The King v Abuelheish (aka Jorban)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

CITATION:The King v Abuelheish (aka Jorban) [2025] NTSC 47

PARTIES:THE KING

v

ABUELHEISH (aka JORBAN), Ahmad

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:22528337

DELIVERED:  10 July 2025

HEARING DATE:  2 July 2025

JUDGMENT OF:  Reeves J

CATCHWORDS:

CRIME – Bail – Review of Local Court grant of bail– s 36(1) Bail Act 1982 – Offences under Misuse of Dugs Act 1990 – Supply of commercial quantity of methamphetamine – Offences exceeding maximum term of 7 years – Presumption against bail – Two-step process of s 7A Bail Act 1982 – Criteria of s 24 Bail Act 1982 – Consideration of assessments required by “would”, “will” and “high degree of confidence” in ss 7A(2AB), 24 Bail Act 1982 – Limitation imposed by “only” in s 24 Bail Act 1982 – Meaning of “community” in ss 7A, 24 Bail Act – Probabilistic assessment of the risk the accused “would” pose to community under s 24(1)(aa) Bail Act 1982 – Probabilistic assessment of whether accused “will” answer bail under s 24(1)(a) Bail Act 1982  –  Low risk posed to Darwin community – Low probability of answering bail outweighs proposed detriment to accused’s personal interest –presumption against bail not overcome – Set aside – Bail revoked.

Bail Act 1982, s 7A, s 7A(2), 7A (2AA), 7A(2AB) , s 24, s 24(1), s 24(1)(a),
s 24(1)(a)(i), s 24(1)(aa), s 24(1)(d) s 36(1), s 36(3)
Misuse of Drugs Act 1990, s 3, s 5(1), s 7(1), sch 1
Bail Act2013 (NSW) s 22C(1)

DZY v Trustees of Christian Bros [2025] HCA 16, JM v R [2015] NSWSC 978, Chau v Director of Public Prosecutions (1995) 37 NSWLR 639, R v EM [2025] NTSC 31, RB v R (No 2) [2024] NSWSC 845, R v TB [2025] NSWSC 38, Workpac Pty Ltd v Skene [2018] FCAFC 131

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Crown:  S Bicknell

Defendant: J Moore with M Bazzi

Solicitors:

Crown:Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions

Defendant:City Group Legal

Judgment category classification:     B

Judgment ID Number:  Ree2502

Number of pages:  22

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

The King v Abuelheish (aka Jorban) [2025] NTSC 47

No. 22528337

BETWEEN:

THE KING

v

AHMAD ABUELHEISH (aka JORBAN)

CORAM:    Reeves J

REASONS FOR DECISION

(Delivered 10 July 2025)

Introduction

  1. This is an application made at the request of the Director of Public Prosecutions under s 36(1) of the Bail Act 1982 (“the Act”) for review of a Local Court decision made 30 June 2025 granting bail to the defendant, Ahmad Abuelheish, also known as Ahmad Jorban.

  2. Section 36(3) of the Act provides that this review is by way of rehearing and may take account of the evidence or information before the Local Court and any additional evidence or information. It therefore proceeds as a rehearing de novo.

    The charges against the defendant

  3. The defendant has been charged with two offences under subsection 5(1)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The King v Abuelheish (aka Jorban) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NTSC 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The King v Abuelheish (aka Jorban) is a case involving the review of a bail decision made by the Darwin Local Court. The defendant, who was charged with serious drug-related offences under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1982, sought to overturn the decision to revoke his bail and remand him in custody. The case examined the application of the Bail Act 1982, particularly the presumption against bail and the criteria that must be considered when granting bail. The defendant argued that the harsh conditions of his bail, including strict reporting and residency requirements, were unjust and that he should be granted bail to allow him to prepare his defence and maintain his livelihood in Sydney.

The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation and application of sections 7A and 24 of the Bail Act 1982. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the presumption against bail could be overcome given the nature of the alleged offences and the defendant's risk to the community. The court also had to consider whether the defendant's personal interests, such as his need to be with his family and to work, could outweigh the community's interest in preventing potential harm. The court evaluated the probabilistic assessments required by sections 7A(2AB) and 24, including the meaning of "community" and the use of terms such as "would" and "will."

The court found that the defendant posed a low risk to the safety of the Darwin community if granted bail, but there was a significant likelihood that he would not comply with the bail conditions and fail to appear in court. The court highlighted that the word "only" in section 24 of the Bail Act limited the considerations to those listed in the statute. Ultimately, the court concluded that the community's interest in preventing potential harm and ensuring the defendant would appear in court outweighed the defendant's personal interests. Therefore, the presumption against bail was not overcome, and the Local Court's decision to revoke bail and remand the defendant in custody was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As already mentioned, the defendant was granted bail in the Darwin Local Court on 30 June 2025. That grant of bail was made subject to the following conditions:(a) The defendant is to be of good behaviour;(b) The defendant must reside at 14A Wales Street, Greenacre NSW 2190;(c) The defendant is to report daily to the Sergeant at Bankstown Police Station between the hours of 6am and 8pm;(d) The defendant must be present in the company of his mother Missadi ABUELHEISH, born 12 October 1972, or brother Mohammad at all times;(e) The defendant is not to be absent from his place of residence between the house of 8pm to 5am;(f) The defendant is not to apply for any travel documents and his current passport must be surrendered to the Northern Territory Police before his release on bail;(g) The defendant is not to leave the state of NSW unless for attendance at court at which time, 48 hours’ notice must be provided to the officer in charge with details of the defendant’s itinerary including flights and accommodation;(h) The defendant is to appear before the court when called upon;(i) The defendant is not to consume any illicit drug or alcohol and shall submit to testing when requested by a Police Officer;(j) The defendant is not to associate or communicate (except through his lawyer) with any prosecution witness including Adam YAGHI;(k) Mohammad ABUELHEISH lodges the sum of $50,000 cash with the clerks of courts, Local Court, Nichols Place, to ensure the accused attendance at court and compliance with conditions of Darwin bail;(l) The defendant is not to leave Berrimah Correctional Centre unless in the company of his mother Missadi ABUELHEISH or brother Mohammad ABUELHEISH;(l) The defendant must not possess or use more than one mobile phone, the IMEI number and phone number and network provider for which he must cause to provide to the Police Officer in charge within 24 hours of his release or within 24 hours of obtaining same, whichever the earlier;(m) The defendant is not to access any computer or electronic communication devices:(i) The defendant is not to access the internet;(ii) The defendant is not to engage in any encrypted communications;(ii) The defendant is not to have any applications on his mobile phone that will allow for encrypted communication; and(n) The defendant must provide his phone to a police officer upon request with the PIN code to it and unlock the phone immediately or facilitate biometric testing.The evidence and contentions The defendant relied on an affidavit of Mr Bazzi, his lawyer sworn 2 July 2025 and the submissions of his counsel directed, in particular, to the criteria in s 24 of the Act. In his affidavit, Mr Bazzi said, among other things, that the defendant's mother and brother are fully aware of the strict conditions of the defendant’s bail and have given assurances that if he breaches any of those conditions they will immediately contact police and report him. Mr Bazzi also said the defendant is of the Islamic faith and that he has experienced difficulties while he has been in custody because no halal food has been offered to him. As well, he said that his custody in Darwin is particularly difficult for him because it means that he has limited contact with his family in New South Wales. In addition, Mr Bazzi said that the defendant needs to return to Sydney so that he can work there and thereby fund his legal representation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

With respect to those matters, first, I accept the defendant’s estimate that he will be likely to spend between 12 and 18 months in custody, on remand, before his matter comes to trial. I also accept that the conditions on remand in the Northern Territory’s correctional facilities are overcrowded and harsh and that is compounded, in his case, by his remoteness from his family and his inability to obtain food which complies with his religious beliefs.[24] As well, I accept that he has a desire to be in Sydney to, among other things, instruct his lawyers and earn an income to fund his legal defence.[25] In addition, I have taken account of the other matters advanced by his counsel including his relative youth and his unblemished history in respect of bail breaches.[26]Conclusion Ultimately I have concluded that, with the exception of the paramount considerations in subsection 24(1)(aa) of the Act, the community interest matters in subsection 24(1) of the Act, as discussed above, outweigh the interests of the defendant as advanced by him. I have excepted the paramount consideration because I have concluded that the defendant poses a low risk to the safety of the Darwin community were he to be released on bail. That aside, I consider the community interest prevails because there is a low probability that the defendant will answer his bail. It follows that I do not consider that the defendant has overcome the presumption against bail contained in s 7A of the Act. Accordingly, the order made by the Local Court on 30 June 2025 is set aside and the defendant is remanded in custody.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

According to the Macquarie Australian Dictionary, 8th ed, 2020, the ordinary English meaning of the word “community” is, relevantly: “all the people of a specific locality or country… a particular locality, considered together with inhabitants”. Locality is therefore pivotal to the concept of community as that word is used in these provisions. Consideration For the following reasons, when the competing matters prescribed under s 24 of the Act are weighed, I do not consider the defendant has, on balance, overcome the presumption against bail contained in s 7A of the Act. This means that the defendant’s application fails at the first step identified above and it is therefore unnecessary to consider the second step. Turning first to the paramount consideration in subsection 24(1)(aa) of the Act, as observed earlier, this consideration requires a probabilistic assessment of the risk the defendant would pose to the safety of “the community” were he to be released on bail, noting that that assessment involves less certainty and a lower bar than that required under the second step. Furthermore, the locality that is pivotal to the word “community” mentioned above, indicates that, in this matter, it is the safety of the Northern Territory community and, in particular, the community in and around Darwin with which this provision is concerned. Methamphetamine is notoriously harmful to those who consume it and, by extension, to the community of which those persons are members, relevantly, in this matter, the Darwin community. Accordingly, if the defendant’s alleged offending were to be repeated while he is on bail, that harm would inevitably result to those persons and to that community. However, if the defendant resides in Sydney while he is on bail, as his proposed conditions of bail require, the likelihood of that harm occurring to that community, would be significantly reduced. That is so, most obviously, because in that location, he will be thousands of kilometres away from Darwin. While that likelihood would be even further reduced if he were to comply strictly with those conditions, for the reasons given below, I doubt that will occur. Nonetheless conducting the kind of assessment described above, I would assess the risk that the defendant poses to the safety of the Darwin community, for the purposes of subsection 24(1)(aa) of the Act, as low. The next community interest matter in subsection 24(1) of the Act is contained in subsection 24(1)(a), namely the probability of the defendant answering his bail. As mentioned earlier, that subsection uses the words “will appear in court” thus requiring an assessment involving greater certainty and a higher bar. In addition, the use of the word “only” in the introductory words to that subsection limits the relevant matters to those listed. Finally, the expression “the community” appearing in subsection 24(1)(a)(i) refers to the Darwin community because, in addition to the matters mentioned above, the Local Court at Darwin is the Court in which he will be required to appear to answer his bail.