope of the review is limited to a review of the decision made 8 January 2019 to suspend the Licensee’s licence because, as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Licensee v Queensland Building and Construction Commissi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 224
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) involves an application by a building license holder, referred to as the Licensee, to review a decision made by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (Commission) to suspend the Licensee's licence due to non-compliance with the Minimum Financial Requirements (MFR) as stipulated in the MFR Policy. The core dispute centres on the interpretation of the MFR Policy, specifically whether certain related entity loans should be classified as current assets in the calculation of the Licensee's current ratio.

The primary legal issue before the court was the interpretation of the MFR Policy to determine the correct classification of related entity loans as current assets. The Licensee argued that certain related entity loans should be included as current assets in calculating the current ratio, while the Commission disagreed, resulting in the Licensee's current ratio falling below the required 1:1 threshold.

The Tribunal examined the definition of 'current assets' within the MFR Policy, which includes assets that are realisable, sold, or consumed within twelve months and are held for trading purposes. The Tribunal found that the related entity loans to D and E were collectible and convertible into cash as of the balance date, thus qualifying as current assets. The Tribunal also noted that the Licensee's accountant, who is an Accepted Independent Accountant, had included these loans as current assets based on the related entities' positive net asset positions and the likelihood of collecting the loans within twelve months. This interpretation aligns with the MFR Policy, which requires that related entity loans be collectible to be included as current assets.

The Tribunal concluded that the MFR Policy must be adhered to as of 31 December 2018 and upheld the Commission's decision to suspend the Licensee's licence. The Tribunal confirmed the decision of the Commission and granted leave to both parties for legal representation throughout the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission made 8 January 2018 is confirmed.

2. Leave is granted to both parties for legal representation in the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I note that although both parties have been legally represented throughout in this matter, no leave has been sought. A query in relation to this point was raised with the Tribunal after the hearing by the Respondent. I am of the view that no leave for legal representation is required as this matter falls within s43(2)(b) (ii) of the QCAT Act. In any event, if I am wrong, leave is now granted to both parties for legal representation with respect to all appearances to date and for the balance of this proceeding.Decision the subject of the review and scope of the review On 20 May 2019 this Tribunal heard the Licensee’s application to review the 8 January 2019 decision. The parties are agreed that the scope of the review is limited to a review of the decision made 8 January 2019 to suspend the Licensee’s licence because, as at 31 December 2018, the Licensee did not meet the relevant Minimum Financial Requirements set out in the Respondent’s Policy effective 9 October 2015 (‘MFR Policy’) (Exhibit 12).[1] The relevant financial requirement is that the Licensee’s ratio of Current Assets to Current Liabilities must be 1:1.[1]Section 35(3) Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld); Minimum Financial Requirements Policy effective 9 October 2015. The MFR Policy has been the subject of legislative change. Counsel for the Licensee took me through the proposals for change culminating in the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (Minimum Financial Requirements) Regulation 2018 (Qld) which commenced on 1 January 2019 and a further Regulation which commenced on 2 April 2019. I have since noted an amending Regulation commencing on 14 June 2019. The question is do the reforms introduced by the Regulations apply to the Licensee’s financial position prior to 1 January 2019? The Licensee’s submissions, with which the Respondent did not disagree, are that:(a)By s 76 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) current as at 1 January 2019, the MFR Policy continues in force until the matters provided for under the Policy are prescribed by Regulation.(b)By s 12 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (Minimum Financial Requirements) Regulation 2018 (Qld) current as at 1 January 2019, Part 4 in relation to Net Tangible Assets of the Licensee applies despite the continued MFR Policy, to the extent of any inconsistency.(c)By transitional provisions set out at s 22 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (Minimum Financial Requirements) Regulation 2018 (Qld) current as at 1 January 2019, Part 4 does not apply to the Licensee until the first annual reporting day to occur after the commencement as stated in the notice given to the person under s 21. By s 21, the notice must be given at least 40 days before the annual reporting day stated in the notice.Section 22(3) provides that the continued MFR policy, Part 2 continues to apply to the person until the first annual reporting day. Part 2 relates to Net Tangible Assets. As at the date of the decision the annual reporting day had not arrived.(d)By the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (Minimum Financial Requirements) Regulation 2018 (Qld) (‘MFR Regulation’) current as at 2 April 2019, the MFR Policy was repealed and the requirements were transferred to the MFR Regulation. (e)It is concluded that the MFR Policy must be complied with by the Licensee as at 31 December 2018 and that is the Policy which I must apply when reviewing the Respondent’s decision of 8 January 2019.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Family Group Balance Sheet records another Related Entity loan in favour of D and E. A note on the Balance Sheet for the Family Group records that D and E have sold their home. As a result, their home and the loan have been replaced with cash at bank of just over $650,000.00, which is noted as a Current Asset. The house was listed for sale as at 31 December 2018 and was sold on 5 March 2019.[7] The Respondent now accepts that considering the sale information, the loan to D and E could properly be taken into account in calculating Current Assets of the Licensee. I find that the loan to D and E in the sum of $237,667.00 is a Current Asset for the purpose of calculating the Licensee’s Current Assets as at 31 December 2018.[7]Historical title search Exhibit 11.Differing calculations of the Applicant’s Current Ratio It is not contested that the Licensee’s accountant, Mr Diacos is an Accepted Independent Accountant in the terms of the MFR Policy. Mr Diacos included the Related Entity loans to A and B, and to C, as Current Assets in the Licensee’s Balance Sheet. He has done so because he considers the loans to be collectible as required by the MFR Policy. He considers they are collectible because the Related Entities have positive net asset positions in their own right when one takes into account the value of their homes. Further, in circumstances where the profits of a trust are distributed to the beneficiaries of the trust as at 30 June each year (recorded against the current account of the beneficiaries) and given the history of profits of the Licensee the current assets pertaining to the beneficiaries could easily be collected in 12 months.[8] Including the Related Entity loans to A and B and to C as Current Assets brings the proportion of Current Assets as to Current Liabilities into an acceptable ratio of 1.1967:1. [8]Exhibit 8 Affidavit of Craig Mitchell Hall filed 24 January 2019, page 7. The Respondent submits that the Licensee’s Current Ratio as at 31 December 2018 is 0.84:1.[9] The Respondent has taken into account as Current Assets, the Related Entity loan to D and E, but not the Related Entity loans to A and B, and C.[9]T2-22 lines 31-35.MFR Policy This matter involves the proper construction of the MFR Policy. It is helpful to set out relevant parts of the MFR Policy. I have marked parts of the extracts in bold to assist in interpretation of the MFR Policy.2.2 Objectives…The objectives of the Minimum Financial Requirements in this policy are to promote financially viable businesses and foster professional business practices in the Queensland building industry.To achieve these objectives and minimise the incidence of financial failure in the building industry, this policy requires all applicants and licensees to comply with the Minimum Financial Requirements.2.3 Applicants and Licensees must comply with this policy…It is also a statutory condition of holding a licence that the Licensee’s financial circumstances must at all times continue to satisfy the relevant Minimum Financial Requirements stated in this policy. If a Licensee breaches a condition on their licence, their licence may be suspended or cancelled under section 48 of the Act.…4. Current RatioDefinitions for Section 4:In this section:Current Assets -means assets:a) which are realised, sold or consumed in the normal operating cycle of the business;b) which are realised within twelve months after the reporting period;c) which are held primarily for the purpose of trading (refer AASB 139);d) which are cash or a cash equivalent (as defined in AASB 107) unless the asset is restricted from being exchanged or used to settle a liability.Related Entity loans and/or investments included as current assets must be collectible and convertible into cash as at balance date.…Current Assets do not include:a) Any Related Entity loans or investments assets which are not collectible;…d) Real property not currently listed on the market for sale;e) Disallowed assetsCurrent Liabilities –…Current Ratio –Means the ratio calculated by using the following formula:Current AssetsCurrent LiabilitiesTo meet the requirements an Applicant or Licensee’s Current Ratio must be at least 1:1.4.1 Financial Requirement – Current RatioIt is a financial requirement that Applicants and Licensees must meet the Current Ratio requirement at time of Application, and at all times whilst the licence is held.4.2 Calculating the Current RatioThe Current Ratio is calculated in accordance with the defined formula.Current assets included in the calculation of the Current Ratio must be in accordance with the definition of current assets in this policy.The Commission may require the Applicant, Licensee or Accepted Independent Accountant to provide evidence of the classification of an asset as a current asset. Where such evidence is not provided the Commission may automatically reclassify such assets as non-current assets without further notice to the Applicant or Licensee.All current liabilities of an Applicant or Licensee must be included in the calculation of the Current Ratio, including any loans to Related Entities payable by the Applicant or Licensee in the 12 months following the end of the reporting period.…4.3 Determining Current Assets and Current Liabilities based on Licensee StructureDepending on the structure of the Applicant or Licensee, the Current Ratio may only be met from current assets and current liabilities …6. Accepted Independent AccountantsDefinitions for Section 6In this section:Accepted Independent Accountant –means a person with the qualifications specified in this policy who is permitted to complete MFR Reports regarding the financial position of an Applicant or Licensee.…6.5 Reporting Requirements for Accepted Independent AccountantsThe Accepted Independent Accountant providing Reports must make appropriate enquiries of the Applicant or Licensee, and seek independent evidence that is appropriate in the circumstances, in their professional opinion, to justify the information stated in the MFR Report.MFR Reports or any other reports to the Commission will be deemed incomplete for assessment where they are qualified by disclaimer clauses or emphasis of matter clauses by the Accepted Independent Accountant giving the report.6.6 Determining Collectability of Related Entity Loans or Investment AssetsThe Accepted Independent Accountant must determine collectability of any Related Entity loan or investment assets based on the financial position of the Related Entity as at the same balance date as the MFR Report or other report.As a minimum the Accepted Independent Accountant is required to view the balance sheet of the Related Entity, for the relevant balance date and ensure the Related Entity loan or investment is shown as a liability for the same amount, and classification, as stated by the Applicant or Licensee. The Related Entity must then have a positive net asset position in its own right as at the relevant balance date.Where the Related Entity in question is owed loans by other Related Entities, the Accepted Independent Accountant must also determine those loans are collectible or deduct those amounts form the Related Entities net assets.Where a Related Entity has a deficiency of assets, any loans owed to the Applicant or Licensee by that Related Entity must be deducted from the Net Tangible Assets and Current Ratio of the Applicant or Licensee. Evidence of collectability is required to be provided to the Commission upon request.…14. Definitions…Collectible –Means convertible to cash as at balance sheet date. For Related Entity Loan or Investment assets it means the Related Entity has net current assets and net tangible assets as at balance sheet date sufficient to repay the loan in full.Evidence of Mr Diacos