TGI Friday's Inc v Weller Hotels & Taverns Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Trade Marks Act 1955

Opposition in the name of WELLER HOTELS & TAVERNS PTY LTD to the registration of trade mark application numbers 438363, 438364 and 438365 in the name of TGI FRIDAY'S INC.

Decision of a Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks

Background

These trade mark applications were lodged on 19 December 1985 by TGI Friday's Inc., of 14665 Midway Road, City of Addison, Texas ("the applicant") in respect of the trade mark T.G.I. FRIDAY'S and the following goods and services:

  1. paper, cardboard and goods made from these materials (not included in other classes); printed matter; photographs; stationery; plastic material for packaging (not included in other classes): class 16

  1. clothing, footwear and headgear: class 25

  1. restaurant services and alcoholic beverage bar services: class 42

438363 and 438364 were advertised as accepted for registration in September and 438365 in October 1988.  In March and April of 1989 notices of opposition to the registration of the trade marks were lodged by Weller Hotels & Taverns Pty Ltd, of C/- Lyons, Dunlop & Pratt, MLC Centre, 85 George Street, Brisbane ("the opponent").  The grounds of opposition were the same in each case and as follows:

(a)By reason of the reputation and rights acquired by the opponent, the use of the trade mark by the applicant in relation to the goods [services] in respect of which registration is sought would be misleading or confusing and an infringement of the opponent's rights.

(b)Use or registration of the trade mark by the applicant would be contrary to law or morality and/or contrary to the public interest.

(c)The trade mark would be disentitled to protection in a court of justice.

(d)The applicant is not the proprietor of the trade mark.

(e)The trade mark is not distinctive of the applicant's goods [services].

(f)By reason of the matters set forth in any one or more of the foregoing paragraphs the Registrar in the exercise of his discretion ought to refuse registration of the trade mark.

Evidence

The opponent's evidence in support consists of a statutory declaration by Alan John Weller, a Director of the opponent company, together with Exhibits AJW-1 to AJW-14.

The applicant's evidence in answer to this material consists of a statutory declaration by Daniel T. Cronk, Vice President of the applicant corporation, together with Exhibits I to V.

Hearing

The applicant was represented by Mr Michael Ellicott of Counsel, instructed by Ms Patricia Kennedy, of Spruson & Ferguson, patent attorneys of Sydney.

The opponent was represented by Mr Claude Anese,of Cullen & Co., patent attorneys of Brisbane.

It was agreed by both parties that their submissions would be directed in the main to application 438365 but would apply as appropriate to the other two applications.

Mr Anese noted that the opponent's case would rely essentially on grounds based on the provisions of sections 40, 28 and 33 of the Act.  It is well-established law that in these sorts of proceedings the matters must be determined on the state of facts existing when the applications…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TGI Friday's Inc v Weller Hotels & Taverns Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] ATMO 84
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition by Weller Hotels & Taverns Pty Ltd to three trade mark applications lodged by TGI Friday's Inc. The applications sought registration of the trade mark T.G.I. FRIDAY'S in relation to goods in Class 16 (paper, cardboard, printed matter, stationery), clothing in Class 25, and services in Class 42 (restaurant and alcoholic beverage bar services). The opposition was heard by a Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The opponent based its opposition on several grounds, including claims of misleading or confusing use, infringement of rights, contravention of law or public interest, disentitlement to protection, lack of proprietorship, lack of distinctiveness, and a general submission that the Registrar ought to refuse registration. The opponent primarily relied on grounds under sections 40, 28, and 33 of the relevant Act, asserting that its prior use and reputation in the mark FRIDAYS, and its earlier filed applications for similar marks, should prevent the applicant's registration. The relevant date for assessing these claims was the filing date of the applicant's applications, 19 December 1985.

The Delegate first considered the ground under section 40 concerning proprietorship. The opponent argued it was the proprietor of the FRIDAYS mark due to earlier use, commencing as early as 1982 for planning, 1984 for a bar, and November 1985 for a complex. However, the Delegate found that for proprietorship to arise, the marks must be identical or substantially identical. Comparing the opponent's FRIDAYS mark with the applicant's T.G.I. FRIDAY'S mark, the Delegate concluded that the addition of "T.G.I." constituted a substantial alteration, meaning the marks were not substantially identical. Consequently, the opponent's claim to proprietorship under section 40 was unsuccessful.

Turning to section 33, which concerns deceptive similarity, the Delegate found that while the opponent's mark was not substantially identical to the applicant's, they were deceptively similar. The key issue then became whether the opponent's services, described as "discotheque" in its earlier applications, were of the same description or closely related to the applicant's goods and services. The Delegate determined that the opponent's discotheque services were not closely related to the applicant's Class 16 and 25 goods. However, regarding the applicant's "alcoholic beverage bar services," the Delegate found them to be of the same description as the opponent's discotheque services, as both involve the provision of alcoholic drinks and share similar uses and trade channels. Therefore, the opposition succeeded on this ground to the extent that application 438365 could not be registered for "alcoholic beverage bar services." The opposition was unsuccessful on the ground under section 28, as the Delegate was not satisfied that the opponent had established sufficient reputation by 19 December 1985 to cause deception or confusion. The Delegate ordered that application 438365 could proceed to registration for "restaurant services" if amended appropriately, and applications 438363 and 438364 were free to proceed. The applicant was awarded 80% of its costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established