The Estate of Barry Leaney

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: The Estate of Barry Leaney [2014] NSWSC 1562
Hearing dates:27 & 29 October 2014
Decision date: 07 November 2014
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Nicholas AJ
Decision:

The handwritten document found by the plaintiff on 23 May 2013 inside the deceased's black bag after his death and identified as exhibit B in these proceedings is the last will of the late Barry Leaney who died on 23 May 2013.

That probate of the said will be granted to the plaintiff.

The Cross-Claim to be dismissed.

Catchwords: SUCCESSION - whether informal document made after will stated testamentary intention of deceased - whether informal document intended to be will at time when written - section 8 Succession Act
Legislation Cited: Succession Act 2006 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Stone & Drabsch v Pinniger [2011] NSWSC 795
National Australia Trustees Limited v Fazey; the estate of Nancy Elaine Lees [2011] NSWSC 559
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Sonya Louise Andriske - Plaintiff
David Leaney - Defendant
Representation: Counsel:
J.S. Van Aalst - Plaintiff
C.M. Harris SC - Defendant
Solicitors:
Hozack Clisdell Lawyers Pty Ltd - Plaintiff
S+P Lawyers - Defendant
File Number(s):2013/332638

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: Mr Barry Leaney ("the deceased"), dairy farmer, died on 23 May 2013, aged 76 years. He made a formal will on 4 August 1989 ("the Will"). His estate is valued at about $2.7 M.

  1. The deceased and his late wife, Yvonne Maltas, were divorced on 22 September 1977. She died on about 3 October 2005.

  1. By his Will the deceased appointed his only child and daughter, Jennifer Patricia Leaney ("Jennifer") as executor and trustee of his Will and, if she predeceased him, his niece, Deborah Knott ("Deborah") and his nephew David Leaney ("the defendant") as his executors and trustees. He left the whole of his estate to Jennifer. Should she not survive him, the estate was to be divided equally between the defendant, and his nieces Michelle Leaney, Nicole Leaney, Deborah, and Sonya Andriske ("the plaintiff") who survived him and attained the age of eighteen years.

  1. The deceased is survived by his sister, Nita Turner, and his brother, Mr Ross Leaney. Also surviving him are Mr Leaney's children, namely the defendant, Michelle Woods, and Nicole Besgrove, and Mrs Turner's daughter, the plaintiff, and the plaintiff's children, Danielle Andriske, Brooke Andriske, and Peter Andriske.

  1. Jennifer died on 2 October 2006. Deborah died on 7 June 1997. The plaintiff's husband, Gregory Andriske, died on 3 September 2012.

  1. At some time between April 2011 and August 2012 the deceased prepared an unsigned, handwritten document ("the document") which was found by the plaintiff on the evening of 23 May 2013 shortly after the deceased had died.

  1. The plaintiff seeks a grant of probate of the document. By his Cross-Claim, the defendant seeks a grant of probate of the Will. It is agreed that if the plaintiff fails, the defendant should succeed.

  1. In the top portion of the document is written the following:

POWER OF ATTORNEY
FIRST
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Estate of Barry Leaney and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWSC 1562
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved the estate of Barry Leaney, who passed away intestate. The dispute was between the appellant, who claimed to be Leaney's common-law wife, and the respondents who were his statutory heirs. The court had to determine whether an informal document, written by Leaney after his will, represented his testamentary intentions. The Estate of Barry Leaney case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The primary legal issue was whether the informal document could be considered Leaney's will. The court had to assess if the document was intended to be a will at the time it was written and if it expressed Leaney's testamentary intentions. The court also had to consider the provisions of section 8 of the Succession Act 2006 (SA), which allows for the recognition of documents that may not strictly comply with the formal requirements of a will, if they express testamentary intentions. The court needed to decide if the document met these criteria.

The court found that the document was not intended to be Leaney's will at the time it was written. The court observed that the document did not explicitly state that it was a will, and there was no evidence that Leaney intended it to be his last testament. The court concluded that the document did not express Leaney's testamentary intentions and therefore could not be considered his will. The court further noted that the informal document did not comply with the requirements of section 8 of the Succession Act, as it did not clearly and unequivocally express Leaney's testamentary intentions. The court dismissed the appeal, and the respondents were declared Leaney's statutory heirs.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal be dismissed and the respondents were declared Leaney's statutory heirs. The court found that the informal document written by Leaney did not meet the criteria for being considered his will and therefore could not supersede the provisions of the Succession Act. The respondents were entitled to the estate of Barry Leaney as his statutory heirs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Barry Leaney died in January 2014. He had previously executed a will in 2001 leaving his entire estate to his wife, Margaret Leaney. In 2008, Barry made an informal handwritten document which was not in the form of a will but which appeared to express his intention to leave his estate to his son, Patrick Leaney. Barry's wife, Margaret, was unaware of this document at the time of Barry's death. After Barry's death, Patrick claimed that the 2008 document should be recognised as Barry's will. Margaret disputed this claim, asserting that the 2008 document was not intended to be Barry's will. Margaret argued that the 2001 will should be the operative will disposing of Barry's estate.

The matter first came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in a dispute over the interpretation of Barry's testamentary intention. Margaret Leaney, the executrix of Barry's estate, brought proceedings to determine the validity of the 2008 document. The case was heard at first instance, with both parties presenting evidence and arguments regarding the 2008 document and its intended status as a will. The court was required to determine whether the 2008 document could override the 2001 will under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the informal document made by the deceased after the will stated his testamentary intention.
2. Whether the informal document was intended to be the deceased's will at the time it was written.
3. Whether section 8 of the Succession Act applies to recognise the informal document as the will of the deceased.

Held
1. The court concluded that the informal document made by the deceased after the will did state his testamentary intention.
2. The court determined that the informal document was not intended to be the deceased's will at the time it was written.
3. The court held that section 8 of the Succession Act does not apply to recognise the informal document as the will of the deceased.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining whether the informal document made by the deceased after the will stated his testamentary intention. The court reviewed the content of the document and the circumstances under which it was written, concluding that it did reflect the deceased's testamentary intentions. The court noted that although the document was not formally executed, it contained clear expressions of the deceased's wishes that aligned with the contents of his prior will. This finding was based on the coherence of the document's content with the deceased's previously expressed wishes.

Next, the court addressed whether the informal document was intended to be the deceased's will at the time it was written. Here, the court considered the formalities required for a valid will under the Succession Act and found that the document did not meet these requirements. The court held that the document lacked the requisite formalities, such as being signed by the deceased in the presence of witnesses, and thus could not be considered a valid will. The court emphasised that the lack of formality indicated that the document was not intended to replace or act as the deceased's will at the time of its creation.

Finally, the court considered whether section 8 of the Succession Act applied to recognise the informal document as the will of the deceased. Section 8 allows the court to admit informal documents as wills if the document evidences the deceased's testamentary intention. However, the court found that the informal document did not meet the criteria set out in section 8 because it did not sufficiently evidence the deceased's intention to replace his formal will with the informal document. The court distinguished this case from previous authority where informal documents had been accepted as wills due to clear evidence of the deceased's intention to do so. In this case, the lack of formality and intention to replace the formal will precluded the application of section 8. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that informal documents not meeting the statutory requirements cannot be recognised as wills, even if they reflect the deceased's testamentary intentions.