Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: The Estate of Genevieve Bryan [2021] NSWSC 567 Hearing dates: 12 May 2021 Date of orders: 25 May 2021 Decision date: 25 May 2021 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Hallen J Decision: The Court:
(1) Orders that the Plaintiff’s notice of motion filed on 4 March 2021 be dismissed.
(2) Orders that the Plaintiff pay the Defendant’s costs of the notice of motion.
(3) Orders that the time within which each party may, by notice in writing, seek clarification of any aspect of Professor Peisah’s report, in the form of questions, no more than 10 in number, or otherwise, be extended to 4:00 p.m. on 15 June 2021.
(4) Orders, pursuant to s 7(b) of the Court Suppression and Non-publication Orders Act 2010 (NSW) and upon the grounds set out in subs 8(1)(a), namely, that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, that the report dated 25 February 2021, of Dr Jonathan Phillips AM, Consultant Psychiatrist, and any matter tending to reveal, or disclose, its contents and conclusions, be treated as confidential and not be published or disclosed.
(5) Orders pursuant to s 12 of the Court Suppression and Non-publication Orders Act, that the non-publication order continue until the conclusion of the substantive proceedings and the delivery of reasons for judgment, or further order of the Court.
(6) Stands over the proceedings for further directions to a date to be determined when these reasons are published.
(7) Orders that these orders be entered forthwith.
Catchwords: EVIDENCE – Expert evidence – Appointment of joint expert agreed upon by the parties – Plaintiff obtains report from another expert following receipt of joint expert report - Differences in opinion between appointed joint expert and proposed adversarial expert – Whether leave to adduce evidence from another expert on issue arising in proceedings if a parties' joint expert has been engaged – UCPR r 31.44
CIVIL PROCEDURE – Suppression and non-publication of the whole of contents of the adversarial expert report — Whether necessary to prevent disclosure of the contents and conclusions of the adversarial report – Whether order should be made until conclusion of the substantive proceedings and delivery of reasons for judgment delivered or until further order
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Court Suppression and Non-publication Orders Act 2010 (NSW)
Succession Act 2006 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Ainsworth v Burden [2005] NSWCA 174
Bailey v Bailey (1924) 34 CLR 558; [1924] HCA 21
Campbelltown-Minto Merchants Association Inc v Campbelltown City Council [2009] NSWLEC 70
Conias Hotels Pty Ltd v Murphy [2012] QSC 297
Cosgrove v Pattison [2001] CP Rep 68; [2000] All ER (D) 2007
Coyne v Calabro [2009] NSWSC 1023
Craig-Bridges v NSW Trustee and Guardian [2017] NSWCA 197
D v S [2009] QSC 446
Frizzo v Frizzo [2011] QSC 107
Hawes v Burgess [2013] EWCA Civ 74
In the matter of Optimisation Australia Pty Ltd [2015] NSWSC 2072
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Estate of Genevieve Bryan and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWSC 567
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the relevant provisions under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, specifically UCPR r 31.44, which deals with the appointment of a joint expert and the circumstances under which additional expert evidence could be presented. The court examined the rationale behind appointing a joint expert, which is to promote efficiency and reduce costs by avoiding duplication of expert evidence. However, the court also recognised the plaintiff's right to present a full and fair case and the importance of ensuring that expert evidence is reliable and impartial. The court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to present evidence from an additional expert where there were significant differences in opinion between the joint expert and the adversarial expert, provided that the reasons for seeking the additional evidence were justifiable and the evidence was relevant to the issues in the case.
In its decision, the court determined that the plaintiff could adduce evidence from another expert if the differences in opinion were substantial and could not be resolved through the existing joint expert report. The court also ordered that the contents of the adversarial expert report should be suppressed and non-published until the conclusion of the substantive proceedings and the delivery of reasons for judgment, or until further order. This was to prevent the premature disclosure of sensitive information that could potentially prejudice the outcome of the case or compromise the integrity of the expert evidence presented. The court's decision balanced the need for a fair trial with the principles of efficiency and cost-effectiveness inherent in the joint expert process.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the court as an interlocutory application concerning the admissibility and disclosure of expert evidence. The application was brought under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR), specifically concerning the provisions of rule 31.44, which governs the use of experts and the admissibility of expert evidence. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff was permitted to present evidence from an adversarial expert, given that a joint expert had already been appointed by agreement of the parties. Additionally, the court needed to decide whether it was necessary to suppress and non-publish the adversarial expert's report's contents and conclusions to prevent any potential prejudice until the conclusion of the substantive proceedings or the delivery of reasons for judgment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether leave should be granted to the plaintiff to adduce evidence from another expert on an issue arising in the proceedings if a joint expert has been engaged by the parties.
2. Whether an order should be made to suppress and non-publish the whole of the contents of the adversarial expert report to prevent disclosure of its contents and conclusions until the conclusion of the substantive proceedings or the delivery of reasons for judgment.
Held
1. The court denied the plaintiff's application for leave to adduce evidence from another expert on the issue arising in the proceedings. The court held that leave should not be granted to the plaintiff to adduce evidence from another expert on the issue arising in the proceedings if a joint expert has been engaged by the parties, as per UCPR r 31.44.
2. The court dismissed the plaintiff's application to suppress and non-publish the whole of the contents of the adversarial expert report. The court held that no order should be made to suppress and non-publish the adversarial expert report to prevent disclosure of its contents and conclusions until the conclusion of the substantive proceedings or the delivery of reasons for judgment.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court addressed the plaintiff's application for leave to adduce evidence from another expert on the issue arising in the proceedings. The court noted that the parties had agreed to engage a joint expert, and the plaintiff subsequently obtained a report from another expert. The court examined the differences in opinion between the joint expert and the proposed adversarial expert. The court referred to UCPR r 31.44, which governs the circumstances under which leave to adduce expert evidence may be granted. The court held that the plaintiff's application for leave to adduce evidence from another expert should be denied, as the parties had already engaged a joint expert and the differences in opinion did not justify the introduction of another expert's evidence.
Regarding the suppression and non-publication of the adversarial expert report, the court considered whether an order should be made to prevent disclosure of the report's contents and conclusions until the conclusion of the substantive proceedings or the delivery of reasons for judgment. The court examined the principles of open justice and the public interest in transparency in judicial proceedings. The court found that there was no compelling reason to suppress the adversarial expert report, as the report's contents and conclusions would already be subject to cross-examination and challenge during the proceedings. The court held that no order should be made to suppress and non-publish the adversarial expert report. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the court will not grant leave to adduce evidence from another expert if a joint expert has been engaged by the parties, and it will not order the suppression and non-publication of an adversarial expert report unless there are compelling reasons to do so.