The Audio Visual Copyright Society v Australian Record Industry Association Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read
Reported Decision: [1999] 152 FLR 142
[1999] 46 IPR 29

New South Wales


Supreme Court

CITATION: THE AUDIO VISUAL COPYRIGHT SOCIETY v AUSTRALIAN RECORD INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION LTD. and ORS. [1999] NSWSC 947
CURRENT JURISDICTION: EQUITY DIVISION
FILE NUMBER(S): 5004/98
HEARING DATE(S): 30 April 1999
JUDGMENT DATE:
17 September 1999

PARTIES :


THE AUDIO VISUAL COPYRIGHT SOCIETY LTD. (PLAINTIFF)
AUSTRALIAN RECORD INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION LIMITED and ORS. (DEFENDANTS)
JUDGMENT OF: Simos J
COUNSEL : N. Manousaridis (Plaintiff)
R.Cobden (First Defendant)
M. Green (Second and Third Defendants)
R.J. Webb (Fourth Defendant)
D.R. Sibtain (Fifth Defendant)
Ms. J.R. Baird (Sixth Defendant)
SOLICITORS: Mallesons Stephen Jaques (Plaintiff)
Gilbert & Tobin (First Defendant)
Faulkner & Associates (Second and Third Defendants)
Gray & Perkins (Fourth Defendant)
Bruce W. Pulsford (Fifth Defendant)
Eakin McCaffery Cox (Sixth Defendant)
CATCHWORDS: COPYRIGHT ACT 1968 (COMMONWEALTH), Part VA - Copying of Transmissions by Educational and Other Institutions -Generally Accepted Mistake of Law as to Entitlement to Royalties of Copyright Owners of Copyright in Sound Recordings Incorporated into the Sound-Track of Cinematograph Films Causing Breaches of Trust by Plaintiff Collecting Society in Distributing Equitable Remuneration to Copyright Owners - No Breach of Trust by Plaintiff Collecting Society in Paying Moneys from Plaintiff's IBNR Fund to Copyright Owners of Copyright in Artistic Works Included in a Cinematograph Film.; TRUSTEE ACT 1925 (NSW), Section 85; Held: Plaintiff Collecting Society Had Acted Honestly and Reasonably and Ought Fairly to be Excused and Wholly Relieved from Liability for Breaches of Trust;
ACTS CITED: Copyright Act 1968 (Commonwealth)
Trustee Act 1925 (NSW)
CASES CITED: Phonographic Performance Company of Australia Ltd. and Ors. v Federation of Australian Commercial Television Stations (1998) 154 ALR 211
DECISION: Plaintiff Collecting Society Entitled To Be Relieved From Liability For Innocent Breaches of Trust.

THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

SIMOS J

FRIDAY, 17 SEPTEMBER 1999

(NO. 5004/98) - THE AUDIO VISUAL COPYRIGHT SOCIETY LTD v AUSTRALIAN RECORD INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION LTD & ORS

JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR:

The Proceedings

1    By Further Amended Summons filed 30 April 1999 the plaintiff claimed certain declarations and orders, including, so far as material, the following:-
          “1 A declaration that, of the remuneration received by the plaintiff pursuant to Part VA of the Copyright Act 1968 (Commonwealth) (“ the Statutory Collection ”) in each of the periods 1 July 1990 - 30 June 1991, 1 July 1991 - 30 June 1992, 1 July 1992 - 30 June 1993, 1 July 1993 - 30 June 1994, 1 July 1994 - 30 June 1995, 1 July 1995 - 30 June 1996 and 1 July 1996 - 30 June 1997 (each of the said periods being referred to as an “ Accounting Period ”):

              (a) the whole was held on trust for the purposes and persons described in Articles 16.2, 16.3 and 16.6, and in conformity with the obligations described in Article 17 of the plaintiff’s Articles of Association, and not otherwise;

              (b) the whole (apart from that expended pursuant to Article 16.2(a) was held on trust…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Audio Visual Copyright Society v Australian Record Indus... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWSC 947
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Audio Visual Copyright Society (AVCA) brought a claim against the Australian Record Industry Association (ARIA) in the Federal Court of Australia, concerning breaches of trust by AVCA in distributing royalties to copyright owners. The dispute centred around whether AVCA, as a collecting society, breached its trust obligations when it distributed royalties derived from cinematograph films to the copyright owners of sound recordings, where AVCA had mistakenly believed it was entitled to do so under the Copyright Act 1968.

The court was required to determine whether AVCA had breached its trust obligations when distributing royalties to copyright owners of sound recordings incorporated into the sound-track of cinematograph films, given AVCA's mistaken belief that it was entitled to do so. The court also had to decide whether AVCA breached its trust obligations when it paid moneys from its IBNR (Incurred But Not Reported) fund to copyright owners of artistic works included in a cinematograph film.

The court found that AVCA had acted honestly and reasonably, and ought fairly to be excused and wholly relieved from liability for the breaches of trust. It held that the mistakes of law made by AVCA in distributing royalties to copyright owners of sound recordings were genuinely held and reasonable, and that there were no circumstances that would justify imposing a penalty on AVCA for those breaches. The court further held that there was no breach of trust in relation to the payment of moneys from AVCA's IBNR fund to copyright owners of artistic works. The court's reasoning was based on the application of the Trustee Act 1925 (NSW) section 85, which provides a defence to trustees who act honestly and reasonably in making a mistake of law.

The court ordered that AVCA be excused and wholly relieved from any liability for the breaches of trust in relation to the distribution of royalties to copyright owners of sound recordings, and that no penalty be imposed on AVCA for those breaches. The court further ordered that AVCA was not in breach of trust in relation to the payment of moneys from its IBNR fund to copyright owners of artistic works.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established