The Commonwealth of Australia v McCormack, H.J

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

L'

._

CATCHWORDS

I

Appeal

-

Money

pa id under mis take of fac t

-

Consent

award

by

I

A r b i t r a t o r

-

Const ruc t ion

thereof

- Provisional

payment.

THE COMMONWEALTH

V.

HUGH

J O H N IllcCORMACK

F.C. No. A.C.T.

G.62 of 1982

F.C. No. A.C.T.

G.63 of 1982

Coram:

Smithers , Woodward and

Gallop

JJ.

Date:

23 December

1 9 8 2

Canberra,

A.C.T.

c

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

)

l

AUSTRALIAN

CAPITAL

TERRITORY

j

No. ACT G.62 o f 1982

1

No. ACT G.63 of 1982

REGISTRY

DISTRICT

1 1

DIVISION

GENERAL

j

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

THE AUSTRALIAY CAPITAL TERRITORY

BETWEEN:

THE COhfhlONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Appellant

&VD

:

HUGH J O H N McCOR!!CK

Respondent

ORDER

l

CORAM: Smithers, Woodward and Gallop JJ.

-

DATE:

24 December 1982

W E R E W E : Canberra

THE COURT ORDERS

THAT:

(1)

In appeal No. ACT G.62 of 1982 in respect of action

No. S.C.

750 of 1977 the appeal is allowed, judgment

therein set aside and in lieu thereof judgment

is

entered for the appellant in the

sum of $75,000 with

costs of an incidental to the appeal and the proceedings

in the Supreme Court.

In appeal No. ACT G.63 of 1982 In respect of action

No. S.C. 799 of 1979 the appeal is allowed, the judgment

therein is set aside and in lieu thereof judgment is

entered for the appellant

by declaring that as

at

5 October 1978 (the date on which the appellant withheld

payment of $75,000) the appellant was entitle& to

set-off

that sum against the respondent’s entitlement o compensation in respect of the land contained i n Certificates of Title Vo1.72, Folio 7163 and V01.90,

Folio 4 , and it is ordered that the respondent pay to

the appellant its costs

o f and incidental to this appsal

and the proceedings in the Supreme Court.

I N THE FEDEltRL COURT O F AUSTPALIA

\

AUSTRALIAN

CAPITAL

TERRITORY

1

NO. ACT G 6 2 of 1982

1

DISTRICT REGISTRY

1

No. ACT G 6 3 of 19U2

\

GENERAL DIVISION

)

ON APPEAL from the Supreme Court of the Australian Canital Territory

Between: THE COMMOVWEAGTH OF

AUSTRALIA

(Appellant\

-

And:

HUGH JQHW YcCnRMACK

(Respondent)

CORAM: Smithers, Woodward and Gallop JJ. alf December l W 2

REASONS

FOR

J U D G W N "

Smithers J.:

This is an appeal against a judgment dismissing

the appellant's claim for S75,OOO as money had and received to the plaintiff's use in that it was paid by the appellant to

the respondent

by mistake of fact.

The appellant'

S case was that havinq naid to the

respondent the

sum of S 7 5 . 0 0 0 a s an advance aqainst the amount

of compensation which miqht

be found to be due to the

respondent by a n arbitrator in respect

of the value

of certain

improvements made

by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Commonwealth of Australia v McCormack, H.J and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1982] FCA 309
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commonwealth of Australia, as appellant, appealed against the judgments of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory in two separate actions. The first action, No. S.C. 750 of 1977, was dismissed with costs, while the second action, No. S.C. 799 of 1979, resulted in a judgment for the respondent, Hugh John McCormack, for the sum of $75,000 plus interest. The Commonwealth sought to recover the sum of $75,000 as money paid under a mistake of fact, while McCormack sought to recover the same sum plus interest from the Commonwealth. The central legal issue was whether the Commonwealth could recover the $75,000, which it had paid to McCormack under a mistake of fact, as it had failed to take into account an earlier advance payment of the same amount. The Court had to determine the proper construction of an award made by consent by an arbitrator and whether the payment of $215,000 was in addition to the $75,000 already paid or if it was the total sum McCormack was entitled to receive. The Court found that the award should be construed to mean that the $215,000 was the total sum McCormack was entitled to receive. Consequently, the Commonwealth was entitled to recover the $75,000 as it had been paid under a mistake of fact. The Court allowed both appeals, set aside the judgments in favour of the respondent, and ordered that the Commonwealth recover the sum of $75,000 with costs of the trial and appeal. In the second appeal, the Court also ordered that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the trial and appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established