The Estate of Stephen Michael Tester

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

CITATION:The Estate of Stephen Michael Tester [2017] NTSC 83

PARTIES:THE ESTATE OF STEPHEN MICHAEL TESTER

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY EXERCISING TERRITORY JURISDICTION

FILE NO:PR 131 of 2017 (21740494)

DELIVERED ON:  21 November 2017

DELIVERED AT:  Darwin

WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS:              6 October 2017

JUDGMENT OF:  HILEY J

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – Wills, probate and administration – clerical error – where formal will prepared by Solicitor is inconsistent with draft will prepared by Testator - application for rectification under s 27 Wills Act 2000 (NT) – held will did not carry out the intentions of the testator and did not give effect to testators instructions – will rectified by amendment

Wills Act 2000 (NT) s 27(1)

Administration of Justice Act 1982 (UK) s 20(1)

Succession Act 1981 (Qld) s 31(1)

Long v Long [2004] NSWSC 1002; Re Allen [1988] 1 Qd R 1; Re Hess [1992] 1 QD R 176; Re Segelman (Deceased) [1995] 3 All ER 676; Rawack v Spicer [2002] NSWSC 849; Wordingham v Royal Exchange Trust Co Ltd [1992] 3 All ER 204, referred to.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Applicant:N Aughterson

Solicitors:

Applicant:Ronald Edwin Lawford

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  Hil1713

Number of pages:  12

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

The Estate of Stephen Michael Tester [2017] NTSC 83

No. PR 131 of 2017 (21740494)

THE ESTATE of STEPHEN MICHAEL TESTER

CORAM:     HILEY J

REASONS FOR DECISION ON REFERENCE BY THE REGISTRAR

(Delivered 21 November 2017)

Introduction

  1. On 17 August 2017 the applicant filed an application seeking that probate of the will of the late Stephen Michael Tester (the Testator) dated 28 April 2017 (the Will), be granted to her and that “an amendment be made to the Will” (the Application).  The effect of the amendment sought is to gift $1,000 to Mr Tom Tester instead of the $25,000 gifted to him in the Will.

  2. The Application was accompanied by documents that usually accompany applications for probate, and two affidavits in support of correction to the Will, one by the solicitor who prepared the Will, Ronald Edwin Lawford, [1] the other by the applicant, Irene Lorraine Bruninghausen, who was appointed executor under the Will.[2]  The Registrar has referred the Application to the Court.  The applicant has subsequently provided the Court with written submissions,[3] amended affidavits in support of correction to the Will,[4] and a copy of email exchanges between Mr Lawford and Mr Tom Tester (the emails).[5]

  3. This is in effect an application for rectification of the Will under s 27 of the Wills Act 2000 (NT). Section 27(1) provides:

    If the Court is satisfied that a will does not carry out the intentions of the testator because:

    (a)   a clerical error was made: or

    (b)   the will does not give effect to the testator’s instructions,

    the Court may make an order to rectify the will so it carries out the testator’s intentions.

    Relevant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Estate of Stephen Michael Tester and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NTSC 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Estate of Stephen Michael Tester involved an application for the rectification of a will under section 27 of the Wills Act 2000 (NT). The case centred on whether the formal will, which had been prepared by a solicitor, accurately reflected the wishes of the testator, Stephen Tester, who had passed away in April 2017. The formal will had been drafted based on a draft will prepared by Mr Tester himself, but the amounts specified in the formal will differed from those in the draft, leading to a dispute over the validity of the formal will.

The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether the formal will accurately carried out the intentions of Mr Tester and gave effect to his instructions. The court needed to determine if the differences between the draft and formal will were due to a clerical error or if they represented a change in Mr Tester's intentions. The case hinged on the evidence of Ms Bruninghausen, the executrix, who had known Mr Tester for many years and had witnessed the creation of the draft will. She testified that Mr Tester had prepared a draft will on his computer, which was given to her to deliver to the solicitor. The formal will, however, contained discrepancies in the amounts specified for certain beneficiaries, raising questions about whether these differences were inadvertent errors or intentional changes.

The court found that the formal will did not accurately reflect Mr Tester's intentions and instructions. The evidence showed that Mr Tester had only skimmed the formal will before signing it, and there was a high likelihood that he overlooked the incorrect amount specified for his brother Tom. The court also considered the timeline, noting that there was little time between the preparation of the draft and the formal will, making a deliberate change in the amounts less probable. Furthermore, the executrix provided affidavit evidence indicating that Mr Tester had always been closer to his brothers Sam and Toby, justifying the larger amounts left to them in the draft will. The court concluded that the formal will did not give effect to Mr Tester's instructions and contained a clerical error, warranting rectification.

The court ordered that the will be rectified by amending the amounts specified for the beneficiaries to align with Mr Tester's draft will. This decision ensures that the formal will now accurately reflects the intentions of the testator and gives effect to his instructions, as evidenced by the draft will he had prepared.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is in effect an application for rectification of the Will under s 27 of the Wills Act 2000 (NT). Section 27(1) provides:If the Court is satisfied that a will does not carry out the intentions of the testator because:(a) a clerical error was made: or(b) the will does not give effect to the testator’s instructions,the Court may make an order to rectify the will so it carries out the testator’s intentions.Relevant Facts Ms Bruninghausen, a retired legal practitioner, had known Stephen Tester for 27 years. He was a close friend and neighbour of hers. When Stephen Tester was diagnosed with cancer in May 2016 he asked Ms Bruninghausen if she would be his executor. She said yes and told him that he would have to make a will. When she subsequently reminded him about this he said that he was in the process of preparing a will on his laptop with the assistance of draft forms available on the internet. Ms Bruninghausen was interstate for some five months and returned early on 22 April 2017 as Mr Tester had been told that he did not have long to live. His mother and two of his brothers, Sam and Toby Tester, had travelled to Darwin from the United Kingdom to say their goodbyes and were to leave Darwin to return home on 26 April 2017. Ms Bruninghausen says that Mr Tester was not willing to discuss his will or see a lawyer while they were there. The following day Ms Bruninghausen had a long conversation with Mr Tester and he agreed to see a lawyer about his will the next day. Ms Bruninghausen made an appointment for them to see Mr Lawford the next day. On the morning of 28 April, Mr Tester telephoned Ms Bruninghausen from Royal Darwin Hospital and asked her to cancel the appointment with Mr Lawford, which she did. A few hours later Mr Tester’s partner, Ms Irene Roziana, and a friend, came to Ms Bruninghausen’s house and gave her a three page document (described in the affidavits as the informal will) and asked her to take it to the lawyer. She understood the document to be a printed version of the draft will prepared by Mr Tester on his computer. At the bottom of the first two pages was provision for signatures by “Stephen Tester” and a witness, but no signatures. At the end of the document, on the third page, was typed the word “Signed”, below that a dotted line and below that the words “Stephen Tester”. On the dotted line was a handwritten signature. The document contained considerable detail concerning the distribution of Mr Tester’s assets most of which was to go to Ms Irene Roziana, identified as his spouse. These included the proceeds of sale of two units in Bakewell, his superannuation benefits and the residue of his estate after paying out a number of legacies. It identified the names and telephone numbers of seven people (one of whom was Ms Bruninghausen) and amounts ranging between $3,000 and $20,000 which were “for the recipients to have a beer on me.” It then identified eight people under the heading “Direct Family” and stated specific amounts opposite the names of all but Irene Roziana. On the first three lines, opposite each of the names “Michael and Jean Tester (Mum & Dad)”, “Sam” and “Toby” was the figure $25,000. On the next three lines were, respectively, the words “Tom - $1,000”, “Nick - $3,000” and “Jane - $1,000”. On the last line were the words “Nona (Irene Roziana) – All remaining monies” and a telephone number. The document then stated that Ms Bruninghausen was to be the executor of the will and “will have power of attorney over all my affairs”. It contained other instructions for example regarding the sale of a unit, a house and a car, and login and password details.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Re Hess Williams J stated that the instructions given to the solicitor “would always be central to an application invoking s 31”.[15] There is a presumption that where a testator has read the will, he or she knew and approved of its contents.[16]Consideration I agree that when the formal will was prepared there was a clerical error and, also, it did not give effect to the testator’s instructions. The informal will clearly shows an amount of $1,000 to be gifted to Mr Tom Tester. Mr Lawford, the testator’s solicitor, has acknowledged that the relevant entry of $25,000 in the formal will does not accord with his instructions.[17] That is supported by the affidavit evidence of Ms Bruninghausen.[18] Despite the presumption referred to in [21] above, the affidavit evidence of the testator’s solicitor Mr Lawford is that in the present case Mr Tester “appeared to skim read [the will] over a period of 10 seconds”, before making the one correction referred to at paragraph [13] above. Mr Tester would have been entitled to assume that the various amounts appearing in the formal will, prepared by his solicitor, were the same as those in the informal will. In the circumstance of signing the Will in a hospital, and given that the two gifts immediately above that for Tom Tester were for $25,000, it is evident that he overlooked the amount of the gift. Also, the obvious correction that was made (from “brother” Nick to “sister” Nicola) appeared immediately below the gift to Tom Tester, which could well have served as a distraction. It is evident that Mr Tester did not subsequently read the Will and so was not in a position to discover any error. In addition to the fact that the informal will only allowed for a gift of $1,000 to Tom Tester, there is other evidence to the effect that a clerical error was made and that the Will did not give effect to Mr Tester’s instructions. There was only a matter of hours between the handing over of the informal will and its transformation into a formal will, making any change of mind much less likely. Secondly, there were differences as between the gifts given to Mr Tester’s siblings. While $25,000 was given to each of Sam and Toby, only $3,000 was given to Nicola and $1,000 to Jane. Mr Tester’s executrix, Ms Bruninghausen, states that a week or so after signing the Will, Mr Tester told her that of his siblings he had always been closer to Toby and Sam and that is why the amounts that he had left to them were so much greater than the amounts he had left to the others.[19] Thirdly, Ms Bruninghausen also states: “I am certain that if Steve had intended to make such a substantial change in the amount to be left to Tom Tester he would definitely have talked to me about it and he did not”.[20] Disposition Accordingly I am satisfied that the Will does not carry out the intentions of the testator because a clerical error was made. I am also satisfied that the Will does not give effect to the testator’s instructions to his solicitor. I consider it appropriate to make an order rectifying the Will.