FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Territory Realty Pty Ltd v Garraway (No 2) [2009] FCA 739
TERRITORY REALTY PTY LTD (ACN 009 644 339), DAVID JOHN BOOTH and JOHN DAVID SANDERS v ALLAN CHARLES GARRAWAY, HERBERT THOMAS HASSALL, ROBERT GEORGE KENDRAY, H & K EARTHMOVING PTY LTD (ACN 009 624 202), EXCESS PTY LTD (ACN 009 608 217), BISHOP ESTATE PTY LTD (ACN 070 455 837) and DUNDEE BEACH PTY LTD (ACN 009 631 136)
NTD 10 of 2007
MANSFIELD J
10 JULY 2009
ADELAIDE
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NORTHERN TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
NTD 10 of 2007
BETWEEN: TERRITORY REALTY PTY LTD (ACN 009 644 339)
First ApplicantDAVID JOHN BOOTH
Second ApplicantJOHN DAVID SANDERS
Third Applicant
AND: ALLAN CHARLES GARRAWAY
First RespondentHERBERT THOMAS HASSALL
Second RespondentROBERT GEORGE KENDRAY
Third RespondentH & K EARTHMOVING PTY LTD (ACN 009 624 202)
Fourth RespondentEXCESS PTY LTD (ACN 009 608 217)
Fifth RespondentBISHOP ESTATE PTY LTD (ACN 070 455 837)
Sixth RespondentDUNDEE BEACH PTY LTD (ACN 009 631 136)
Seventh Respondent
JUDGE:
MANSFIELD J
DATE OF ORDER:
10 JULY 2009
WHERE MADE:
ADELAIDE
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The first, fifth and sixth respondents pay to the applicants 50% of their costs of the proceedings to be taxed.
2.In the event that the first, fifth and sixth respondents do not pay to the applicants the costs ordered in Order 1 hereof, the applicants have liberty to apply to the intent that they may renew their application for costs as against the second, fourth and seventh respondents, or one or more of those respondents.
3.The first, fifth and sixth respondents have liberty to apply within 28 days to seek contribution from the second, fourth and seventh respondents, or one or more of those respondents to the costs ordered in Order 1 hereof.
Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NORTHERN TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
NTD 10 of 2007
BETWEEN: TERRITORY REALTY PTY LTD (ACN 009 644 339)
First ApplicantDAVID JOHN BOOTH
Second ApplicantJOHN DAVID SANDERS
Third Applicant
AND: ALLAN CHARLES GARRAWAY
First RespondentHERBERT THOMAS HASSALL
Second RespondentROBERT GEORGE KENDRAY
Third RespondentH & K EARTHMOVING PTY LTD (ACN 009 624 202)
Fourth RespondentEXCESS PTY LTD (ACN 009 608 217)
Fifth RespondentBISHOP ESTATE PTY LTD (ACN 070 455 837)
Sixth RespondentDUNDEE BEACH PTY LTD (ACN 009 631 136)
Seventh Respondent
JUDGE:
MANSFIELD J
DATE:
10 JULY 2009
PLACE:
ADELAIDE
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
INTRODUCTION
On 1 April 2009 I published reasons for judgment in this matter: Territory Realty Pty Ltd v Garraway [2009] FCA 292 (the primary judgment). On 6 May 2009 I made orders giving effect to those reasons. The only issue that remains to be dealt with is the costs of the proceeding. That is the subject of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Territory Realty Pty Ltd v Garraway (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] FCA 739
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court had to address included the appropriateness of the evidence presented concerning the share transfers, the original share structure of Territory Realty, and the evolution of the Dundee Beach development. The court needed to determine whether the evidence and submissions relating to claims on which Territory Realty, Booth, and Sanders were unsuccessful were necessary to the ultimate orders made. The court also had to consider the valuation of Dundee Beach P/L's assets, which was a contested issue pertinent to the relief for oppressive conduct.
In its judgment, the court found that the analysis suggesting only the successful claims' evidence and submissions were necessary was inappropriate. The court concluded that it was appropriate to lead evidence about the original share structure, the dealings between Territory Realty and Garraway, and the Dundee Beach development to inform the significance of the offer to acquire Territory Realty's shares and the valuation of Dundee Beach P/L's assets. The court did not accept the contention that the evidence and submissions related to unsuccessful claims were entirely unnecessary.
The court ordered that the first, fifth, and sixth respondents pay 50% of the applicants' costs of the proceedings, with provisions for the applicants to apply for costs against other respondents if the initial respondents did not pay. Additionally, the first, fifth, and sixth respondents were granted liberty to seek contribution from the second, fourth, and seventh respondents to the costs ordered.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The first, fifth and sixth respondents pay to the applicants 50% of their costs of the proceedings to be taxed.
2. In the event that the first, fifth and sixth respondents do not pay to the applicants the costs ordered in Order 1 hereof, the applicants have liberty to apply to the intent that they may renew their application for costs as against the second, fourth and seventh respondents, or one or more of those respondents.
3. The first, fifth and sixth respondents have liberty to apply within 28 days to seek contribution from the second, fourth and seventh respondents, or one or more of those respondents to the costs ordered in Order 1 hereof.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MANSFIELD J
Territory Realty, Booth and Sanders submitted that the entire proceeding turned on the 4 May 1999 share transfer, and that the findings concerning the events of May 1999 were compounded by what they submitted was an “egregious failure and refusal” to make a fair and reasonable offer to purchase the interest of Territory Realty in Dundee Beach P/L. They submitted that the nature of an oppression claim, in the present circumstances, left Territory Realty as the minority shareholder with “no alternative but to capitulate or to litigate”, a dilemma which they submitted:… is only compounded by the fact that the majority has control of the company’s resources and is thereby in a position not only to starve the minority of the funds needed to litigate but also to access the minority’s investment (as well as its own) in the company to resist any litigation.CONSIDERATION In my judgment, this is an appropriate matter to reflect in a general way the extent to which the respective parties succeeded on particular issues. There were, as the above summary illustrates, a range of discrete issues which were required to be addressed. It was a matter for Territory Realty, Booth and Sanders as to whether they chose to make and maintain the allegations in relation to each of them. It does not follow that the failure to secure relief adverse to any of the respondents in relation to or arising out of the 4 May 1999 share transfers, or the 2003 share transfers or the 2004 share transfers, means that those matters were not properly the subject of evidence. It was appropriate to lead evidence about the original share structure of Territory Realty, and how it came about that by about mid 2004 Excess and Bishop Estate came to be equal shareholders, together in effect holding two thirds of the issued shares in Dundee Beach P/L. It was also appropriate to lead evidence about the dealings between Territory Realty and Garraway (on behalf of Excess and Bishop Estate) prior to the 2007 share issue and the ultimate offer to acquire the shares of Territory Realty in Dundee Beach P/L, and about the evolution of the Dundee Beach development and its particular features and prospects, to inform the significance of that offer. It was also appropriate to lead evidence about the evolution of the Dundee Beach development and its particular features and prospects to provide the foundation for the valuation of the assets of Dundee Beach P/L, as that also was a relevant – and contested – issue once it became appropriate to address the relief to be granted for oppressive conduct. Consequently, I do not accept that the analysis on behalf of Excess, Bishop Estate and Garraway reveals with the clarity for which they contend the extent to which the evidence and submissions related to claims on which Territory Realty, Booth and Sanders were unsuccessful. The “default” analysis, that is the identification of the evidence and submissions specifically relating to the claims on which they were successful and the assumption that all else was quite unnecessary to the orders ultimately made, is one that I do not accept as appropriate.