The Grape Organisation Pty Ltd v A.C.N 123732516 Pty Limited (ACN 123732516)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by The Grape Organisation Pty Ltd to applications under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by A.C.N 123732516 Pty Limited (ACN 123732516) for removal of trade mark numbers 1938040 (9) – Fraternity, 1960308 (9) – Headband (Musical Band), 1984553 (9) – The Valentines, and 1961113 (9, 16, 25, 41) – Fraternity all in the name of The Grape Organisation Pty Ltd

Delegate:

Nicholas Smith

Representation:

Opponent: Self-represented with submissions by Victor Marshall

Applicant: Rahul Shah of Sharon Givoni Consulting

Decision:

2024 ATMO 215

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) - section 96 opposition: s 92(4)(a) application for removal – intent to use inherent in filing of Trade Mark applications – opponent asserts its intention at the filing date to use the Trade Marks – evidence of actual use of the Trade Marks for the Registered Goods – Trade Marks to remain on Register in its current form

Background

  1. This decision is pursuant to applications made on 30 November 2022[1] under s 92(4)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) by A.C.N 123732516 Pty Limited (ACN 123732516) (‘Applicant’) to remove the trade marks detailed below (collectively ‘Trade Marks’) from the Register of Trade Marks.  The applications are made in respect of all the goods for which the trade marks are registered, that is, the applications are for complete removal of the Trade Marks.

    [1] This decision only concerns the applications made 30 November 2022, not the applications made 10 October 2023 by a related company of the Applicant with the same legal representation.

Registration No.

1938040

Lodgement date

2 July 2018

Goods

Class 9: Music recordings; Pre-recorded compact discs (disks)(CDs)

Owner

The Grape Organisation Pty Ltd

Trade Mark

Fraternity

(‘1938040 Mark’)

Registration No.

1960308

Lodgement date

7 October 2018

Goods

Class 9: Digital music (downloadable) from the Internet; Digital music (downloadable) provided from MP3 web sites on the internet; Downloadable music files; Music cassettes; Music recordings; Music tapes; Musical cassettes; Musical recordings in the form of discs; Musical recordings in the form of tapes; Musical recordings in the form of wires; Pre-recorded music videos; Tape recordings of music; Films for sound recordings; Films prepared for exhibitions; Motion picture films (recorded); Motion picture films for television use; Motion picture films for theatrical use; Photographic media (films, exposed); Pre-recorded films; Pre-recorded video films; Printed motion picture film; Recorded film; Recorded films; Video films; Video films prepared for exhibitions; Pre-recorded DVDs; Vinyl pressed records; Vinyl records; Pre-recorded compact discs (disks)(CDs); Record albums (discs); Digitally stored images; Discs for bearing video images; Downloadable image files

Owner

The Grape Organisation Pty Ltd

Trade Mark

Headband (Musical Band)

(‘1960308 Mark’)

Registration No.

1961113

Lodgement date

11 October 2018

Goods

Class 9: Pre-recorded compact discs (disks)(CDs); Digital music (downloadable) from the Internet; Digital music (downloadable) provided from MP3 web sites on the internet; Downloadable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Grape Organisation Pty Ltd v A.C.N 123732516 Pty Limited... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ATMO 215
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute before the delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Nicholas Smith, concerned an application by The Grape Organisation Pty Ltd (the Applicant) to remove four trade mark registrations owned by A.C.N 123732516 Pty Limited (the Opponent) from the Register. The grounds for removal were based on allegations that the Opponent had no intention to use the trade marks, or had not used them, in relation to the goods and services for which they were registered. The Applicant contended that the bands associated with the trade marks were defunct, that the Opponent was only selling old music, and that the Opponent had a history of registering defunct band names to deceive the public.

The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether the Opponent had demonstrated an intention to use, or actual use of, the trade marks for which they were registered, thereby satisfying the requirements of section 92(4)(a) of the relevant legislation. This involved considering the onus of proof in such proceedings and the nature of the evidence required to establish an intention to use a trade mark, particularly in circumstances where the registered owner is alleged to be dealing with defunct musical acts.

The delegate applied the principle that the onus is on the applicant for removal to prove the absence of intention to use, and that this onus is not particularly arduous. Citing precedent, the delegate noted that the making of an application for registration is prima facie evidence of an intention to use, and that "intention" does not necessarily mean an intention to use immediately or within a limited time. The delegate was satisfied that, at the relevant dates, the Opponent intended to use each of the trade marks and had indeed actively used them for many of the registered goods and services. Consequently, the Opponent successfully established its opposition to the removal application.

The Opponent was successful in its oppositions to the removal of the trade marks and was awarded costs. The delegate ordered that the Applicant pay the Opponent's costs in relation to trade mark number 1938040. Costs in relation to trade mark numbers 1960308, 1984553, and 1961113 were to be taxed in a specified manner, with costs awarded against the Opponent in these instances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The relevant claims/statements in Marshall 2 are summarised below:· The Applicant no longer has any interest in the Trade Marks and has sold any rights it claims in the marks to a third party, which has brought a similar non-use action against the Opponent. · The fact that each of these bands has not recently performed and/or released new music does not prevent the ongoing use or intention to use the Trade Marks for the various goods and services for which they are registered. Applicant’s Evidence The relevant claims/statements in the Reilly declaration are summarised below:· Each of the bands referred to in the EIS is presently defunct and not releasing new music. The Opponent is only selling old music from each of their websites.· The Opponent has a history of applying to register the name of defunct Australian bands as trademarks. The Opponent has done so for the purpose of preventing third parties from using these marks and are deceiving the Australian public into believing that the bands remain active in the Australian music industry. The relevant claims/statements in the Seeger declaration are summarised below:· In the case of defunct bands, it is usual for the estate to own the rights in any trademarks and the proper owner of the Trade Marks should be the band members and not the Opponent. The declarant expresses the view that the music industry would be severely affected if distributors of legitimate products could not describe the product using the trade marked artist’s name. Discussion Though the onus is, in terms of s 100, on the Opponent in this matter, that onus is not particularly arduous. In Aston v Harlee Manufacturing Co[3] Fullagar J observed:[…] the making of the application itself is, I think, to be regarded as prima facie evidence of intention to use. I cannot think that the Registrar is called upon to institute an inquiry as to the intention of any applicant, and I think that, on … a motion to expunge, the burden must rest on … the person aggrieved, of proving the absence of intention. Again, I do not think that “intention” in this connexion ought to be regarded as meaning an intention to use immediately or within any limited time.[3] [1960] HCA 47; (1960) 103 CLR 391; [1960] ALR 605; 34 ALJR 242, [21]. While this observation was made in proceedings under the Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth), where the onus was on ‘the person aggrieved’ (that is, an applicant for removal), the principle has been held to be sound under the Act. In Structureco Inc v Starite Distributors Pty Ltd[4] the Registrar’s delegate Mr Forno said:Although the opponent to removal does bear the initial onus, in accordance with the legislation, I think that, in the case of applications for removal under s.92(4)(a), where the primary allegation regards the state of mind of an applicant for registration about whether it intends to use a mark in good faith, then that onus is not high. I believe that it is so low that it can be overcome if the opponent or its agent states that it was the case that the applicant for registration had an intention to use the mark in good faith. The onus should then shift to the removal applicant to support its case - perhaps by the production of some evidence which might support a circumstantial case of a lack of good faith, or by some other means.[4] [2000] ATMO 31.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am satisfied that at the relevant dates the Opponent intended to use each of the Trade Marks for the goods and/or services for which they are registered (and indeed has actively used the Trade Marks for many of the goods and/or services for which each mark is registered). The Opponent has established its opposition in relation to the application for removal under s 92(4)(a).Decision The Opponent has established its opposition to removal in respect of each of the Trade Marks. Accordingly, I decide not to remove trade mark registrations 1938040, 1960308, 1984553 and 1961113 from the Register in relation to any of the goods and services for which they are registered.Costs The Opponent has been successful in its oppositions to removal of trade mark numbers. 1938040, 1960308, 1984553 and 1961113 and has requested its costs. I see no reason to depart from the general rule that costs follow the event. I accordingly award costs in respect of trade mark number 1938040 against the Applicant under s 221 in the relevant amounts under Schedule 8 of the Regulations. In respect of trade mark number 1960308 I award costs against the Opponent to be taxed in the same manner as indicated in Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhad v James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd[14]. In respect of trade mark number 1984553 I award costs against the Opponent to be taxed in the same manner as indicated in Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhad v James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd[15]. In respect of trade mark number 1961113 I award costs against the Opponent to be taxed in the same manner as indicated in Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhad v James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd[16]. [14] [2001] ATMO 78 (Hearing Officer Williams).[15] Ibid.[16] IbidNicholas SmithHearing OfficerDelegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks5 November 2024

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established