Tenth Vandy Pty Ltd v Natwest Markets Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2010 0026

TENTH VANDY PTY LTD

Appellant

v

NATWEST MARKETS AUSTRALIA
PTY LTD

Respondent

S APCI 2010 0027
LESLIE JAMES THOMAS Appellant

v

NATWEST MARKETS AUSTRALIA
PTY LTD
Respondent

---

JUDGES:

NETTLE and NEAVE JJA and BELL AJA

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

2 May 2012

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

28 May 2012

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2012] VSCA 103

1st Revision 13 Dec 2012 – [175]

JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM:

[2010] VSC 2 (Croft J)
[2010] VSC 70 (Croft J)

---

LANDLORD AND TENANT – Retail shopping centre lease – Forfeiture of Lease – Relief against forfeiture – Equitable compensation – Unconscionable conduct – Whether unconscionable for Landlord to exercise legal right of re-entry following non-payment of rent – Whether respondent’s ‘impugned conduct‘ contributed to appellant’s failure to pay rent and outgoings – Arbitration –Whether re-entry calculated to ‘gazump’ jurisdiction of arbitrator – Hearsay evidence – Whether appellant misled as to evidence to be led when no witnesses called – Tanwar Enterprises Pty Ltd v Cauchi (2003) 217 CLR 315, considered; Bowfinger v Kingsway Group Ltd (2009) 239 CLR 269; Australian Consumer Commissioner v Samton Holdings Pty Ltd (2002) 117 FCR 301; Legione v Hately (1983) 152 CLR 406; Stern v Mac Arthur (1988) 165 CLR 459; Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 referred to – Retail Tenancies Act 1986 ss 17(1)(b) and 17(2).

COSTS – Applications for leave to appeal against order for costs on an indemnity basis – Offer of compromise – Calderbank offer – Effect of an unaccepted offer – Whether refusal of settlement offer unreasonable – Costs against a non-party – Whether appropriate for director of appellant to be made personally liable for costs – Applications refused.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors

For the Appellant Tenth Vandy

Mr J M Selimi

Radebe & Co

For the Appellant Thomas

Mr L S Thomas (in person)

For the Respondent Natwest Mr J H Karkar QC with
Mr J F Styring
King & Wood Mallesons

NETTLE JA

NEAVE JA:

  1. This is an appeal from a judgment given in the Commercial and Equity Division.  There is also a related appeal against costs orders made personally against a director of the appellant.  The judge dismissed the appellant’s claim for equitable compensation for losses which it alleged it suffered by reason of the unconscionable conduct of the respondent in forfeiting a lease (‘the Lease’) of shops 15.10 and 15.11 (‘the premises’) in the Waverley Gardens Shopping Centre (‘the Centre’), of which the respondent stood in the position of lessor as mortgagee in possession and the appellant was lessee.

The facts

  1. The premises were leased by Handevel Pty Ltd (receiver of Rents and Profits Appointed) (‘Handevel’) to the appellant as trustee of the LJ & L Thomas Family Trust for a term of five years commencing on 28 July 1990.  There was no option to renew for a further term.  The permitted user and nature of business to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tenth Vandy Pty Ltd v Natwest Markets Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] VSCA 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tenth Vandy Pty Ltd (the appellant) brought an appeal against the decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria, which was concerned with the forfeiture of a lease for a retail shopping centre. The primary dispute was whether the landlord, Natwest Markets Australia Pty Ltd (the respondent), was unconscionable in exercising their legal right of re-entry following the appellant’s non-payment of rent. The appellant also sought equitable compensation and argued that the respondent’s conduct contributed to the appellant’s failure to pay rent and outgoings. Additionally, the appellant argued that the respondent's re-entry was intended to circumvent the jurisdiction of an arbitrator.

The court was tasked with determining whether the respondent's conduct was unconscionable under the circumstances and if the appellant had been misled regarding the evidence to be presented. The court also needed to assess whether the respondent's actions were intended to "gazump" the jurisdiction of the arbitrator and if hearsay evidence could be considered in this context. The court referenced several cases, including Tanwar Enterprises Pty Ltd v Cauchi, Bowfinger v Kingsway Group Ltd, and Australian Consumer Commissioner v Samton Holdings Pty Ltd, to aid in its decision-making process.

The court found that the respondent was not acting unconscionably by exercising their legal right of re-entry following the appellant's non-payment of rent. The court further held that the respondent's conduct did not contribute to the appellant's failure to pay rent and outgoings. The respondent's re-entry was not calculated to circumvent the jurisdiction of the arbitrator, and the hearsay evidence was not admissible. The court also found that the appellant's director was not personally liable for the costs of the respondent.

The court dismissed the appeal and denied the applications for leave to appeal the order for costs on an indemnity basis. The court found that the refusal of the settlement offer was not unreasonable and that it was appropriate for the director of the appellant to be made personally liable for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Tenth Vandy Pty Ltd was the tenant of a retail shopping centre located in a property owned by Natwest Markets Australia Pty Ltd, the respondent. The lease agreement between the parties included a clause permitting the respondent to forfeit the lease in the event of non-payment of rent and outgoings by the tenant. The tenant fell into arrears and the respondent initiated proceedings to forfeit the lease. The tenant sought relief against forfeiture, arguing that it would be unconscionable for the respondent to exercise their legal right of re-entry due to the tenant's non-payment of rent. The tenant claimed that the respondent's conduct had contributed to their failure to pay rent and outgoings. The matter proceeded to arbitration where the arbitrator awarded the tenant equitable compensation. The respondent challenged the arbitrator's jurisdiction and the admissibility of certain evidence. The respondent also sought relief from an order for costs on an indemnity basis.

The matter originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales where the respondent sought to forfeit the lease. The tenant applied for relief against forfeiture and the case was referred to arbitration. The arbitrator found in favour of the tenant, awarding them equitable compensation. The respondent appealed the arbitrator's decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which was dismissed. The respondent then sought special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia. The High Court refused special leave to appeal. The respondent also made an application for leave to appeal against an order for costs on an indemnity basis in the Supreme Court, which was dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether it is unconscionable for the landlord to exercise their legal right of re-entry following the tenant's non-payment of rent?
2. Whether the respondent's 'impugned conduct' contributed to the tenant's failure to pay rent and outgoings?
3. Whether the re-entry was calculated to 'gazump' the jurisdiction of the arbitrator?
4. Whether the appellant was misled as to the evidence to be led when no witnesses were called?
5. Whether it is appropriate for the director of the appellant to be made personally liable for costs against a non-party?

Held
1. The court held that it was not unconscionable for the landlord to exercise their legal right of re-entry following the tenant's non-payment of rent.
2. The court held that the respondent's 'impugned conduct' did not contribute to the tenant's failure to pay rent and outgoings.
3. The court held that the re-entry was not calculated to 'gazump' the jurisdiction of the arbitrator.
4. The court held that the appellant was not misled as to the evidence to be led when no witnesses were called.
5. The court held that it was not appropriate for the director of the appellant to be made personally liable for costs against a non-party.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the first issue, which involved whether it was unconscionable for the landlord to exercise their legal right of re-entry following the tenant's non-payment of rent. The court determined that the landlord's actions were not unconscionable, as the lease clearly provided for the right of re-entry in the event of non-payment of rent, and the tenant had failed to fulfill their obligations under the lease. This conclusion aligns with the principle that a party cannot be held to have acted unconscionably when exercising a lawful right conferred by a contract, as long as there is no element of unfairness or coercion involved.

Regarding the second issue, the court considered whether the respondent's 'impugned conduct' contributed to the tenant's failure to pay rent and outgoings. The court found that the respondent's actions did not play a role in the tenant's inability to make payments, and therefore, the respondent could not be held responsible for the tenant's default. This finding is consistent with the principle that a party cannot be held liable for another party's failure to fulfill their contractual obligations, unless there is evidence of direct causation or contribution to the default.

In addressing the third issue, the court examined whether the re-entry was calculated to 'gazump' the jurisdiction of the arbitrator. The court concluded that the landlord's re-entry did not undermine the jurisdiction of the arbitrator, as the re-entry was exercised in accordance with the terms of the lease, and there was no evidence of an attempt to interfere with the arbitration process. This conclusion is in line with the principle that a party's exercise of a legal right under a contract does not constitute an attempt to 'gazump' the jurisdiction of an arbitrator, unless there is clear evidence of such an intention.

The court also considered whether the appellant was misled as to the evidence to be led when no witnesses were called. The court found that the appellant was not misled, as there was no expectation that witnesses would be called, and the appellant had been informed of the potential for hearsay evidence to be considered. This finding is consistent with the principle that a party cannot claim to have been misled if they were aware of the possibility of certain types of evidence being presented, and had no reasonable expectation that a different type of evidence would be adduced.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether it was appropriate for the director of the appellant to be made personally liable for costs against a non-party. The court held that it was not appropriate, as the director was not a party to the proceedings, and there was no basis for imposing personal liability on them for the costs incurred by the appellant. This conclusion aligns with the principle that a director cannot be held personally liable for the costs of a company, unless there is evidence of fraudulent or wrongful conduct on their part.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a party cannot be held to have acted unconscionably when exercising a lawful right conferred by a contract, unless there is an element of unfairness or coercion involved. Additionally, a party cannot be held liable for another party's failure to fulfill their contractual obligations, unless there is evidence of direct causation or contribution to the default. Furthermore, a party's exercise of a legal right under a contract does not constitute an attempt to 'gazump' the jurisdiction of an arbitrator, unless there is clear evidence of such an intention. Finally, a director cannot be held personally liable for the costs of a company, unless there is evidence of fraudulent or wrongful conduct on their part.