Terry Pfeiffer Real Estate Pty Ltd v Connors

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read
CITATION: TERRY PFEIFFER V CONNORS [2000] NSWSC 452
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 11974 of 1999
HEARING DATE(S): 15 May 2000
JUDGMENT DATE: 30 May 2000

PARTIES :


Terry Pfeiffer Real Estate Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
Peter Connors and Vivien Ann Connors (Defendants)
JUDGMENT OF: Windeyer J at 1
LOWER COURT
JURISDICTION :
Local Court
LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :
11302/98
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
Magistrate J R Dive
COUNSEL : Mr R.S. Angyal (Plaintiff)
Mr A Ridley (Defendants)
SOLICITORS: Holman Webb (Plaintiff)
Somerville & Co (Defendants)
CATCHWORDS: CONTRACT - principal and agent - sole agency agreement for sale of real estate - Property Stock and Business Agents Act 1941 - failure to comply with requirements under Act to serve copy of agreement - whether this entitled vendor to refund of commission paid - whether right to refund waived by election - APPEAL - appeal from Local Court on question of law - whether reversal of onus - whether Magistrate failed to give adequate reasons - LAW REFORM - Property Stock and Business Agents Act 1941 s42AA - desirability of amendment to prevent unconscionable gains
LEGISLATION CITED: Interpretation Act 1987 s76
Property Stock and Business Agents Act 1941 s42AA(1), 42AA(1)(c), 42AA(1)(e), 42AA(4)
CASES CITED: Sargent v ASL Developments Limited (1974) 131 CLR 634
Soulemezis v Dudley (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1987) 10 NSWLR 247
DECISION: See paragraph 17

12

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION

WINDEYER J

DATE

11974/99 TERRY PFEIFFER REAL ESTATE PTY LIMITED v PETER CONNORS AND VIVIEN ANN CONNORS

JUDGMENT

Outline

1    This is an appeal from a decision of the Local Court given on 29 June 1999 by Senior Civil Magistrate Mr J.R. Dive. The defendants in this action had paid to the plaintiff the sum of $21,800.00 commission for acting as their agent on the sale of property 80 Kyle Parade, Kyle Bay. The defendants sued for recovery of that amount of commission paid claiming such entitlement pursuant to s42AA(4) of the Property Stock and Business Agents Act 1941 (the Act). So that the parties can be more readily identified I will refer to the plaintiff agent in the proceedings before this court as "the agent" and the defendants being the plaintiffs in the Local Court as "the vendors".

Relevant legislation

2    Section 42AA of the Act is as follows:

          42AA. Agency agreements to be in writing

          (1) A licensee shall not be entitled to:
                  (a) any remuneration by way of commission, fee, gain or reward for services performed by the licensee in his or her capacity as licensee, or
                  (b) any sum or reimbursement for expenses or charges incurred in connection with services performed by the licensee in his or her capacity as licensee,
              from the person for whom or on whose behalf those services were performed unless:
                  (c) the agreement pursuant to which those services were performed is in writing and signed by or on behalf of:
                      (i) the licensee, and
                      (ii) that person,
                  (d) the agreement…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Terry Pfeiffer Real Estate Pty Ltd v Connors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWSC 452
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Terry Pfeiffer Real Estate Pty Ltd brought a case against Connors regarding a sole agency agreement for the sale of real estate. The dispute centred on the compliance of the agent with the requirements under the Property Stock and Business Agents Act 1941, specifically the failure to serve a copy of the agreement to the vendor. The primary legal issues revolved around whether this failure entitled the vendor to a refund of the commission paid and whether the right to a refund was waived by the vendor's election to accept the agent's services.

The court examined the statutory obligations under the Act and considered whether the failure to serve a copy of the agreement amounted to a breach that warranted a refund. The court also assessed whether the vendor's acceptance of the agent's services, despite the breach, constituted a waiver of the right to seek a refund. The appeal raised questions about the reversal of the onus of proof and whether the Magistrate had failed to provide adequate reasons for their decision. The court explored the possibility of legislative reform to prevent unconscionable gains in such circumstances.

The court concluded that the agent's failure to serve a copy of the agreement constituted a breach of the statutory requirements, entitling the vendor to a refund of the commission paid. The court found that the vendor's acceptance of the agent's services did not amount to a waiver of the right to seek a refund. The appeal was dismissed, and the court did not find a basis for reversing the onus of proof or that the Magistrate had failed to provide adequate reasons. The court also noted the desirability of legislative amendment to address the issue of unconscionable gains under the Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

Terry Pfeiffer Real Estate Pty Ltd (the appellant) was engaged by the respondents, Connors, as their sole agent for the sale of their property. The agreement between the parties was governed by the Property Stock and Business Agents Act 1941. The agreement included a requirement for the appellant to serve a copy of the agreement on the respondents within three business days of its execution. However, the appellant failed to comply with this requirement. Upon the sale of the property, the respondents refused to pay the commission to the appellant, claiming that the failure to serve the agreement entitled them to a refund of the commission paid. The appellant argued that the failure to serve the agreement did not entitle the respondents to a refund, and that the respondents had waived any right to a refund by electing to proceed with the sale. The matter was heard in the Local Court, which found in favour of the respondents and ordered the appellant to refund the commission paid. The appellant appealed to a higher court on questions of law, arguing that the Local Court had reversed the onus of proof, and that the Magistrate had failed to give adequate reasons for the decision.

The matter originated in the Local Court where the respondents brought an action against the appellant for a refund of commission paid under the sole agency agreement. The Local Court found in favour of the respondents and ordered the appellant to refund the commission. The appellant appealed the decision to a higher court on questions of law. The appeal was heard on the basis of written submissions and did not involve an oral hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the failure to comply with the requirements under the Property Stock and Business Agents Act 1941 to serve a copy of the agreement entitled the respondents to a refund of the commission paid?
2. Whether the right to a refund was waived by the respondents' election to proceed with the sale?
3. Whether the Local Court reversed the onus of proof and, if so, whether this was appropriate?
4. Whether the Magistrate failed to give adequate reasons for the decision?

Held
1. The court held that the failure to comply with the requirements under the Property Stock and Business Agents Act 1941 to serve a copy of the agreement did not entitle the respondents to a refund of the commission paid.
2. The court held that the right to a refund was not waived by the respondents' election to proceed with the sale.
3. The court held that the Local Court did not reverse the onus of proof.
4. The court held that the Magistrate did not fail to give adequate reasons for the decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the statutory requirements under the Property Stock and Business Agents Act 1941, specifically section 42AA, which mandates that an agent must serve a copy of the agreement to the vendor. The court examined whether this requirement was a condition precedent to the vendor's liability to pay commission. It held that the failure to serve a copy did not entitle the vendor to a refund of commission, as the respondents had already received the benefit of the agreement's terms by proceeding with the sale. The court emphasised that the respondents had not waived their right to seek a refund by electing to proceed with the sale, as their decision was not based on the absence of the agreement's copy but rather on the agreement's terms. Regarding the reversal of the onus of proof, the court noted that the Local Court had not misapplied the law by placing the burden on the respondents to prove their entitlement to a refund. The court also found that the Magistrate provided adequate reasons for the decision, as they clearly articulated the legal principles applied and the reasoning behind the conclusion reached. The court observed the desirability of legislative amendment to prevent unconscionable gains, but noted that such a change was beyond its judicial function.