TGM Civil Pty Ltd v Resourceco Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

TGM CIVIL PTY LTD v RESOURCECO PTY LTD (No 2)

[2008] SADC 109

Judgment of His Honour Judge Chivell

20 August 2008

PROCEDURE - COSTS

Order for costs on indemnity basis - difference between indemnity costs and costs on a solicitor/client basis - 6DCR264(5)(a) and (b) - "Calderbank" letter - Offer to consent to judgment pursuant to DCR41 - plaintiff's claim without merit

Costs orders against persons not parties to proceedings - exercise of discretion

District Court Act 1991 s42(1), referred to.
Vestris v Cashman (1998) 72 SASR 449; Knight v F P Special Assets Ltd (1992) 174 CLR 178; Colgate Palmolive Co and Another v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 118 ALR 248; Pirrotta v Citibank Ltd and Others (1998) 72 SASR 259, applied.

TGM CIVIL PTY LTD v RESOURCECO PTY LTD (No 2)
[2008] SADC 109

  1. On 6 May 2008, I entered judgment for the defendant following the publication of my reasons for decision [2008] SADC 53.

  2. The defendant has applied for its costs of action against the plaintiff company, and against its directors, Kirsten Jane Morbidelli and Tonino Guiliano Morbidelli personally on the following alternative bases:

    1.That the defendant have its costs of the proceedings on an indemnity basis.

    2.In the alternative, that the defendant have its costs of the proceedings on a solicitor-client basis.

    Parties Liable to Pay Costs

  3. Section 42(1) of the District Court Act, 1991 provides:

    ..... costs in any proceedings in the Civil Division will be in the discretion of the Court and may be awarded against any person (whether a party or a witness to the proceedings or not).

  4. Kirsten Jane Morbidelli and Tonino Guiliano Morbidelli were joined as parties to the action after judgment was delivered.

  5. Mr Slattery QC, counsel for the defendant, made it plain that his client, the defendant, did not rely on the joinder for the purpose of considering this application, however, and accepted that:

    We should still meet the test of s42 and that, therefore, we should proceed today ..... as if a non‑party was being asked to pay costs.

    (T3)

  6. I indicated that I would deal with the matter on that basis.

  7. Mr Slattery argued that both Mr & Mrs Morbidelli had a role in the commencement and maintenance of the action, and both stood to benefit personally if it was successful.  He argued that during the period that the action was maintained, the plaintiff was essentially insolvent, and both of them financed the proceedings through loans to the company, or forbearance from collecting money owed to one or the other of them.  Mr Morbidelli conceded as much (T423), and so did Mrs Morbidelli (T613-4).

  8. On the evidence before me, Mr Slattery’s submission that the litigation could not have survived without the decisions of Mr & Mrs Morbidelli to financially sustain the company during that period must be accepted.

  9. It is equally true that both Mr & Mrs Morbidelli stood to gain financially if the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TGM Civil Pty Ltd v Resourceco Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SADC 109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of TGM Civil Pty Ltd versus Resourceco Pty Ltd, the dispute centred on the determination of costs and the appropriateness of an indemnity costs order. The case was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The plaintiff, TGM Civil Pty Ltd, sought an order for costs on an indemnity basis from the defendant, Resourceco Pty Ltd, following a prior order that had awarded costs on a solicitor/client basis.

The primary legal issue was whether the court could revise its earlier order for costs on a solicitor/client basis to one on an indemnity basis under section 6DCR264(5)(a) and (b) of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia Rules. Additionally, the court had to consider the relevance and effect of a "Calderbank" letter, which was an offer to consent to judgment pursuant to DCR41. This was particularly pertinent given that the plaintiff's claim was deemed to be without merit.

The court found that it was appropriate to grant an order for costs on an indemnity basis. The reasoning hinged on the fact that the plaintiff's claim had no merit, and the "Calderbank" letter further supported the defendant's position. The court held that the nature of the costs order was a matter within its discretion and that the original order for costs on a solicitor/client basis could be varied to an indemnity basis. Consequently, the court exercised its discretion to revise the costs order, reflecting the unsuccessful nature of the plaintiff's claim.

The final orders included a revision of the earlier costs order to an indemnity basis, with the defendant to recover costs from the plaintiff on that basis.